Based on the information provided there is no reason to believe your consultant is wrong. All the diagnoses you have been given were reasonable based on the information that was available at the time of that diagnosis. The most recent one is based on the largest amount of evidence and is most likely correct. The GADA and islet antibody tests are not conclusive as there are false negatives in a significant number of cases. If you were T2, ketosis prone or not, you would expect a C-peptide at the high end of the range and a high insulin resistance leading to a high insulin requirement. Your requirement of 10u/day (after initial stabilisation of DKA) is typical of a honeymooning newly diagnosed T1.