Haha. I'm not suggesting that's what you or anyone else should be eating, rather it was just an example that stuck in my mind of something that was quite low carb (in % terms) but was way over what most would consider low carb by the time you consider the portion size.Ah - it depends on the definition of food - something in a plastic tray or pot heated up in a microwave fails on several levels
Lots of people have a daily amount of carbs as a target so, if the meal you mentioned was the main meal of the day, 36g may not actually be that high if all the other meals were vlc. The useful thing about the percentage method is that it tells you how much of that particular food you can eat.Haha. I'm not suggesting that's what you or anyone else should be eating, rather it was just an example that stuck in my mind of something that was quite low carb (in % terms) but was way over what most would consider low carb by the time you consider the portion size.
My point still remains than total carbs is a more accurate benchmark for low carb than percentage, but if that works for you (and others) that's great. For folk that are new to this though it's probably not great advice given my example above and would rule out quite a lot of other things that were perfectly fine to have (or at least try)
Carb % is useful to work out what portion size you could manage and I do it myself too, but the poster I responded to stated that they didn't eat ANYTHING over 10% carbs. I'm not saying it's not useful for some, just that automatically rejecting foods that are above some arbitrary carb % regardless of the actual portion size (and therefore total carb content) could mean folk are rejecting foods that could be eaten with no problems at all.Lots of people have a daily amount of carbs as a target so, if the meal you mentioned was the main meal of the day, 36g may not actually be that high if all the other meals were vlc. The useful thing about the percentage method is that it tells you how much of that particular food you can eat.
I agree and, whilst I eat low carb , I would be quite happy to eat something 20% carbs if I was only having a very small portion of it and also that I knew it not to be a food that spiked me. Personally, I don`t like to have to stick to rules too rigidly but I realise that some people find that this kind of discipline helps them enormously. Each to their own I sayCarb % is useful to work out what portion size you could manage and I do it myself too, but the poster I responded to stated that they didn't eat ANYTHING over 10% carbs. I'm not saying it's not useful for some, just that automatically rejecting foods that are above some arbitrary carb % regardless of the actual portion size (and therefore total carb content) could mean folk are rejecting foods that could be eaten with no problems at all.
To compare another example - my wife picked up some soy bean 'spaghetti' the other day for me to try. According to the pack, it's about 16% carbs, but the serving size is 50g - so carbs per portion is around 8g. If this is eaten with some fish/chicken and some veg it would likely be much less carbs than the ready meal mentioned in the previous post but would automatically be rejected using the <10% rule and the ready meal would be considered OK (from a carb only point of view, regardless of whether one considers it real food or not).
I don't buy any ready meals now, you don't really know what's in them, fresh fish or meat is much better..I've seen a few folks say they stick to foods that are less than a certain percentage of carbs, but surely the total carbs is more important than the percentage?
For example, I was checking the labels on a ready meal in a supermarket the other day and it was around 9g carbs per 100g. So going by your <10% rule it seems OK. However, the pack size was 400g so the total carbs were nearly 40g. For someone low-carbing that seems pretty high.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?