Pros and Cons of Insulin Pumps

It is useful to weigh up the pros and cons of insulin pump therapy
It is useful to weigh up the pros and cons of insulin pump therapy

Insulin pumps have become very sought after by people with diabetes, particularly people with type 1 diabetes as they have a number of key benefits over injections, including allowing greater control over diabetes.

Insulin pumps are not for everyone though and there are a number of disadvantages which need to be taken into account when deciding whether a pump will be right for you.

Advantages of insulin pumps

Insulin pumps have a number of features which allow people to take firmer control over their diabetes as well as improving quality of life for those that have struggled on multiple daily injections.

Less jabs

Insulin pumps require a catheter to be implanted every 2 or 3 days, which can be more involved than single injections but the benefit is that you have to do this much less often than the number of times you’d need to inject. It also means you don’t need to associate every meal with a needle.

Take insulin as and when you need it

Because the cannula stays implanted, it is easier and painless to take additional insulin as and when it is needed. No need to go through the injection process, just press a few buttons and you’re done.

Have different basal rates at different times of day

A big advantage of an insulin pump is that you can set your pump to deliver different rates of background insulin at different times of day. So, if you’re having night time hypos, but are fine during the day, with a pump you can adjust your night time basal and keep your daytime basal dose the same. It may also give more control in beating dawn phenomenon.

Flexibility with food

Because delivering insulin is less hassle on a pump, you therefore have more flexibility around meal times. Say you decide you want to have a dessert after all, you can go ahead without having to decide whether it’s worth the extra jab.

Flexibility with exercise

If you decide to go dancing or have an active kick around, you can instantly lower your basal dose so you can minimise the chances of going hypo as a result of the exercise. On injections, if you decide to take part in exercise that you haven’t planned for, your only choice is to take on board carbohydrate and then make sure you do the right amount of exercise to balance the carbohydrate you’ve taken.

Increased blood glucose control

All this extra flexibility adds up to mean a better chance of controlling blood sugar levels and research shows that insulin pump therapy is generally linked with better blood glucose numbers.

NICE reviewed 18 adult and mixed age group studies and in each study, insulin pump therapy showed reduced Hba1c values. In studies of teenagers and children, 20 out of 23 studies showed an improvement in HbA1c results as a result of starting insulin pump therapy.[88]

Reducing episodes of severe hypoglycaemia

Possibly because insulin pumps require less need to plan hours into the future than with injections, pumps are also linked with a lower risk of having a severe hypo.

NICE reviewed 10 studies looking at adult and mixed age groups and found 80% of these studies showed reduced incidence of severe hypoglycemia associated with CSII. Out of 11 studies of teenagers and children, all had reduced incidence of severe hypoglycemia. [88]

Reduced risk of complications

This one follows straight on from having improved diabetes control but is well worth a mention as a lower HbA1c has been shown to equate to a lower risk of developing long term diabetes complications

Disadvantages of insulin pumps

Whilst there‘s a wealth of benefits in being on a pump, there are some disadvantages which may also apply.

Difficulties getting a pump on the NHS

In some cases, getting a pump on the NHS can be straight forward and you may not have difficulty applying. However, it is not unusual for the application process for a pump to be drawn out and it can be an emotional rollercoaster for some whilst applying and waiting to see whether you meet the requirements.

Cost: if you need to buy the pump yourself

If you don’t get approved for a pump on the NHS then you have the option to fully fund the pump yourself. As pumps and the necessary supplies are not cheap, this will involve significant outlay of money.

Steep learning curve

There is undoubtedly a lot to take in with moving onto an insulin pump and the first few weeks can represent a steep learning curve as you get used to changing infusion sets, getting your basal rates set and learning to avoid problems such as bubbles.

Frequent blood glucose testing required

Whilst pumps give you increased opportunity to take control of your diabetes, generally speaking, this does require frequent blood glucose testing of at least 4 times a day. It’s worth noting that attaining better control on multiple daily injections will most likely require frequent testing too.

Changing infusion sets more difficult than single injections

Infusion sets only usually need changing every 2 or 3 days but the down side is that changing infusion sites is a more involved and longer process than taking a single injection. Read more on changing infusion sets. Link to infusion sets page

Risk of diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA)

Whilst insulin pumps are generally associated with improved diabetes control, if problems such as getting air in tubing or having a blocked cannula develop, you may not get enough insulin delivered which could lead to ketone levels rising and an increased risk of suffering ketoacidosis.

Skin infections

Because insulin pumps involve having a catheter implanted under the skin for a number of days, there is a risk that skin infections can occur. As long as correct procedures are followed, skin infections should be rare but they can be unpleasant and could be dangerous if they do happen.

Tubing of insulin pumps getting caught on objects

This is an unfortunate down side of insulin pump, particularly if you use longer lengths of tubing. Catching the tubing of your pump on handles and other objects can happen from time to time and, yes, it does usually hurt and can leave your infusion site quite sore for a while. Note that the OmniPod from Ypsomed avoids this problem by not needing tubing.

Explore Insulin Pumps