NHS Dietitian Contradicting Himself

lucylocket61

Expert
Messages
6,435
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Medical practitioners are paid to do a job. I take advice from a bank advisor who may not have a mortgage himself. He is trained and paid to advice. Same with the medical world. hey do not have the freedom to go their own path, they would lose their jobs if they did so.

Lets not have a go at people who are doing their job.
 

david1241

Well-Known Member
Messages
62
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
doctors and dentists.I would not be rude to any.Also i don't like being taken for granted.
Absolutely. I am sure that's why they slashed the threshold of the Q Risk score from 20 to 10 just to have an excuse to put thousands more on statins etc.
The last doctor i saw ,about 3 years ago got nasty when i refused to take statins.Then the chief doctor reprimanded me for not taking stains and aspirin.I said take a fish oil tablets and a garlic tablet every day .He never said anymore
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sue192

lucylocket61

Expert
Messages
6,435
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
He is trained and paid to sell you something...a bank advisor will be promoting the products his organisation is trying to sell that week. That is his job.
I should have realized you would take my words to the literal end.

: )
 

david1241

Well-Known Member
Messages
62
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
doctors and dentists.I would not be rude to any.Also i don't like being taken for granted.
Medical practitioners are paid to do a job. I take advice from a bank advisor who may not have a mortgage himself. He is trained and paid to advice. Same with the medical world. hey do not have the freedom to go their own path, they would lose their jobs if they did so.

Lets not have a go at people who are doing their job.
Yes but some doctors don't do their jobs properly.In fact once you reach 65 retirement age they could not careless.I've heard of yourger people receiving bad treatment .Before i retired i received excellent treatment from the N.H.S.But it has all gone down the pan as far as i'm concerned.
 

lovinglife

Moderator
Staff Member
Messages
4,578
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
I'm still "fat" - if you didn't know my history or anything about me you would probably look at me and think "fat cow she must stuff her face - needs to lose weight, cheek of her telling me to lose weight or giving any advice on my way of eating.

Ask me about myself and find out about the person I am behind the "fat" - I will tell you I'm almost 12st lighter and 8 dress sizes smaller since the start of my journey - I'm still on my journey but you'd only know that if you took an interest before you judged me. I don't judge anyone on their size - I don't know where they are on their journey or how difficult that has been.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jjraak and Guzzler

Bluetit1802

Legend
Messages
25,216
Type of diabetes
Treatment type
Diet only
Yes but some doctors don't do their jobs properly.In fact once you reach 65 retirement age they could not careless.I've heard of yourger people receiving bad treatment .Before i retired i received excellent treatment from the N.H.S.But it has all gone down the pan as far as i'm concerned.

I completely disagree. We oldies are looked after very well at my surgery. Had it not been for the fact I was a pensioner at the time, my diabetes may not have been picked up as early as it was, if at all. Many others may never have had other health issues picked up through the routine health checks.
 

alf_Josiah

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,920
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
People that point out my spelling mistakes
Well I have just read the whole thread from start to finish and a few things are becoming apparent to me, I have an IQ that runs in minus numbers so please cut me a little leeway.
T1 diabetics are different to T2 diabetics.
All our body chemistries are different, what works for one person MIGHT not work for another.
Other medical conditions could affect how our bodies metabolizes food stuffs.
Yes there is a huge overlap but and it's a big but, we all must find out what works for us.
Now I have had my arguments with diabetic nurses, doctors and dieticians over 18 years where they refuse to look at my prescribed medications and prefer to go through the standard script. These professionals I chose to ignore.
In conclusion I will repeat what I stated above we must find out what works for us, nobody else will.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zand

Sue192

Well-Known Member
Messages
594
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
I completely disagree. We oldies are looked after very well at my surgery. Had it not been for the fact I was a pensioner at the time, my diabetes may not have been picked up as early as it was, if at all. Many others may never have had other health issues picked up through the routine health checks.
I disagree too. My mother (87) has the most amazing GP and the surgery is excellent. She lives in an area favoured by pensioners and neither her nor any of her elderly friends have ever come across that attitude, @david1241. Here, too, my former neighbours were all in their 80s and all received excellent care. I acknowledge that the care at GP surgeries/hospitals is hit and miss, and I'm sorry to read that you think people are 'written off' at 65 and also sorry if you have found that to be the case, but I think (hope) that that is the exception rather than the norm.
 

david1241

Well-Known Member
Messages
62
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
doctors and dentists.I would not be rude to any.Also i don't like being taken for granted.
Well I have just read the whole thread from start to finish and a few things are becoming apparent to me, I have an IQ that runs in minus numbers so please cut me a little leeway.
T1 diabetics are different to T2 diabetics.
All our body chemistries are different, what works for one person MIGHT not work for another.
Other medical conditions could affect how our bodies metabolizes food stuffs.
Yes there is a huge overlap but and it's a big but, we all must find out what works for us.
Now I have had my arguments with diabetic nurses, doctors and dieticians over 18 years where they refuse to look at my prescribed medications and prefer to go through the standard script. These professionals I chose to ignore.
In conclusion I will repeat what I stated above we must find out what works for us, nobody else will.
I totally agree Sir/
 

Bluetit1802

Legend
Messages
25,216
Type of diabetes
Treatment type
Diet only
I disagree too. My mother (87) has the most amazing GP and the surgery is excellent. She lives in an area favoured by pensioners and neither her nor any of her elderly friends have ever come across that attitude, @david1241. Here, too, my former neighbours were all in their 80s and all received excellent care. I acknowledge that the care at GP surgeries/hospitals is hit and miss, and I'm sorry to read that you think people are 'written off' at 65 and also sorry if you have found that to be the case, but I think (hope) that that is the exception rather than the norm.

Yes, my mum had the very best of care from the surgery, through all her various illnesses. It was 5 star treatment without a doubt, and it continued when eventually she had to move from living with us to a residential care home right up to the end of 89 year life.
 

david1241

Well-Known Member
Messages
62
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
doctors and dentists.I would not be rude to any.Also i don't like being taken for granted.
I disagree too. My mother (87) has the most amazing GP and the surgery is excellent. She lives in an area favoured by pensioners and neither her nor any of her elderly friends have ever come across that attitude, @david1241. Here, too, my former neighbours were all in their 80s and all received excellent care. I acknowledge that the care at GP surgeries/hospitals is hit and miss, and I'm sorry to read that you think people are 'written off' at 65 and also sorry if you have found that to be the case, but I think (hope) that that is the exception rather than the norm.
Hello You are very lucky to have good doctors who care about the elderly.I'm only going on my treatment or lack ot it.
 

Bluetit1802

Legend
Messages
25,216
Type of diabetes
Treatment type
Diet only
Hello You are very lucky to have good doctors who care about the elderly.I'm only going on my treatment or lack ot it.

That is a shame, but do remember it isn't the same everywhere, so generalisations are unfair. :)
 

Lally123

Well-Known Member
Messages
231
Type of diabetes
LADA
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
Yeah it's cheating the doc from getting pay-backs from Big Pharma.
I totally disagree. Doctors do not receive backhanders from drug companies. It would be completely unethical and completely against prescribing guidelines and they would be struck off if they did. I am not a doctor but I am an independent prescriber and we have to be immensely careful about contact with drug companies. Even something like conference sponsorship is strictly controlled and has to be registered. Having said that, I know that one of the QOF standards GPs have to meet for diabetes is for 80% (I think) to have total cholesterol <5.0. If they meet the target the practice gets money. But that doesn't go into the GPs pocket it goes into the money to run the practice and continue developing services. Please don't make it sound as though a doctor is just out to make money out of us, they aren't. And you always have the choice to take a drug or not no one is going to force you, how could They? I don't take statins myself because I just don't want to right now based on my blood results. My GP tries to persuade me every visit but says it's my choice which it is. I don't think it's fair to make that sort of comment and possibly influence people new to diabetes who may be reading this forum into thinking their gp is all about their money and not their health.
 

bulkbiker

BANNED
Messages
19,575
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Doctors do not receive backhanders from drug companies
Free lunches? golf days? free pens, notepads etc?
I think there is more going on than you care to admit.. ok so they don't get blatant cash payouts (probably) if they did then I'm not sure how you would know.
 

Lally123

Well-Known Member
Messages
231
Type of diabetes
LADA
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
Free lunches? golf days? free pens, notepads etc?
I think there is more going on than you care to admit.. ok so they don't get blatant cash payouts (probably) if they did then I'm not sure how you would know.
Not any more they don't. The ABPI rules changed about 7 years ago. It was thought that giving out pens with Viagra or whatever written on it could affect the meds prescribed...the only lunches allowed now are if there is a learning element attached. I often go to dinners but there is usually a 2 hour presentation before dinner. Golf days are no more either though they did used to happen. You can get sponsored for conference abroad but even then you have no.free time, electronic attendance monitoring, taken to the restaurant on a bus in the evening and not allowed to make your own arrangements. I am sure it did used to happen in years gone by but it simply doesn't any more.
 

LooperCat

Expert
Messages
5,223
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Other
Free lunches? golf days? free pens, notepads etc?
I think there is more going on than you care to admit.. ok so they don't get blatant cash payouts (probably) if they did then I'm not sure how you would know.
I know the surgery gets more money if they put me on statins. I don’t know how much, is it more than the cost of the actual pills? If it helped my surgery I’d be willing to accept the prescription and not fill it - or would it be recorded if I didn’t and stop their payment from going through? I’d love to know more about how all this target driven funding works. I’ve been requested by my practice nurse to have my hospital-ordered phlebotomy done at my surgery rather than the hospital clinic as they get more income if I do.
 

Lally123

Well-Known Member
Messages
231
Type of diabetes
LADA
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
I know the surgery gets more money if they put me on statins. I don’t know how much, is it more than the cost of the actual pills? If it helped my surgery I’d be willing to accept the prescription and not fill it - or would it be recorded if I didn’t and stop their payment from going through? I’d love to know more about how all this target driven funding works. I’ve been requested by my practice nurse to have my hospital-ordered phlebotomy done at my surgery rather than the hospital clinic as they get more income if I do.
It's all to do with something called the quality outcome framework (QOF). This is a series of targets set down to improve the care we get. If a surgery meets a QOF and there are lots of different targets to meet, they get extra funding. It's not a target specifically for giving you a statin for example so getting a prescription wouldn't help them meet the target. But if that prescription reduced your cholesterol below target level ie 5, and 80% of their diabetics did that, then they would meet that particular target and would get that extra bit of money. As for your blood test end of the day it's your choice where you get it done, they may well get paid per blood test they do but if it's easier for you to go to the hospital then go there. Hope that explains the targets a bit I feel like I've waffled on!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bluetit1802

LooperCat

Expert
Messages
5,223
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Other
It's all to do with something called the quality outcome framework (QOF). This is a series of targets set down to improve the care we get. If a surgery meets a QOF and there are lots of different targets to meet, they get extra funding. It's not a target specifically for giving you a statin for example so getting a prescription wouldn't help them meet the target. But if that prescription reduced your cholesterol below target level ie 5, and 80% of their diabetics did that, then they would meet that particular target and would get that extra bit of money. As for your blood test end of the day it's your choice where you get it done, they may well get paid per blood test they do but if it's easier for you to go to the hospital then go there. Hope that explains the targets a bit I feel like I've waffled on!
Nah, that’s good to know. Thank you! I’d like to help my surgery get max funding if I can, it makes no odds whether I go there or the clinic to have bloods taken. The only difference is a walk-in clinic at the hospital v appointments at the GP, so as long as I’m organised enough I’ll go to them.
 

Guzzler

Master
Messages
10,577
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
Poor grammar, bullying and drunks.
This sounds strange. I was sent a letter calling for my HbA1c blood test from the surgery and up until now have had the bloods drawn at the surgery. This time the letter states I have to go up to the hospital or to another surgery just to have the bloods drawn. I am unhappy about this and I am about a month overdue for the tests as I do not see why a simple blood draw has to be done elsewhere. I had deliberately changed GP/Surgery so as to cut the inconvenience and cost of going to my old surgery, now it will cost twice as much.