I like red whale. Easy to read and understand.
I took a copy of the red whale suggested tx to my gp when I was requesting additional help with my hypothyroidism. They both refused to even look at it. However, I did get a referral to an endo. Some gps will just stick with whatever they were taught years ago. And most certainly do not like patients knowing stuff.
My next comments relate to t2d.
A question? Does the "tight control" mentioned refer only to tight medical control ie drugs, and not tight control by lifestyle? I did not see a difference drawn between the two. I now have fairly tight control, and take metformin.( although I did forget it for a couple of weeks and my bgl remained the same). My question is about the method to achieve good control. If it makes no.difference, and indeed makes for worse outcomes then what is the point?
I believe I remember looking at the study quite some time ago (was it the ACCORD study?) and tight control was achieved by using medication rather than diet. I also agree with
@Bluetit1802 that one of the reasons advanced for increased more mortality was a higher incidence of hypos with tighter control.
Btw, here is the link to the study:
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa0802743
However, might it not also be possible that the reason tight control involving medication (especially insulin and drugs increasing insulin production in the pancreas) may lead to higher circulating insulin levels (especially in already insulin-resistant people), which in turn lead to a number of adverse consequences.
Do we really know which diabetic complications are due to high blood sugar levels and which are due to high insulin levels?
Has anyone seen any studies about this?
Personally, I don't believe that tightly controlling blood sugar levels through diet (and/or exercise) will carry much risk -- especially given the additional benefits that almost all of us experience, such as lower blood pressure, lower triglicerides and higher HDL.
Edited to provide information on and link to the ACCORD study.