Pretty much agree with all of that.
Except that very low calorie diet or fasting is not misery for me. I never feel better than during or just after a period of fasting. BG levels are always at their best. I have more energy, less arthritic pain, and better sleep, and none of the 'brain fog' that I have when eating the recommended calorie intake.
You still don't understand what some of us are saying. We aren't choosing to stay T2 we are still T2 and that's a fact! The VLC diet is not a cure for all of us. I would suggest that it only works for those of us who had a truly awful diet before diagnosis. I did not. I was lowish carbing even before diagnosis. The misery of the VLC diet for me was afterwards when I had lost some weight but nothing else had changed. Still T2. Think of it, these diets have been around for many years, if they really worked for the masses would there be an increase in T2 now?So basically you're benchmarking other people's choices against your own personal values which are entirely subjective. For example, personally, I find the idea of choosing to stay a T2 Diabetic in order to avoid the "misery of a VLC diet" (misery is a personal frame of reference) an utterly abhorrent choice. But only for me personally, so if that's someone else's choice then the very best of luck to you. Vive la difference
Holds up his hands and still an HbA1c of 33. I eat what and when I want and that includes bags of liquorice, jelly beans, mints, dried apricots, dates, figs, oat and honey cake with strawberry icing (yesterday's delight) shop cookies etcI haven't heard of anyone in this situation. An occasional slice of cake, yes. Two slices of seeded bread per day. Roast potatoes for dinner almost daily. I've seen people on here talk about making these choices and still having non-diabetic BG. But having 50% starchy carbs day in day out (as per the healthy plate / food pyramid)? Cereal and toast for breakfast, sandwich and crisps for lunch and meat and potatoes for dinner, snacking on fruit and occasional sweets? For many people this is a normal diet. But for someone who has "reversed" T2D? Would it really stay reversed?
If you or someone you know has achieved this, please share.
I used to love VLC diets, they gave me energy whilst doing them. All that happened though was that my metabolism adjusted to a lower level of food intake and I survived on less and less.I believe @zand feels the same.
My experience, both of fasting and very low calorie diets is that I hit a kind of 'fasting high' but that it is a very narrow zone of comfort, and my stamina is shot. Even climbing stairs is intimidating. And, for me, the Hunger never dies. It is like a permanent grinding ache.
I quite envy you.But then my body gets the same benefits from LCHF, so maybe it is just a basic difference in personal physiology - which has been the main recurring theme of this thread. lol.
But you have always accepted that despite all your magnificent efforts you were lucky that it worked for you. You haven't thought less of me because it didn't work for me. Some of the born again dieters now seem to imply that the rest of us are lesser human beings because these methods don't work for us. We must be weak minded individuals with no will power. Nope. Our bodies just don't work like yours that's all.Holds up his hands and still an HbA1c of 33. I eat what and when I want and that includes bags of liquorice, jelly beans, mints, dried apricots, dates, figs, oat and honey cake with strawberry icing (yesterday's delight) shop cookies etc
This is why I used to get upset with all the nay sayers but now I let it wash over me. I know what my body is capable of again and that is all that matters to me. Will it stay like this, I doubt it as when I age I am sure it will start to pack up again but until that point I will push it as much as I want
but I don't have thyroid issues thankfully. There are so many reasons for D to strike. Some we may be able to just get in early and have a large impact on; as for others who knows. Losing weight does and will not work for all but should help reduce insulin resistance. How we lose weight is a difficult question to answer as it is personal to your genes and the capability of your body to use what it has.
When they understand the differnet causes of T2 we will end up with subclasses I am sure. Just look at the MODY work that is finding new genes all the time.
BTW Zand I thought you are doing great with LCHF and your fat fasts
Thank you for your response! I have seen your posts before, but have misunderstood them (my own personal bias, obviously) to mean that you can eat all those carbs *occasionally*, rather than regularly, without it affecting your BG. Thanks for clarifying it for me, and congratulations on your success!Holds up his hands and still an HbA1c of 33. I eat what and when I want and that includes bags of liquorice, jelly beans, mints, dried apricots, dates, figs, oat and honey cake with strawberry icing (yesterday's delight) shop cookies etc
This is why I used to get upset with all the nay sayers but now I let it wash over me. I know what my body is capable of again and that is all that matters to me. Will it stay like this, I doubt it as when I age I am sure it will start to pack up again but until that point I will push it as much as I want
not as great as you!but I don't have thyroid issues thankfully. There are so many reasons for D to strike. Some we may be able to just get in early and have a large impact on; as for others who knows. Losing weight does and will not work for all but should help reduce insulin resistance. How we lose weight is a difficult question to answer as it is personal to your genes and the capability of your body to use what it has.
When they understand the differnet causes of T2 we will end up with subclasses I am sure. Just look at the MODY work that is finding new genes all the time.
BTW Zand I thought you are doing great with LCHF and your fat fasts
I do periods to keep me in check. I will do serveral weeks (6 months was my longest leading up to last HbA1c) of high carb and them go to intermittent fasting for a few weeks and then low carb for a period (not too low any more). I find I start to add weight when on higher carb periods. I like my nuts and with high carb can be enlargeningThank you for your response! I have seen your posts before, but have misunderstood them (my own personal bias, obviously) to mean that you can eat all those carbs *occasionally*, rather than regularly, without it affecting your BG. Thanks for clarifying it for me, and congratulations on your success!
I understand the stuck weight I cannot get below 12st 5lbs by normal fasting so I think this is my bodies natural level. This is what I used to be as a fit 20 something when I used to cycle many hundreds of miles each week. I did manage with huge effort to hit 12st but bounced straight back.not as great as you!The weight has been stuck for a long time now. I'm trying to go low cal for a while and also finding different exercises to do as the walking doesn't do much anymore. Maybe I'll get my head round the 800 cal diet again sometime soon, I'll keep you posted. If I do though it will be simply for weight loss, I am not expecting a cure.
Except me? I have to come with proof and references to support my opinions otherwise they add nothing to the thread? My observations and subjective interpretations and evaluations of those observations must be backed by scientific study. Whereas you - you're allowed to just have an opinion.Consequently, I am totally comfortable with commenting from my personal experience and letting other people make up their own minds.
I do, I have not suggested there is a reversal option for all. I have even spelled that out. What I am rejecting is that a reversal option does not exist because it doesn't work for all. Even if only 1% of T2 diabetics can achieve reversal that's worth knowing about.You still don't understand what some of us are saying.
I slipped on ice and fractured my wrist in two places. I was told by a doctor and three people who had each sustained a single fracture to a wrist, that I would never recover full function. Of course I didn't believe them and with diligent application of appropriate exercises (that I wasn't told about at the hospital but had to find out about for myself) I did recover full function. Not only that I didn't turn up for my cast appointment and returned to the hospital 9 days later to demonstrate that my wrist had already healed sufficiently to continue with a brace not a cast. You see we can aim higher than accepting the fate other people before us have accepted.Hang on though, @SunnyExpat . That broken leg analogy has a flaw. Broken leg may heal well with treatment, but will never be as good as before.
Yes of course it's worth knowing about. I was naïve and thought I would be cured and would be able to eat my favourite foods again. It didn't happen but my HbA1c's are now at pre-diabetic levels and I have found many new favourite foods. It just took a bit longer then the 8 weeks I was hoping for back in 2011/12.I do, I have not suggested there is a reversal option for all. I have even spelled that out. What I am rejecting is that a reversal option does not exist because it doesn't work for all. Even if only 1% of T2 diabetics can achieve reversal that's worth knowing about.
Except me? I have to come with proof and references to support my opinions otherwise they add nothing to the thread? My observations and subjective interpretations and evaluations of those observations must be backed by scientific study. Whereas you - you're allowed to just have an opinion.
The bottom line is I have not "promoted a theory" I've offered my interpretation of data that has been heavily discussed on this forum and elsewhere for years. I've met people 'in the real world' who have followed the diets promoted by those studies and have ceased having a diabetic response. I have read about other people who have ceased having diabetic responses. My understanding is there are numerous people on this very forum who, whichever word they choose to describe their circumstances, have ceased having a diabetic response.
So whilst reversal may not be an option for you have you considered that there are people who would like to explore this as a first option. You know those people who can be bothered to endure "the misery of a VLC diet" because they'd take healthy over sick every day of the week EVEN if it meant a little bit of effort.
So by all means have your opinion but stop being so bloody demanding when it comes to the opinions of people who happen to disagree with you.
There are people who have exhibited diabetic responses for years, who then go on to follow specific diets, such as the Newcastle Diet, lose lots of weight and lose their diabetic response. I have met people who had much worse blood readings than me who followed the newcastle diet, or a close derivative, lost a few stone and completely lost their diabetic response.As far as I'm aware there is no cure as such, just good control.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?