Hi Smidge, I would reduce the insulin,,,,as I don't want to gain weight...BUT, I am intesrested by something you said.
You mentionedthe fact that you usually go to bed with a blood sugar around 9? What kind of insulin are you taking? Lantus, Levimir etc all have a profile...ie, they go into your system...start to work, work up to a maximum level, and then tail off a bit. The trick is finding one that works for you. Sounds to me (although I am not a DR, so this is just an opinion) that it may be the time that you take the insulin may not be right? If you are dropping fast over night...this is not good obviously, but at the same time, you are high before bed. I would be tempted to do the injection first thing in the morning and see how thatgoes...if that doesn't work, try splitting the dose.
I say this, though, as someone who has been injection insulin for years...so it is definately worth talking to your Dr about this. I would guess that you may be better with 2, smaller doses of basal insulin...but it is a guess, so get some professional help.
I aim for a BG level between 5 and 6...but I am on an insulin pump now, before the pump, I aimed for 6 to 7. Night time hypos should be avoided at all costs...but so should higher blood glucose levels.....Welcome to the diabetic tight rope!