Hi Darren
I can understand why the hospital would say that. Byetta encourages your pancreas to produce the appropriate amount of insulin to deal with the raise in blood sugar following eating. The important word is APPROPRIATE - in other words you either need Byetta or you need insulin, but taking both would put far too much insulin into your system and simply force a major hypo. Your hospital must be happy that your pancreas is capable of producing insulin or there would be no point in recommending it. It is possible that your pancreas might not be able to produce the full amount of insulin that is needed, in which case topping up with a small quantity of injected insulin might be necessary, but that can only be determined by removing the insulin and seeing what the result of Byetta on its own is.
There is a further consideration that your hospital may be considering, which is that NICE have not approved Byetta to be prescribed in combination with insulin, although several diabetes consultants do prescribe the two in tandem where the insulin is a small quantity to simply augment the pancreas' own production.
I hestitate to mention this because however you say it, it sounds like slagging off the medical profession - but in most cases the diabetes specialists that work in hospitals have forgotten more about diabetes than doctors and nurses in general practice will ever know. I certainly know which one's advice I would be inclined to follow!!