That sounds to me like you are doing well then and I think you are about where I was 12 months ago.
I was diagnosed after I developed neuropathy in my hands and feet, no idea at the time what that even was and by the time i realised something needed looking at I think I had done some damage.
My GP told me there was little that could be done to help with neuropathy but if I controlled my blood sugars I could avoid further damage., and If I was lucky, I might see some gradual improvement in my condition.
The DNs idea of good control was "anything in single figures is fine for type 2s" (I was about 14.6 at the time....) but reading through the advice on here, particularly in a thread called "help in dealing with neuropathy", I decided anything below 6 before a meal is acceptable, and I should avoid eating anything that causes a spike of more than 2.0 , two hours later.
15 months on I am normally around 5 to 5.5, I have regained feeling in my fingers and my feet have returning sensation, which was extremely painful for quite a while but is improving now, so I think its all good.
I am not keen on pills either and am trying to cut down on Metformin too - I was on 4 per day for a year or so, cut it to 3 three weeks ago, and dropped to 2 as of yesterday.
I shall be keeping a close eye on the figures though!
HTH
Tim