To all our highly researched and well controlled diabetics on the forum
When advising diabetics, even if it is in answer to a post by an experienced diabetic, please remember that this forum is read by newly diagnosed as well.
You may have got your numbers very low but for someone who is high then this is like shooting for the moon! The advice to get to the NICE guidelines is do-able for most newly diagnosed. Once they get their levels down to that level, then they can try for the lower levels as, by this time, they will have got some idea on diet etc. and more experience in just what diabetes is.
Similarly on diet, yes, you may have a diet that controls your diabetes successfully but did you start there? Reducing down gradually is more likely to be permanent and a life style change than trying to go ultra- low immediately and perhaps failing and feeling guilty about it.
Newly diagnosed diabetics need time to acclimatise to their condition and small steps at a time are more likely to succeed than very large steps.
Similarly advising that certain low numbers are ok just because you have attained them is very disheartening for someone confused and inexperienced.
Being confused immediately after a diagnosis is very common.
Hi Sue, hope you don't mind me quoting you here but I thought it was worth discussing.
I can't speak for anyone else, but I managed to get my waking BG level from double figures to low 5s within a week. That's quite a big step! I needed to get to basics and concentrate on just one thing -lowering those numbers. As such, I'm not sure that it is 'shooting for the moon' TBH Sue, it was fairly straightforward really. If I can do that, others in my position could also, I'm not saying everyone could, but some could!
For me, reducing down slowly would have been a disaster. I'm naturally very weak-willed when it comes to food so had I gone off plan for any time I'm sure I would have ended up back on the carbs big time. I would have been continually climbing back in the saddle, so to speak.
Also seeing others posting their low numbers gave me hope that it was possible, I think without that hope I would have just given up! Surely other newly diagnosed members could view it in the same way.
I can only speak for myself, but 'cold turkey' has proved very effective for me and I was as confused and scared as anybody. If it worked for me, it can also work for others, although I can see that it is not for everyone.
Surely, that's why we need as many people as possible discussing their approaches so that new members can pick and choose. I don't think there is one 'right' way, although carb control has to play a part for everyone.
I think the more stories new members are exposed to, the more able they are to make informed decisions. I can't advocate an approach I haven't followed, that would be hypocritical. My approach worked for ME, surely by default then it would work for others too!