LittleWolf
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 677
janeecee said:Right now—meaning today, at this minute—I'm not convinced that low carbing is working for me. I believe it is upping my overall BG. As of today I am increasing my daily carbs and giving my system some time to adapt. Last night's Finn Crisp experiment produced a prolonged raised BG, 5.6 @ +1, 6.1 @ +2 and still 6.1 @ +3. It was too late for another test but I was back down to a normal 5.1 abefore breakfast i.e. fasting, which was also interesting. After breakfast I was +5.8 @ +2, so not all that bothered but until last week I was almost always within +0.2 to +0.3 at 2 hours. Tested before lunch, approximately +3.5 hours after breakfast and I was 6.2. Now, this has NEVER happened. I'm almost always at fasting level by lunch time. I've never gone up after +2 hours following breakfast.
I found one explanation online, along the lines of low carbing creating insulin resistance as a result of ketosis, with the result that the second phase insulin becomes less effective. People find that not only are their FBG levels up, their post prandial readings rise after 2 hours and stay high. Their bodies produce less insulin when the glycogen stored in the liver is used up and in the absence of glucose they start breaking down fats for energy. When glucose from food enters the bloodstream, it remains in the bloodstream not being used because the body has adapted to using fat as its primary fuel source.
OK, I'm no biochemist, I'm only reporting back on the information that I've read and I make no claim as to the scientific veracity of these sources. I've summarised, more or less, the information that I've found online. So, I'm not going to argue over the merits or otherwise of which study supports which theory re low carbing. I know it helps some, but right now, I'm not convinced it's helping me.
I'm interested in how this information relates to my own experience i.e. when I cut down carbs my readings went up, when I responded by cutting carbs even more, my readings went up again. These were almost overnight jumps that occurred approximately one week later. Nothing else had changed in terms of activity levels, intercurrent illness, and I'm not feeling stressed about anything much, so I can kick that tired old catch-all excuse to the kerb.
Right so…I'm cautiously upping my daily carbs. Sensibly, an apple after lunch and that sort of thing. Yes, my levels might go higher as a consequence BUT they were going up eating fewer carbs anyway. I think (I hope) I have some headroom. What I'm interested in is restoring the second phase insulin response, assuming it has lessened. I may well be wrong, but I'll find out.
Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
janeecee said:Today has been interesting.
I started with a fasting BG of 5.2, had an almost identical breakfast to yesterday's and was 5.4 at +2 hours, compared with yesterday's 5.9. Before lunch I was still 5.4 which was better than yesterday's surprising 6.2. So far, so good. I seemed to be returning to my previous pattern.
Lunch wasn't so good. A somewhat worrying 7.6 at +2 hours although today's lunch was lower in protein and fat compared with yesterday's lunch, which gave me 6.8 at +2 hours. I would hazard a guess that my usual lunch would have given me a lower reading. How much lower, I don't know, maybe closer to yesterday's but even that reading was about +1.0 higher than I was getting until last week or so. I'll find out tomorrow.
I don't typically take 3 hour readings but in this instance I am concerned about whether my second phase is responding as it should as this can be diminished by low carbing and ketosis according to the information I have read. (Once again, not claiming any expertise). My 3 hour reading today was 5.8 compared with yesterday's 6.0, so both quite similar. I won't test again until before dinner.
I think it's too soon to say anything about increasing carbs, just that I'm aiming for approximately 100g total carbs per day. Yesterday I consumed 118g. Today's estimate looks like 98g. I don't want to spike up too much after dinner, because I feel my system needs time to adjust. Of course, all this assumes that my guess about low carbing leading to insulin resistance is correct in my case—I always feel the need to stress I could be wrong, and I may well be.
BTW, I tested for ketones this morning. I showed a trace but this is probably normal as I hadn't eaten for 15 hours. I had zero ketones this afternoon, so no ketosis.
Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
gezzathorpe said:Silly question probably, but how do you test for ketones? Is there a kit or test strip or something?
Ambersilva said:gezzathorpe said:Silly question probably, but how do you test for ketones? Is there a kit or test strip or something?
Some of us have meters that test blood for ketone levels as well as for glucose levels.
janeecee said:Gezzathorpe, I'm using Ketostix to test my urine. You can get them from the chemist. My meter can also read ketones but the strips are rather expensive.
Update:
My pre-dinner reading was down to 4.8 which is actually around what I was getting for the previous week or two before my BGs jumped up. I didn't want to carb up any more for today. I wanted to see what my reading would be after a dinner that I have had before and knew what to expect (or at least I THOUGHT I knew :lol: ). My reading was 6.3 at +2 hours. Previously I've had 6.5 or thereabouts with this dinner so I was pleasantly surprised to be just a tad lower than what I was getting before—but really, it's more or less the same given the old caveats about meters.
So, what do I reckon so far? I still think it's too soon to tell. This is only day 2 of 'carbing up' and this blood glucose malarky is not an exact science. I must admit, I was very pleased to see that my preprandial was back down this evening and also that my post prandial was in line. At this stage I have no idea whether this evening's readings are just a flash in the pan. I had high hopes after observing that my breakfast readings were approaching my previous pattern but my post lunch figure was a downer. It did come down, though, and to a greater extent than yesterday—although different meals have different after effects so I need to bear that in mind. Reality check and all that.
All in all, it's been an interesting day. Tomorrow may tell another story.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?