'I lost 8st on my GP's low-carb diet programme'

pdmjoker

Well-Known Member
Messages
426
Type of diabetes
Prediabetes
Treatment type
Diet only

From article:
===
Sue Myerscough, 72, from East Morton, near Keighley, used to weigh 19 stone before taking part on the Type 2 diabetes "reversal programme" at her surgery.

The eating plan, which involves cutting out foods like potato and pasta, is different to the standard NHS programme, which is based on a low-calorie approach.

Dr Jackie Craven, who has helped almost 600 patients at the Modality Practice since introducing the low-carb programme six years ago, said they'd seen "fantastic results".

Mrs Myerscough has been living with Type 2 diabetes for 27 years and was struggling with mobility and pain when she began the course in February 2022.

...

The NHS has said its [low calorie] programme is "effective" and can work "successfully to improve people's diabetes control".

However, Dr Craven said in her experience low-calorie diets "do work" but can be difficult to maintain because it is a "starvation diet".

"With the low-carb approach they feel fuller for longer with a high protein, high-fat diet", she said.

Dr Craven said the patients on their programme were closely monitored and the higher levels of fat in the diet had not led to problems.

"On average, patients' cholesterol levels were staying the same or reducing - and when we look at those patients whose levels had risen, the 'bad fats' have significantly reduced."
 

pdmjoker

Well-Known Member
Messages
426
Type of diabetes
Prediabetes
Treatment type
Diet only
Note: the BBC article continues:
===
The charity Diabetes UK said: "Low-calorie diet programmes that include total meal replacement products and full support from a healthcare team have the strongest evidence for putting Type 2 diabetes in remission, but other approaches such as low-carb diets can also help some people lose weight and go into remission."
===

That's puzzling, since according to the NHS Confederation website:

Dr David Unwin is an award-winning GP known for pioneering the low-carb approach in the UK. He is the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) national champion for collaborative care and support planning in obesity and diabetes. He also won the NHS Innovator of the Year Award 2016 for his research into diet and lifestyle interventions. He has worked at Norwood Surgery in Southport since 1986 as a family doctor. To date, he has helped 141 patients achieve drug free, type 2 diabetes remission (achieving a remission rate of 51 per cent).

Does Low-calorie (with support) have a better than 51% success rate?