Metformin is a pretty safe medication with few side effects. The worst being the famous digestive upsets.Metformin SR is less irritant.
A study comparing Metformin with a placebo, doesn't tell you anything about comparing Metformin to diet and exercise.
If your blood glucose is fairly easy to control, then diet alone may be enough. If you need to be strict on carbs, Metformin will help.
I'm pretty sure that I could manage without Metformin, but I'd have to be 100% on diet. I opt to be about 95% strict and take 2 x 500
mg Metformin per day. that's 10 years after diagnosis.
Essentially everyone must make their own decisions on what suits them and what helps. Even maximum dose Metformin doesn't reduce B G very much, which is why many people move on to other medications.
Hana