- Messages
- 19,575
- Type of diabetes
- Type 2
- Treatment type
- Diet only
https://drmalcolmkendrick.org/2021/11/04/the-enduring-mystery-of-heart-disease-the-clot-thickens/
An interesting read indeed...
An interesting read indeed...
The way they drive around where I live I can relate to the post code thingy deff a risk to life if nothing else!@bulkbiker thank you for the link. I may well ask Santa for the book.
@hankjam I also ran the Q risk calculator and was 16.2% without my postcode and 18.5% with it, all the rest of the numbers stayed the same. Why on earth would my address increase my death risk??? IMHO it just shows how useless the Qrisk calculation system is. I am not losing sleep over it.
You might like to read this about the Glasgow Effect...Why on earth would my address increase my death risk???
@bulkbiker thank you for the link. I may well ask Santa for the book.
@hankjam I also ran the Q risk calculator and was 16.2% without my postcode and 18.5% with it, all the rest of the numbers stayed the same. Why on earth would my address increase my death risk??? IMHO it just shows how useless the Qrisk calculation system is. I am not losing sleep over it.
OK, so if we assume he's right...what can we do to prevent cardiovascular disease?
He stops short of that point, any knowledge any one?
Of course it is a generalisation about a population rather than a fact about an individual. Consider someone who has lived most of their life somewhere rural and recently moved to an inner city, their health doesn't suddenly change. All of the Qrisk factors are just statistical probabilities, although I believe the test has been validated using actual deaths. One of its big weaknesses for the members of this forum is that it asks if you are diabetic without asking about control.@Mr_Pot I understand that some areas are more deprived than others but I didn't think that where I lived was one of those areas. It seems as if I am somewhat deluded. It is a working class area of the North West of England but fairly rural.
One of its big weaknesses for the members of this forum is that it asks if you are diabetic without asking about control.
Love the title of the book The Clot Thickens...https://drmalcolmkendrick.org/2021/11/04/the-enduring-mystery-of-heart-disease-the-clot-thickens/
An interesting read indeed...
You would need to ask how you controlled your diabetes since studies of those with very tightly controlled glucose but achieved through use of insulin and sulphonyureas (glicazide etc) had to be halted because this group had worse CVD outcomes.Of course it is a generalisation about a population rather than a fact about an individual. Consider someone who has lived most of their life somewhere rural and recently moved to an inner city, their health doesn't suddenly change. All of the Qrisk factors are just statistical probabilities, although I believe the test has been validated using actual deaths. One of its big weaknesses for the members of this forum is that it asks if you are diabetic without asking about control.
Agreed. In my own case, as a diet controlled type 2 with non diabetic Hba1c my doctor was happy not to tick diabetic when he ran the Qrisk calculator. Not that it makes much difference, apart from not recommending statins.You would need to ask how you controlled your diabetes since studies of those with very tightly controlled glucose but achieved through use of insulin and sulphonyureas (glicazide etc) had to be halted because this group had worse CVD outcomes.
Possibly, but the calculator isn't clairvoyantThis is true but it also occurs to me that perhaps the major risk factor is the underlying pathology of metabolic syndrome and all of its associated health problems rather than blood glucose data per se.
Not that it makes much difference
What I meant was that the Qrisk score doesn't make much difference. Most of the factors you can't alter and the rest you probably knew were risks anyway.T2 makes mine go from 8.4% to 14.7% everything else the same. Almost doubling the "risk".
Nonsense of course but still not insignificant.