Protein Shakes Safe?

[cricketer]

Is it safe for T1 diabetic to take a protein shake such as this as I want to increase my muscle tone

http://www.argos.co.uk/static/Product/p ... 419289.htm

Im already very active

 

[bonerp]

i do - I but from GNC Metx. Low sugar and choc flavour. Nicest one of the lot

 

[Beav]

As far as I know bud and ive been training for 5 years in June. Try to find a low carb shake. I know protein can effect sugar level as well but see how it goes before injecting more for a shake as your sugar level will drop a few hours after a weight training session anyway.

 

[borofergie]

I'm a T2 (low-carber) and I drink them all the time (mainly to support my running, but also as a breakfast replacement).

Most of them are pretty low-carb, I drink chocolate Sci-Mx GRS-5, which is only about 2.5g per serving.

Some people suggests that Diabetics should be careful of too much protein in case it affects your kidneys, but I don't think that there is very much good science behind that claim, and lots of anecdotal evidence that suggests otherwise.

 

[cricketer]

Thanks guys, really helped. Going to go and get one today, will report back with results later :lol:

 

[bonerp]

i find scrambled eggs can increase my bgs a couple of hours later so that would indicate to me protein can affect you - or me any ways

 

[Beav]

I forgot to add, avoid argos and holland a barret muck, lol. You don't have to spend £50/£60 a tub on big brands either such as PHD but these are good. You can save money buy using brands such as myprotein / bulkpowders.

~all the best!

 

[borofergie]

I forgot to add, avoid argos and holland a barret muck, lol. You don't have to spend £50/£60 a tub on big brands either such as PHD but these are good. You can save money buy using brands such as myprotein / bulkpowders.

~all the best!

+1

I made the mistake of buying some Holland and Barret Banana Flavoured Whey Protein, and I can't finish it. It tastes chemical and digusting.

 

[Beav]

I forgot to add. What is your diet like? The key to seeing muscle is losing fat. This is done by diet/cardio!

 

[cricketer]

Ooops read your post too late and got some "York All in one" which is protein and creatine from Argos... was reduced to £11 which was mainly why I got it! Doesn't taste great but will see if I get any results.

As for diet im vegetarian but eat fish and eggs etc, not eating great atm as am at Uni but am trying to eat better...

 

[humaject]

The best protein powder to use is Soya not as good as whey for building but the health benefits are numerous and far outreach the whey proteins on the market.I am 58 years old have been weight training for 34 years. I won the NABBA WALES + NORTH WALES in 1990 theres nothing i haven`t used in the bodybuilding game.........but after a scare { hypo coma } was in hospital for a week 15 years ago and was told in no uncertain terms what the outcome would be, i changed everything around i still weight train 5 days per week ,after each session i make a drink consisting of strawberrys,blueberrys, half a bannana,1 raw egg,2 desert spoons of porrige oats,1 scoop of Soya Protein and water to mix.

 

[borofergie]

The best protein powder to use is Soya not as good as whey for building but the health benefits are numerous and far outreach the whey proteins on the market.I am 58 years old have been weight training for 34 years. I won the NABBA WALES

Are you not worried about phyto-oestrogens in soya? I wouldn't mind a six pack, but I could do without the accompanying boobs...

 

[ljwilson]

I'm a T2 (low-carber) and I drink them all the time (mainly to support my running, but also as a breakfast replacement).

Most of them are pretty low-carb, I drink chocolate Sci-Mx GRS-5, which is only about 2.5g per serving.

Some people suggests that Diabetics should be careful of too much protein in case it affects your kidneys, but I don't think that there is very much good science behind that claim, and lots of anecdotal evidence that suggests otherwise.

As a Type 1 with Stage 4 CKD I cannot touch these!

Lorna

 

[mrglut4]

Proteins shakes are safe to some extent if the sugar levels in your blood do not get too high if you are at initial stages.. or else dont even think about them

 

[stumac0127]

I checked with my diabetic Doctor at the hospital he said as long as your kidney function was ok then a high protein diet was fine, So I would check that first! I lost over 2 stone of fat and gained some muscle on a high protein low(er) carb diet. 14.8 to 12.5. You cannot cut all your carbs like some diets/exercise plans for non diabectic's say. You also need to test more when training. Before in the middle an after. I found different exercise made massive differences to my BS. One day I could start at 8 then hypo. Others start a 8 again the go up to the high twentys. Good luck with your training.
Ps don't forget to get your kidney function checked!!

 

[Anonymous]

I've been using the Precision Engineered brand instant milk and egg protein from Holland and Barrett (Red tub) - it's 1.2g carb per serving which is a lot lower than the last one I bought. That's still 9.5g carb if I make it with milk.

I'm going to need to buy some more this week - has anyone got any suggestions that are equally low carb? This one is quite sweet but it doesn't list what the sweetener is though it hasn't caused me any problems. I haven't tried making it with water yet.

 

[borofergie]

I've been using the Precision Engineered brand instant milk and egg protein from Holland and Barrett (Red tub) - it's 1.2g carb per serving which is a lot lower than the last one I bought. That's still 9.5g carb if I make it with milk.

I'm going to need to buy some more this week - has anyone got any suggestions that are equally low carb? This one is quite sweet but it doesn't list what the sweetener is though it hasn't caused me any problems. I haven't tried making it with water yet.

Recipe for a safe protein shake:
Put some steak and some cream in a blender.
Drink.

 

[BioHaZarD]

I've been using the Precision Engineered brand instant milk and egg protein from Holland and Barrett (Red tub) - it's 1.2g carb per serving which is a lot lower than the last one I bought. That's still 9.5g carb if I make it with milk.

I'm going to need to buy some more this week - has anyone got any suggestions that are equally low carb? This one is quite sweet but it doesn't list what the sweetener is though it hasn't caused me any problems. I haven't tried making it with water yet.

Recipe for a safe protein shake:
Put some steak and some cream in a blender.
Drink.

:lol:

 

[AMBrennan]

Recipe for a safe protein shake:
Put some steak and some cream in a blender.
Drink.

I thought the point of those shakes was both price (not that you could tell from the high street prices, but whey protein is basically industrial waste from the cheese industry) and logistical convenience (I can keep a tub with a month's supply in my cupboard, which would be difficult to do with steak...)

I'm not sure that blended steak would satisfy either requirement. :twisted:

 

[GlazedDoughnuts]

Im using protein powders from myprotein, my kidneyfunction was recorded as normal.

The protein powder i use does have some fast carbs but it also has rolled oats. 20 of mixed carbs per serving. I have two shakes per day and add 70 grams of rolled oats to both. I increase my insulin slightly.

I find post exercise my blood sugar level is perfect