Richard Dawkins - Letter to his daughter

You've gotta love that final sentence

And, next time somebody tells you that something
is true, why not say to them: 'What kind of evidence is there for that?' And if they
can't give you a good answer, I hope you'll think very carefully before you believe a
word they say.

Click to expand...

Thanks for the link, Dillinger.

Geoff

+1 Geoff!

.. and thanks for the link Dillinger

Richard Dawkins should rule the world.

Thank you for posting this letter.

Quote: "Now that you are ten"

If only more "grown-ups" lived by this beautiful, sensible, intelligent approach; the whiff of war in the world would gradually dissipate.

Amen!

Brilliant :!:
What a thought-provoking letter.

Angie

Where is the evidence for the "50% carbohydrate diet", the "food pyramid", or the "Eatwell plate". It's all just religious dogma.

Dawkins makes me mad and makes me laugh at the same time. Whereas I agree that some matters demand evidence [I am after all a scientist myself] and that evidence needs testing. There are matters which depend on faith. [I am a convinced Christian]
Dawkins, despite his intellect doesn't seem to grasp the differences. He's an atheist of the worst sort. he belittles people of faith regularly and yet I've always suspected that he is afraid of God. Why else would he be so violently anti?
As to children making up their own minds. Doesn't his way work against that? Are his children not distanced from ideas offaith and belief and not given a chance to find something there that might enrich their lives?
As to children saying things like" We Muslims believe..."
I expect a child when asked about magnets to say"the magnet attracts metals" I don't expect a treatise on magnetic fields and forces or a list of which metals are ferromagnetic. Equally I believe that as children grow in faith, they come to understand why they believe. The "Why" of science isn't understandable by everybody as the "Why" of Faith isn't.
Ask an NHS dietician about a diet for diabetes and what you get is a belief system NOT an analysis of evidence.
Dawkins Go figure.
Hana

hanadr said:

I've always suspected that he is afraid of God.

Click to expand...

For Dawkins, or any other avowed atheist, to be afraid of God would, by definition, make them not an atheist. I think that a more likely explanation is that he is angry at the liberties taken in the name of religion.

I can concur with a lot of what Dawkins says in that letter.

hanadr said:

I expect a child when asked about magnets to say"the magnet attracts metals" I don't expect a treatise on magnetic fields and forces or a list of which metals are ferromagnetic. Equally I believe that as children grow in faith, they come to understand why they believe.

Click to expand...

I'd expect a child to work out that magnets attract (some) metals by empirical observation, not because someone told them it was true. That's the whole point.

borofergie
I rarely disagree with you and I'm not doing so now.
You are simply restating my points. I do think that Dawkins believes himself to be an atheist, but has a niggle in the back of his mind that here could be something.
My late mother in law was an avowed atheist. She never felt any need to push her point of view on to anyone else, although she could hold her own in an academic discussion without demeaning the other party. She "knew" there is no God, so didn't see any reason to argue about it. Interestingly, both her sons and several of her grandchildren have become active in church matters.
And as to children and magnets. The children use the evidence of their eyes. Or at least the ones I taught did
Hana

hanadr said:

I do think that Dawkins believes himself to be an atheist, but has a niggle in the back of his mind that here could be something.

Click to expand...

Funny think, beliefs. We all have them - but it seems that the stronger certain people hold their own, the less likely they are to allow others to do the same...

Patch said:

Funny think, beliefs. We all have them - but it seems that the stronger certain people hold their own, the less likely they are to allow others to do the same...

Click to expand...

:thumbup:

Afterthought: If, on your deathbed, all of your beliefs are proven to be incorrect, what have you lost in believing them all of your life?

Absolutely nothing. Aren't beliefs great!

Beliefs ARE great! If you have them then woohoo for you...Have at 'em.
However beliefs based on fear are not great; and aren't religious beliefs fundamentally based on what will happen if you err from the path? Do christians not live in the fear of god?

Viv
. It's part of my belief that The Higher Being offers infinite forgiveness to all those who truly repent of their sins. That certainly isn't anything to scare me. I would seriously doubt the depth of faith of anyone who felt it their right or even obligation to harm another being.
and what about those who would kill to protect their beliefs? Those Iwould class as unbelievers.
So NOT all belief is based on fear!
Hana

I was listening to a debate on the radio a few years back about people believing/not believing in God, they interviewed a Vicar who said that those who went through life as atheists often changed their mind when on their deathbeds.