• A new study found consumers and expert-derived nutrition ratings often disagree on how healthy common carbohydrate foods are.
  • People tended to underestimate the healthfulness of some carbohydrate foods, while overrating others such as honey.
  • For people with diabetes, the message is not “carbs are good” or “carbs are bad” – it is that the type, portion and context matter.

Carbohydrates are probably the most misunderstood part of the diet.

For people with diabetes, that confusion is even worse, because carbs directly affect blood glucose but are also found in many foods that can be part of a healthy diet.

A new study looked at how consumers judge the healthfulness of 20 common carbohydrate-rich foods.

The researchers compared public perceptions with expert-derived nutrition ratings.

They found substantial mismatch.

In fact, misperceptions were present for all 20 foods.

Around 85% of the foods scored poorly for alignment between consumer views and expert-derived ratings.

Honey stood out in one direction.

Consumers tended to rate it as healthier than expert ratings suggested.

That is not surprising. Honey is often marketed as natural, but from a glucose-management point of view it is still a sugar source.

Potato foods showed the opposite pattern.

French fries, potato crisps, baked potatoes and air-popped unbuttered popcorn were often rated less healthy by consumers than the expert-derived ratings suggested.

That does not mean chips and crisps should suddenly become diabetes staples.

It means people often judge foods by reputation rather than by nutrient profile, preparation method or portion.

A baked potato is not nutritionally the same as fries.

Air-popped popcorn is not the same as buttered cinema popcorn.

More on carbohydrates:

The study also found complex misconceptions around honey oat cereal, 100% fruit juice, whole wheat bread, buttered popcorn and corn tortillas.

These are the kinds of foods where simple health labels can be misleading.

For example, 100% fruit juice sounds healthy because it comes from fruit, but it can deliver sugar quickly without the fibre of whole fruit.

Whole wheat bread may be a better choice than white bread for many people, but it still contains carbohydrate and portion size matters.

The researchers identified white rice, white bread, corn tortillas and vitamin C-fortified fruit juice as priority foods for clearer communication.

That was based on three things: consumer misunderstanding, expert uncertainty and how often these foods are eaten.

This is useful because diabetes advice can easily become too blunt.

Telling people to “avoid carbs” is not realistic or accurate.

Telling people “whole grains are better” is true in many cases but still incomplete.

The better conversation is about carbohydrate quality, fibre, processing, portion size, meal balance and individual glucose response.

The study also has limits.

It was a pilot analysis of only 20 foods and used a US convenience sample.

It also compared consumer views with a harmonised expert-rating system, which may not perfectly capture diabetes-specific effects such as post-meal glucose rise.

So this should not be treated as a final ranking of which carbs are best.

But it does highlight a real problem.

People are trying to make food choices in a noisy environment where “natural”, “wholegrain”, “low fat”, “fortified” and “healthy” can all mean different things.

For diabetes, clearer advice is badly needed.

Carbohydrates are not one category. They are a whole landscape, and people deserve better maps.

Get our free newsletters

Stay up to date with the latest news, research and breakthroughs.