So, we should be ignoring NICE after all?

AndBreathe

Master
Retired Moderator
Messages
11,320
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
The following was published today on GP Online, so I thought I'd copy it into here.

The following article was published today on GP Online. Interesting...........

GPs and patients must choose when to ignore NICE advice, says Haslam

By David Millett on the 13 October 2015 Be the First to Comment


NICE guidance 'may not be appropriate' for every patient, and it is important that GPs talk through treatment options with patients, NICE chairman Professor David Haslam has said.

Speaking at the NICE annual conference in Liverpool on Tuesday, Professor Haslam told delegates that although NICE guidance represents the ‘gold standard’ of treatment, it is not meant to be prescriptive and should not replace a doctor’s clinical judgment.

He said the health and social care system in the UK had changed ‘significantly’ since NICE was founded in 1999. Doctors of today are facing new challenges as multimorbidity and long-term conditions become rife in the population, he said.

NICE will play a pivotal role in helping doctors tackle these issues, with new guidance on multimorbidity due next year.

Professor Haslam said: ‘NICE guidelines give a population-level steer on what the most clinically and cost-effective ways are to treat different diseases and conditions. Nationally, the guidance helps the NHS make sure that it’s getting the best value for taxpayers’ money.

NICE GP guidance

‘But it is essential to remember that on an individual level, our recommendations might not always be appropriate for individual patients. The guidance is not intended to replace a doctor’s clinical judgment or the joint decisions they make with their patients about their specific and individual needs.

‘Our job at NICE is to ensure clinicians and social care professionals are supported to give the very best care to people.

‘Equally we understand that each discussion between a patient and their clinician is unique.

‘NICE guidance is a gold-standard which professionals should take very seriously. But the role of the clinician is to interpret our guidance together with their training and experience in the interests of the patient before them.’

The article url is: http://www.gponline.com/gps-patients-choose-when-ignore-nice-advice-says-haslam/article/1368070
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 people

satindoll

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,083
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Insulin
@AndBreathe

Thank you for posting this, very interesting, it may be worth my printing it off and taking to show the Dr if and when they get stroppy and pointing out to them the last 4 paras.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people

Blackers183

Well-Known Member
Messages
164
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Commercial television
I think allowing GPs a get out clause disadvantages a lot of T1s. I'd like to to know how many T1s really should be treated differently from the NICE guideline and what % of the T1 population do they represent? I'd put money on them being a minority.
 

AndBreathe

Master
Retired Moderator
Messages
11,320
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
I think allowing GPs a get out clause disadvantages a lot of T1s. I'd like to to know how many T1s really should be treated differently from the NICE guideline and what % of the T1 population do they represent? I'd put money on them being a minority.

Hello there.

I'm unsure I really understand your post. Do you mean that only a minority of T1s would benefit from their GPs treating them outside NICE guideline?

There's no judgement in me asking my question. I just not sure I see which way you feel.
 

SunnyExpat

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,230
Type of diabetes
Prefer not to say
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
You can lead a horse to water......

Offer the gold standard.
If the patient rejects it, let them get on with it their way.
Don't get involved in a futile argument.
Just make a note you offered the gold standard, and the patient refused it.

But, as @Blackers183 says, if there is an even cheaper way.......
Maybe that's another more cost effective answer.
 

xAoifex

Well-Known Member
Messages
199
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Pump
NICE guidelines are just that, GUIDELINES. There is no one shoe fits all with any disease or condition (would be a lot simpler all round there was) guidelines and recommendations will not fit everybody's needs and HCP (and patients) need to realise that although it can work in our favour when NICE recommend something the docs aren't keen on! NICE aren't a group of magicians, those who write the guidelines tend to be experts in their area working off best available research and practice. It's not infallible and new research is going on all the time. It also needs to ensure treatments are cost effective and able to reach the largest amount of people. Its this last point that annoys me as I feel often NICE doesn't look at the future picture, eg pumps and CGMs are a lot more expensive short term than MDI however if it reduces complications in the future and enables us to avoid expensive complications and treatment of these for and be a tax paying productive member of society for longer then is it still so expensive?
(rant over!)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people

Blackers183

Well-Known Member
Messages
164
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Commercial television
Hello there.

I'm unsure I really understand your post. Do you mean that only a minority of T1s would benefit from their GPs treating them outside NICE guideline?

There's no judgement in me asking my question. I just not sure I see which way you feel.

I feel that only a small number of T1s might actually require treatment outside what NICE recommends. 'Allowing' GPs to vary treatment outside the guideline introduces inconsistencies to T1s treatment resulting in a lot of T1s not getting the treatment which results in better outcomes, eg lower HBA1C, less hypos, etc.
I have been a T1 for 24 years and every GP and specialist I have had had different ways of treating and explaining the treatment to me. Yes I have always had the target of lowering my BGL but 'how' was always the question with which I could not get (in my mind) a consistent answer. Fortunately I do have it I do have it know after attending DAFNE program, mentioned in the guidelines, 12 months ago.
David
 

ButtterflyLady

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,291
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
Dislikes
Acceptance of health treatment claims that are not adequately supported by evidence. I dislike it when people sell ineffective and even harmful alternative health products to exploit the desperation of people with chronic illness.
The following was published today on GP Online, so I thought I'd copy it into here.

The following article was published today on GP Online. Interesting...........

GPs and patients must choose when to ignore NICE advice, says Haslam

By David Millett on the 13 October 2015 Be the First to Comment


NICE guidance 'may not be appropriate' for every patient, and it is important that GPs talk through treatment options with patients, NICE chairman Professor David Haslam has said.

Speaking at the NICE annual conference in Liverpool on Tuesday, Professor Haslam told delegates that although NICE guidance represents the ‘gold standard’ of treatment, it is not meant to be prescriptive and should not replace a doctor’s clinical judgment.

He said the health and social care system in the UK had changed ‘significantly’ since NICE was founded in 1999. Doctors of today are facing new challenges as multimorbidity and long-term conditions become rife in the population, he said.

NICE will play a pivotal role in helping doctors tackle these issues, with new guidance on multimorbidity due next year.

Professor Haslam said: ‘NICE guidelines give a population-level steer on what the most clinically and cost-effective ways are to treat different diseases and conditions. Nationally, the guidance helps the NHS make sure that it’s getting the best value for taxpayers’ money.

NICE GP guidance

‘But it is essential to remember that on an individual level, our recommendations might not always be appropriate for individual patients. The guidance is not intended to replace a doctor’s clinical judgment or the joint decisions they make with their patients about their specific and individual needs.

‘Our job at NICE is to ensure clinicians and social care professionals are supported to give the very best care to people.

‘Equally we understand that each discussion between a patient and their clinician is unique.

‘NICE guidance is a gold-standard which professionals should take very seriously. But the role of the clinician is to interpret our guidance together with their training and experience in the interests of the patient before them.’

The article url is: http://www.gponline.com/gps-patients-choose-when-ignore-nice-advice-says-haslam/article/1368070
Sounds perfectly reasonable to me. I think doctors are trained in medical school to take this approach, ie use their knowledge, the guidelines, research, and the patient's circumstances and wishes to recommend a course of action.
 

Brunneria

Guru
Retired Moderator
Messages
21,889
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
From my experience, I haven't seen much signs of my doc following the NICE guidelines up until now - so I expect he will just carry on as normal.
 

AndBreathe

Master
Retired Moderator
Messages
11,320
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
I feel that only a small number of T1s might actually require treatment outside what NICE recommends. 'Allowing' GPs to vary treatment outside the guideline introduces inconsistencies to T1s treatment resulting in a lot of T1s not getting the treatment which results in better outcomes, eg lower HBA1C, less hypos, etc.
I have been a T1 for 24 years and every GP and specialist I have had had different ways of treating and explaining the treatment to me. Yes I have always had the target of lowering my BGL but 'how' was always the question with which I could not get (in my mind) a consistent answer. Fortunately I do have it I do have it know after attending DAFNE program, mentioned in the guidelines, 12 months ago.
David

Thanks for clarifying.