• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

Confused?

jennie275

Member
Messages
6
Hi I posted last night feeling quite positive about my diabetes having only been diagnosed last month I thought I was doing really well with what I was eating as i'm feeling great, loads of energy but my recommended diet plan was just to just moderate what I was eating and obviously cut out sugars. However the doctor told me not to eat eggs, bacon or fried foods because of the effect it could have on cholestrol, yet on this forum these are the foods which people are recommending. My cholestrol was 4.9 so was under the recommended level.
Just a little confused? Why is the NHS view of moderation so different to what seems to actually work for people?
 
jennie275 wrote
Why is the NHS view of moderation so different to what seems to actually work for people?

For decades the following have been the cornerstones of conventional dietary advice :

A) fat, especially saturated fat is only good in moderation.
B) dietary cholesterol (e.g. eggs, cheese,red meat) is to be severely limited, since it will increase your cholesterol levels.
C) 'healthy' carbohydrates form the basis of any sensible eating plan.

When you take the above , and throw a condition like diabetes into the mix, all that's left to advise is that the sugar-rich foods are to be restricted, since A and B cannot be increased, and everyone knows carbohydrates are 'good' for you, so continue eating them. Just moderate your intake.

In the last ten/fifteen years there has been growth in new understanding about dietary health e.g.

1) dietary cholesterol doesn't increase body cholesterol
2) carb intake affects cholesterol levels i.e. worsens them
3) saturated fat may not be the villain it's often made out to be
4) a low-carb diet improves cholesterol levels, since many carbohydrate foods turn fairly rapidly to glucose in your body

Some of this has been known for a long term, but Dr Atkins is probably the best known figurehead for this diet revolution (diet as in way of eating.) Paleo, primal, low-carb high fat all share a stance that differs from conventional wisdom.
They've looked back at studies which led to A,B, and C above and have found them flawed. They have proved, by adopting a new way of eating, that benefits can be experienced.
Many diabetics, by testing their blood sugar levels, find carbs to be the main culprit. Some tolerate more, whilst a moderate NHS level is too high for others.

But the NHS is like a super tanker, that can't be easily and quickly turned around. Some GPs, DSNs and other HCPs are recognising the benefits of a low-carb approach, but do so whilst recognising it can't be pushed as NHS advice.

Since many here are looking to take control of their diabetes, they're noticing what others are saying, both about what conventional advice did (or didn't do) for them, and what a fresh approach has done for them. (IanD springs to mind.)

So we feel we're ahead of conventional wisdom. But there's tons of research and studies to support our view. And as I said our own experiences.

Just take time to take it in, and make your own mind up about it all.
It's your diabetes. You're in control.

Geoff
 
Hi Jennie and welcome to the forum
Here is some information that we give to new members which should help you to feel less confused. As you are trying for a baby you should follow what the medical staff advise you first. Ask as many questions as you like as there is always someone who will answer.

 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn More.…