One day a month binge...

RobsterinSheff

Well-Known Member
Messages
54
Dislikes
Type 2 diabetes; Hashimotos; English weather; arrogant and self centered people
...how dangerous?

Come across postings on various diabetic forums alluding to 'falling off the wagon' whether being high sugar (booze binge) or high carb (fast food or restaurant hi carb binge).

I am wondering what people think/ what their experiences might have been of say 1 day a month having a big p*ss up; or going out to a restaurant and having what your old carbaholic self would have had pre T2D diagnosis.

Is such behaviour to be avoided at all costs?

Or could it be used a a once-per-month 'treat' / as a motivator for the dietary discipline on the other 29/30 days?
 

borofergie

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,169
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
Racism, Sexism, Homophobia
Obviously it's not the best, but if you can stay on the waggon for the other 29 days then it's better than nothing. Everyone falls off the waggon sometimes, you have to find a solution that is sustainable for you. Someone on here said that diabetes is a "6 days a week" disease (although I'm not sure that I agree).

In my experience, if you can stick at the diet, those cravings go away. I can't even look at a glass of orange juice these days. Once you have control, you'll probably feel so bad after your binge that you won't want to do it again, especially if it takes days for your BG to recover.

(I'm not the only poster here, someone else will hopefully reply in a bit).
 

Grazer

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,115
A food binge once a month will probably last a lot longer than that in effects, so in addition to the peaks of BG you experienced doing damage, (arguably, but lots will say high peaks cause harm) the effect on your overall average BGs and thus HbA1c is not inconsiderable. I guess it wouldn't help with weight either if that's an issue. There is the further issue that once a month can become once a month plus birthdays, then plus friends birthdays and so on. Bit like the occasional fag!
Regarding the Pxxx up- why do you describe this as a sugar binge? Spirits have zero sugar or carbs, wine very little and even though beer does, the alcohol stops the liver processing the carbs into sugar in the blood. It's why insulin dependant diabetics have to be wary of hypos if they drink. So drinking is between you and your liver rather than your diabetes! We have to enjoy something-I do!
 

Dillinger

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,207
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Celery.
Hi,

I don't have a problem with drinking alcohol - as long as it is wine or spirits with low carb mixers. Beer is a carby killer which is a shame.

The thing with falling off/throwing yourself off the wagon as far as food is concerned it will mess up your metabolism; if you are in ketosis then the body will prefer to use energy from carbs (by 'prefer' I mean it will use it first not that it 'likes' it more) and you will drop out of ketosis if you binge.

Purely anecdotally I've found that where that has happened it seems harder to get back into a good ketotic stage; Atkins mentions this I think. So, you will do yourself no favours; try and avoid it - the benefits of maintaining the diet I think override the pleasures of a pizza or two. I know that it is far easier to say that than do that; we are all human but you've got to steel yourself against that tricky tempter of a disease that is diabetes.

Best

Dillinger
 

andrewk

Well-Known Member
Messages
166
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
Dislikes
Folks who "know it all" (but don't)
Dillinger said:
Purely anecdotally I've found that where that has happened it seems harder to get back into a good ketotic stage

It takes me 3 to 4 days to get back into ketosis after a binge. I think that is quite usual

Andrew
 

didie

Well-Known Member
Messages
729
Dislikes
People who think they are always right and ram their opinions down your throat. No-one knows everything. Those who shout loudest are usually the ones who actually know the least.
I'd not be able to do that because it would be so easy to slip and fall into bad eating habits again. It's just easier to keep going with with what I eat. If I feel like munching on something 'bad', then I give myself a reminder about why I totally changed my lifestyle and eating habits and as there is no way I'm going back there again, the temptation fizzles away. It's just not worth it. Food is just fuel really, whereas life is for living and I want a good long life. It might sound trite, but that's the way I see things.
 

MaryJ

Well-Known Member
Messages
842
Hi Robster.

I'm with the others I'm afraid. I have had to eat what I didn't want to at a wedding recenty, dealt with it, felt no ill effects. Couldn't wait to get back to my new healthier way of eating.

I understand totally that this is for life and there will be occasions which present themselves where you are massively restricted in your choices. I take these times as my 'fall off the wagon' rather than plan for them once a week/month/qtr/whatever.

Mary x
 

borofergie

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,169
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Dislikes
Racism, Sexism, Homophobia
andrewk said:
It takes me 3 to 4 days to get back into ketosis after a binge. I think that is quite usual

Steve Phinney reckons it can take up to 2-3 weeks to get back into ketosis (although he admits there is not much scientific background to this and I've heard Mark Sissons and some others saying that it should only take a few days):
[youtube]KkdFkPxxDG8[/youtube]

As a hard-core ketogenic dieter, the fear of dumping out of ketosis is what keeps me on the straight and narrow.

It's worth noting that the OP is currently on 200g a day of carb, so he'd have to drop well below 100g for ketosis to be a factor in his considerations.
 

RobsterinSheff

Well-Known Member
Messages
54
Dislikes
Type 2 diabetes; Hashimotos; English weather; arrogant and self centered people
Thanks everyone- some very interesting posts.

I have to say intellectually I am of the view 'off the wagon only rarely if ever' and don't think its a good idea to become a part of my planned approach to managing the condition.

Maybe I will reconsider that when I get to below 6.5.

Glad that I can have the occasional glass of red wine though !
 

Gappy

Well-Known Member
Messages
483
Dislikes
hypocrisy, prejudice and the corrupt legal system (never got compensation I deserved from an accident)
borofergie said:
Obviously it's not the best, but if you can stay on the waggon for the other 29 days then it's better than nothing. Everyone falls off the waggon sometimes, you have to find a solution that is sustainable for you. Someone on here said that diabetes is a "6 days a week" disease (although I'm not sure that I agree)
That was probably me, I've said that several times & light heartedly my diabetic nurse agrees with me. I would never have the discipline many have about such strict regimes, so my night off is my way of coping. My last hbac was 5.6 so although it may not be ideal it works for me. I think the big problem comes if you're not honest enough about your control & still have a "treat day" then it becomes a downward spiral
 

goslow12

Member
Messages
24
Dislikes
Unfair people
MaryJ said:
I take these times as my 'fall off the wagon' rather than plan for them once a week/month/qtr/whatever.

Mary x

Nicely put Mary...

There are some days I just wish we could have "a day off"! It can be difficult sometimes, especially when you are newly diagnosed to sort your diet out. In fact I got quite depressed over it myself.

As others have said just don't make the binging a thing of habit