- Messages
- 3,742
- Type of diabetes
- Prediabetes
- Treatment type
- Tablets (oral)
http://www.diabetesincontrol.com/kathleen-wyne-complete-interview/
You can watch a series of videos of this interview with Dr Kathleen Wyne, or read the complete transcript. I was especially interested in what she has to say about diagnosing adult onset T1. She says exactly the same as Dr Bernstein, that the C-peptide test is useless without a simultaneous glucose test. I have just been listening to one of Dr B's Teleseminars, where he explains that a person with a normal response to carbs would test low for C-peptide if they had not eaten any/many carbs, as they would then have no reason to produce a lot of insulin. Dr K.W says,
"... most people think you diagnose type 1 by doing a C-peptide and if the C-peptide is undetectable, then by definition, they have type 1. That’s not true. First of all, someone who has had type 2 for many years could have an undetectable C-peptide. Second of all, any time you measure C-peptide, it must have a simultaneous glucose. You need a context. So, this person who is an adult onset type 1, may have a C-peptide that’s reported in the normal range. But if the simultaneous glucose is 410, then it’s inappropriately low which is not what you would see in a newly diagnosed type 2 where it would be inappropriately high. So, first of all, your C-peptide needs to be in a context."
You can watch a series of videos of this interview with Dr Kathleen Wyne, or read the complete transcript. I was especially interested in what she has to say about diagnosing adult onset T1. She says exactly the same as Dr Bernstein, that the C-peptide test is useless without a simultaneous glucose test. I have just been listening to one of Dr B's Teleseminars, where he explains that a person with a normal response to carbs would test low for C-peptide if they had not eaten any/many carbs, as they would then have no reason to produce a lot of insulin. Dr K.W says,
"... most people think you diagnose type 1 by doing a C-peptide and if the C-peptide is undetectable, then by definition, they have type 1. That’s not true. First of all, someone who has had type 2 for many years could have an undetectable C-peptide. Second of all, any time you measure C-peptide, it must have a simultaneous glucose. You need a context. So, this person who is an adult onset type 1, may have a C-peptide that’s reported in the normal range. But if the simultaneous glucose is 410, then it’s inappropriately low which is not what you would see in a newly diagnosed type 2 where it would be inappropriately high. So, first of all, your C-peptide needs to be in a context."