• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

Diagnosed today...or well have I..??

Thunderbird 4

Member
Messages
6
Back from docs today after two fasting blood test over a week both reading 6.9 and 7.1 respectively. However my HB1 was just 5.5.

The doctor has put me straight on medication 'Metaformin' without any further thought, or consultation over diet etc. His comment was...well your Diabetic and I start people on medication straight away as they will end up taking it sooner or later'

Do you think I should ask for a second opion before going down the med route?

Thanks
 
A Quote from the NICE guidelines.


You can try and control your diabetes with diet and exercise for a while and if you can keep your levels down without medication so much the better.
Diabetes Type 2 does not need to be progressive if controlled. Keeping the daily blood glucose levels down can help prevent long term complications.


If your doctor does not subscribe to you having a say in the management of YOUR diabetes then perhaps a second opinion may be advisable.

Sue/Ken.
 
hi there, i was diagnosed a couple of months ago.Fasting test was 13.1 and hbac1 6.5 doc told me i could go 3 months with diet and excersice to get it down which i am doing.
Your GP doesnt sound very helpful, i think that i would ask for a second opinion.
 
Hi thanks for th replys,

Was just slightly concerned that the med route should be considered so soon ans with relitivey on the edge readings. I have no problem with taking the GP's advice but as with many health situations medication may not always be the best first course of action. Yes, I have been feeling quite off colour for a while and very....very exhausted, thus the reason for the tests being undertaken to check this out.

I am not looking at my recent diagnosis of Diabetes as a negative, moreover a positive as it brings you up short and makes you realise you just need to look after yourself a little more. Although I have picked the meds up from the pharmacy I still have not taken them, as I know I am not in any imminent danger, so a I will be making an appointment for a second opinion.

The GP's did not give me any leaflets, advice on diet or anything, what he did do was handed me a piece of paper with a web address (diabetes uk) and said go and have a look at this site there is loads of useful information on there to help you..!!

I suppose..yes its shock to find out you have diabetes but reading the posts on here life can be fine as long as you look after yourself.

Will come back with outcome.

Thanks again.
 
I had the same with my Dr. Found I was type 2 and immediately put on Metformine, Ramipril and Simvastatin with no explanation, apart from his comment, well your very overweight so what did you expect!! Hence I made a complaint and requested I never see him again.

I did seek a second opinion and was told that because Diabetics are more prone to Heart attacks/strokes, it is advisable to have Ramipril to keep blood pressure down. Also Simvastatin for cholesterol benefits. I was put on Aspirin too but I must admit I do not take these daily as I heard they can cause stomach bleeding.
 
Iff you take "soluble" aspirin, dissolved, with food, It won't cause bleeding
Hana
 
This has always puzzled me, why do a fasting test when on waking, (at 5am in my case), when my bs levels are fine 4-6, but by the time I get to the docs at 9-10am my liver is dumping and they have gone well up, usually 6+. If I have had some Bergan toast and a cuppa they are usually well below 6 by that time . Is the HB1 not a better indicator? Mine was 6.2 and after an oral test doc tells me I am pre diabetic and just to keep on with my diet. Got my yearly check in a few weeks and am now a bit concerned wether my doc knows what he is doing! :roll:
 
Firstly, congratulations on your HBA1c of 5.5


As jumbleannie says, I would think the dawn phenomenon is probably to blame here, with an A1c of 5.5% I would think you are probably fine with just diet and exercise, but I am not a medical professional so I would advise you to ask your doctor for a referral to a diabetic clinic and let them be the judge of your future medication.

It is common on here to read of some GP's treating all their diabetic patients as though they are all going to suffer complications, you are entitled to be referred to a diabetic clinic where you may well find the team there more optimistic about your future.
 
I've just been diagnosed with an HbA1c of 10.6, and while the doctor wanted to put me straight on Metformin, I asked to be allowed to try to manage it with diet and exercise first, and she was happy to let me do that. The diabetes nurse at the practice backed this up this week.

I wouldn't be happy with someone telling me I *must* take medication without discussing the options with me ...
 

I agree with ramtops and haggis.

Those levels you stated are not very high IMHO and I would opt for diet and exercise for a few months before resorting to meds. I've a feeling that if you do so the meds wont be necessary.

If I can do it anyone can.
 
Thanks everyone for the replies,

Clearly as I am new to all this, there seems to be many whom follow the diet route as against the medication option.

As some of you have said, and after further research my numbers are not way off the scale and in particualr the important factor of the HBA1 being just 5.5. I have also read that in the states they are starting to use the HB1a as a stronger indicator, due to peroples spikes in glucose prior to a fasting test.

Thanks all for the advice.

 
Hello Thunderbird 4 and welcome to the forum.


Do follow the advice given by Ken/Sue as it will be of the greatest benefit. 8)
 
Hi Thunderbird, welcome to the forum, everyone is very helpful here. I am a 73yr old lady diagnosed with T2 just over 2 years ago. My practice tried to give me Metformin to start with, but after 6 weeks of being really ill, I said no more and opted for the diet and exercise regime. I lost 4stone in 5 months. 2 years on and I am still doing really well. I walk around 2miles a day, plus all the normal household jobs. You will find that certain food agrees with you and others dont, we are all different. Good Luck, if I could do it you certainly will be able to. Sheila.
 
Hi,

my fasting results are similar to yours, just over 7 each time.
However, the Practice Nurse said I was "borderline" and I just needed to lose weight, but that she would "treat me as Diabetic" ???

So although I'm relieved not to be on medication, or worse, sticking needles in myself, I'm a bit confused, especially after reading your post.

I'm due back mid-June for a monthly check-up, I shall go along with lots of questions as a result of finding this website/forum
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn More.…