Provisional Licence refused - dvla

marktw

Member
Messages
10
I dont know if this has happend to anyone else who has applied for a provisonal licence or if anyone knows of someone it has happened to

We sent off the aplication form for my sons provisional licence, ticking the box that he is a type 1 diabetic and obviously on insulin.We received back fm DVLA the diab1 medical form that we filled in, ticking the boxes where it asked what type of diabetes you have and yes to - do you regularly monitor yr blood glucose. yes to have you experienced hypos. yes to recognise hypos etc, and ticking no to the box that asks have you had a disabling hypo attck in the past 12 months that needd to be treated by someone else.

He does have the occasional hypo, recognises them, treats them and tests at least 4 times a day, and has never had a hypo that needed treating by anyone else. We also gave details of his consultant and our gp giving DVLA permisson to contact them for any additional information then posted this back and waited for his licence to come through

Last wednesday my son received a letter fm the DVLA stating that he had been refused a licence on condiiton of his diabetes and i quote fm the letter:

"it is clear fm the info received that your condition affects your ability to control a veh safely at all times and that modified controls or an autojatic gearbox would not overcome this. If and when your condition improves to a degree that it no longer affects safe driving, with or without special controls or a restricion to an automatic gearbox, a reapplicain would be welcome"

further in the letter is states
"if your GP or Specialist can provide any additional information abour your condition that shows, in their view, that you can meet the reqd medical standards, pse forward the information to me as soon as possible"

So my son wasnt best pleased when he opened it up and read that especially the bit about his condition improving. He has freinds in college and who he has met on duk holidays who are learning to drive at the moment and didnt have any problems getting a provisional licence

It appears that the letters are a bog standard reply, printed off and even a printed signature on them. they have not consulted my sons consultant or gp to get additional information as we have been in touch with his consultant and he has said that DVLA have not contacted him, so we have an appointment to see him on 28 Jul, (it appears that want us to do the leg work for them), taking along the chapter 3 to the "at a glance guide to medical standards of fitness to drive for medical practitioners (inf188/2)" because reading that he meets the requirements to be able to drive

We can of course go to a Magistrates court to appeal the decision, which i would love to do, just to get the people who signes the letter(s) into court to ask them some questions of thier expertse in diabetes as well as their medical background and how they cme to make the decsisions, but unfortunately i dont think i could afford to

It makes me wonder if they have to reject so many a year to make out they are doing their job, when as mentioned earlier his friends have had no problems obtaiing a licence. Maybe i should write a letter under the freedom of information and ask how many Type 1 Diabetics they refuse for a provisional licence. It also make you wonder why ask for contact details of consultants/gps etc as well as giving permission for them to contact them is they are not going to.

anyway apologies for the long post but it would be interesting to see if any other 17 year olds have had this problem obtatinig a provisional licence or not
 

Snodger

Well-Known Member
Messages
787
Is he just applying for an ordinary licence (not one for lorries or buses etc?) Because if so, it sounds to me as if you've run up against a pen-pusher at the DVLA who just doesn't know what they are doing. I remember a while ago I had a delayed renewal because I was honest and said I had experienced hypos (not severe ones), they asked for a doc's report but then did renew. And as I understood it, the DVLA is meant to be becoming MORE flexible, not less, on this issue.
I don't know if you've tried ringing Diabetes UK careline but they might be able to advise? More info here:
http://www.diabetes.org.uk/Guide-to-dia ... s/Driving/
 

marktw

Member
Messages
10
Yea its just his car licence he applying for, nothing else. Think they want the letter from his consultant to say hes okay to drive, if thats the case why not put it on the applicaiton form to say you need a letter etc to go along with it instead of this long winded way.
 

RussG

Well-Known Member
Messages
401
I would tend to agree with Snodger (as I often do!). It may also be that his consultant hadn't written back in time, perhaps or the reply got lost. Does the letter outline an appeal / complaint process?
 

iHs

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,595
Hi

Am a bit confused about the mention of an automatic gearbox. Whether someone drives a vehicle using manual or automatic gearbox has got nothing to do with being able to drive safely as an insulin dependant diabetic.
 

marktw

Member
Messages
10
yea, it was a bit strange. It looks like a computer printed bog standard reply, just fill in name, reference etc. no realy reason why it was refused just the para that i quoted in my post
 

marktw

Member
Messages
10
the letter says we can appeal via the magistrates court, or if we can provide any medical evidence to say that he is okay to drive then to resubmit it with a new application for a licence. I think they want his consultant to say hes okay to drive. His consultant said that he hadnt received anything from dvla regarding his application
 

noblehead

Guru
Retired Moderator
Messages
23,618
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Pump
Dislikes
Disrespectful people
Very odd Mark as I am surprised that the DVLA has not already wrote to your lads gp or consultant and asked for a report on his diabetes (i.e control or any problems with diabetic retinopathy etc) if your son is just recently diagnosed then this may explain why they have refused his license on this occasion, failing that then ask his gp or diabetes specialist to support his application and reapply/appeal..

Nigel
 

marktw

Member
Messages
10
he was diagnosed apr 2008 just before his 14th birthday. He did miss his last transisition clinic as he was on a geography trip, hence his consultant wanting to see him next week before he writes anything. Just think dvla want it coming fm his consultant that hes okay for a licence, just annoying when he has friends who havent had any probs, but dont know how long they have been diagnosed
 

noblehead

Guru
Retired Moderator
Messages
23,618
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Pump
Dislikes
Disrespectful people
marktw said:
he was diagnosed apr 2008 just before his 14th birthday. He did miss his last transisition clinic as he was on a geography trip, hence his consultant wanting to see him next week before he writes anything. Just think dvla want it coming fm his consultant that hes okay for a licence, just annoying when he has friends who havent had any probs, but dont know how long they have been diagnosed

Appreciate what your saying Mark, perhaps when he attends the clinic in the next few weeks he can discuss this issue with his consultant.

Good luck and hope he is successful!

Nigel
 

bowell

Well-Known Member
Messages
945
Dislikes
Tablets, Mums with pushchair who push in ,Bus and WC
Am a bit confused about the mention of an automatic gearbox

Must be a standard letter as automatic gearbox is a good fix for a lot of physical disability's

I had to be assessed and my license came back
Only Automatic gearbox and adapted steering wheel (nob fitted)
I then lost use of second leg ,Changed to Auto with hand operated brake

Later license Removed due to the amount of Pain Medication ,being spaced out most of the time 8)


Bob
 

Snodger

Well-Known Member
Messages
787
yes, I thought that too - which also suggests the dvla didn't really look at the individual form, just chucked it in the general 'no' pile.
bowell, I *love* your steampunk profile pic.
 

Snodger

Well-Known Member
Messages
787
Snodger said:
yes, I thought that too - which also suggests the dvla didn't really look at the individual form, just chucked it in the general 'no' pile.

RussG said:
I would tend to agree with Snodger (as I often do!).
aw thanks RussG.

bowell, I *love* your steampunk profile pic.
 

spideog

Well-Known Member
Messages
164
Sounds like you ticked all the same boxes as I have always ticked, but have never had an issue with getting the license renewed. I'm doubtful that they have ever contacted my consultant either as until recently I was seeing consultants in Ireland and getting the UK driving license, but the new one always came back far too quickly for there to have ever been any kind of communication going on between the DVLA and the medical types. Also if the consultant in Ireland had ever had to be writing letters to the DVLA in the UK then I'd most likely have been charged for the pleasure at some point over the years.