Thanks for the responses everyone -- it feels better knowing that I'm not alone in this. So far my approach has been a generic lower-calorie diet -- I've been using the myfitness pal app, set to lose half a pound a week which allows me around 1,800 calories a day. Like Ruth B says, I've been going more steady than anything because I really want to lose the weight for goof this time. Historically, I've lost the same 40-50 lbs THREE times but have always gained it back. (I was even contemplating trying the diet from the Newcastle study but I have a feeling I'd go "wild" once the 8 weeks were "finished".)
That said, I haven't been watching carbs as close as I should and now is obviously the time to start. I've had conflicting accounts of how much I should eat, so I suppose it does just depend on the individual. My previous GP said 3 meals at or below 45g and 3 snacks at or below 15g. The diabetic nurse says 3 snacks at 10g and then 30g for breakfast, 30-60 for lunch and dinner (if dinner is 60g, lunch should be closer to 30) etc. To be honest, I don't know how realistic it would be for me to follow the nurse's plan...isn't a small apple around 12g carbohydrate?
Here's a typical "good" day....for a bad day, add 500-1,000 calories of random rubbish during a binge session :|
Breakfast: Porridge OR toast (typically burgen) with peanut butter or bagel (time to throw these out) w/ cream cheese and fruit -- typically strawberries. Could switch to making own porridge with the larger oats? Finding I get a post-breakfast high so obviously need to cut the carbs but I struggle finding things I a) have time to prepare and b) fancy in the morning
AM snack: Seed or fruit bar (like 9 bar or Nakd) , or fruit with piece of cheese, or around 2x per week 1 homemade biscuit or small muffin, possible with latte type coffee. Could switch the coffee to regular to reduce carbs from milk?
Lunch: Tbsp Hummus w/ carrot batons, 30g cheese w/ 4 water crackers, fruit (apple or grapes) and "healthy" yogurt. OR sandwich w/ quorn (only if haven't had bread with breakfast) or smaller portion of leftovers. I'm not a big fan of natural yogurt but I think I'll try mixing it with my fruit, as a lot of the healthy yogurts seem to have a lot of hidden carbs
PM snack: 25g cashew or almond nuts, OR small portion of chocolate (typically a fredo but I could switch this up to dark choc)
Dinner: Typically something like Spag bol made with quorn mince and 50g dried pasta, or BBQ'd chicken (cooking method, not BBG sauce) with half a pouch of tilda rice and salad, or breaded chicken breast with caesar salad.
Eve snack: Still trying to figure out whether this is best eaten with main meal or a couple hours after -- haven't yet figured out the effect it has on my fasting sugars. Typically might be a mini ice cream (eg. twister) or tinned peaches w/ a little cream or homemade baked product. I could eat something "bad" at 10.30pm at night and have a low (for me) fasting sugar the next day, or have a really good day overall and not eat anything after 6.30 and get a high reading. Doesn't seem to be any rhyme or reason.
Anyway - suggestions would be most welcome!!!!