My issue with the Bernstein method is the damnable Gluconeogenesis process that means that even without carbs, managing BG level is a little more hit and miss. The most frustrating thing is that I end up injecting a lot - MDI for me is more like 2x Basal and 8x Bolus as I sugar surf and try and even out the protein rises. Maybe I do need a third pen of "regular".as he calls it, for Protein use. Whilst I'm okay at remaining in the 4-7.5 band, only reaching 5.6 post prandial needs to reduce the protein amounts I eat significantly, which doesn't work with the amount of time I spend in the gym!
I also don't understand why scoring a post prandial of >5.6 mmol/l is more of an issue for a diabetic than a non-diabetic, who will generally be higher than 5.6 post prandial as well.
My goal is to contribute to this thread in 11 months time!
Low carbed on and off for over 10 years but never managed to make last for a year+
I'm glad I'm not the only one following his suggestions... for how good his advice sounds, it seems a lot of people finds it restrictive and hard to comply with. To me the only thing that ever worked to loose weight was to restrict carbs exactly to the levels that his method proposes, so I am kind of used to how to keep myself on track.
I am so far finding it easier to follow his rules just cause I feel motivated by my numbers. I am not new to low carb, but I think his suggestion about keeping portions consistent everyday is important as I feel it keeps the number within the range I want them the to be.
I am not very patient either... but I am thinking now that this will have to last for a lifetime if I want to keep myself healthy and away from complications.
I had a small box of dark chocolates held for me tonight. Picking it up in the morning. Holidays are such a trigger for me.
I've been thinking about how I ate growing up...not that different from the LCHF diet I'm on now, just more restrictive. Each day is a bit easier than the last. I feel like I've been eating better each year. This diet just feels right to me.
Today, my three other books arrived: two Adkin's books and the Gary Taubes book, Why We Are Fat, the latter I've talked my husband into reading. I think I'm going to take a break from the Bernstein book and read the Adkins Diabetes Revolution book. Not sure what Adkin's contribution was to it though, as it was published in 2004, after his death. The book cover states "Based on the medical practice of Robert C. Atkins, M.D., with Mary C. Vernon, M.D., C.M.D., and Jacqueline A. Eberstein, R.N."
I have a lot of questions about this diet. Like how much is too much fat and protein? And can I keep adding more vegetables? Hoping this book will catch me up. For now I think I'll alternate between this book and the "Bernstein Diabetes University" videos.
I had a small box of dark chocolates held for me tonight. Picking it up in the morning. Holidays are such a trigger for me.
I've been thinking about how I ate growing up...not that different from the LCHF diet I'm on now, just more restrictive. Each day is a bit easier than the last. I feel like I've been eating better each year. This diet just feels right to me.
Today, my three other books arrived: two Adkin's books and the Gary Taubes book, Why We Are Fat, the latter I've talked my husband into reading. I think I'm going to take a break from the Bernstein book and read the Adkins Diabetes Revolution book. Not sure what Adkin's contribution was to it though, as it was published in 2004, after his death. The book cover states "Based on the medical practice of Robert C. Atkins, M.D., with Mary C. Vernon, M.D., C.M.D., and Jacqueline A. Eberstein, R.N."
I have a lot of questions about this diet. Like how much is too much fat and protein? And can I keep adding more vegetables? Hoping this book will catch me up. For now I think I'll alternate between this book and the "Bernstein Diabetes University" videos.
I think Bernstein has it right about keeping the portions consistent while Atkins tells you to eat freely of the permitted foods and some people interprets that as eating tons of protein and that can be counterproductive in the weight loss front after a while.
For me that's never been a problem as I think low carb diets with sufficient fat and protein are self regulatory, I just feel satisfied much faster and with less food than when eating carbs.
However, I believe that after loosing all the weight I need to lose, I will take the Atkins approach of increasing the amount of carbs by 5grms a day per week to test how many carbs I tolerate and which carbs spike me the most... what amounts, etc.
Atkins suggest to keep carbs below 20grms a day at induction while Bernstein says 30grms... I am currently under 30grms as I feel satisfied and can't just eat if I don't feel hungry anymore.
mehhh2015, thanks for saying this. I think I ate too much for a couple of days, then didn't eat enough these last two days. I'm not sure what the right portions are for me yet. Will work on it. Tonight I went on a bit of a binge. Figured out that cream cheese tastes wonderful next to a pickle wrapped in a slice of ham.
mehhh2015, thanks for saying this. I think I ate too much for a couple of days, then didn't eat enough these last two days. I'm not sure what the right portions are for me yet. Will work on it. Tonight I went on a bit of a binge. Figured out that cream cheese tastes wonderful next to a pickle wrapped in a slice of ham.
Not read Adkins book, but to my knowledge it is not specifically for diabetics whereas Bernstein is.
That is the critical diff' bernstein is an acknowledged diabetic expert and is himself a t1 for decades, disregard his advice at your peril .Not read Adkins book, but to my knowledge it is not specifically for diabetics whereas Bernstein is.
That is the critical diff' bernstein is an acknowledged diabetic expert and is himself a t1 for decades, disregard his advice at your peril .
You are doing well, keep up the good work , all i'm saying is dr bernstein is the acknowledged expert, and we all have our own personal ways that we choose to add :)
Exactly , dr bernsteins sage advice is not restrictive just advice!I thought it would be nice to add this quotation from Dr. Bersteins book so people don't feel dogmatized or uneccesarily limited to very restritive food choices:
" One purpose of blood glucose self-monitoring is to learn through your blood sugar profiles how particular foods affects you. Blood sugar self monitoring is the ultimate measure of the effect foods have on your blood sugar. If you don't believe what you are reading here, check your blood sugars every two hours after consuming food your are certain must be bening. Over the years of examining profiles like the ones you will create, I've observed that some people are more tolerant of certain foods than other people. For example, bread makes my own blood sugar rise very rapidly. Yet one or two of my patients with mild type 2 diabetes eat a sandwich of thin bread everyday with only minor problems. Inevitably I find this is related to delayed stomach-emptying. In any case, you should feel free to experiment with food and then perform blood sugar readings. It's likely that for many diabetics most or all of our restrictions will be necessary" Bersteins Diabetic Solution. (my own highlights).
I've got to say... wheat (in the form of bread and little pretzels), followed by sugar (that I had in half a little mocha the other day), are the worst offenders I have found over the last month (spiking me over 7's)... and I am not intending to go back there as its simply not worthy. I noticed the BG's after this occasions took a while before going back in order. But my aubergines and my boiled sweet potatoes made no difference during the day or the next...
I haven't experimented with anything else and therefore I'm away from all other forms of starches and sugars, however I would like to know if I can tolerate them, and if so, how much and which ones I can... but it will only work once I have reached my weight goal and got rid of the belly fat that exacerbates my insulin resistance.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?