Which is best. More Basal or more Bolus?

ickihun

Master
Messages
13,698
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Bullies
When I inject is a certain area of tum I feel it trickling to a certain area. I guess to lowest point of gravity, near enough.
When I inject standing up I get a bit leakage. Not when sedate. Anyone else noticed that?
Some needles definitely cheaper than others given on my prescription over the years.
 

ickihun

Master
Messages
13,698
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Bullies
I use my basal to keep me steady through the night and bolus during the day. My basal is long gone by morning.
If I took enough basal to get me through the day I'd hypo during the night.
Me too. Too much basal gives me the somogyi effect through the night (only on toujeo300 thou). Just full blown hypos to a 1.7mmol/l once on humulin m3 mix.
 

GrantGam

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,603
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Still, on my original question, what do you think is best. More Basal or more Bolus?
Your asking a question that doesn't make any sense - nor does it have a sensible answer. Bolus dosing (amount and frequency) is relative to what you're eating.

As I take 18u basal; and my ICR is 1:12; then depending whether I eat either side of 216g CHO will dictate whether my bolus is more or less than my basal. Is either one better, not at all. What is important is that my BG control is good.

Basal rate testing will help you set your dose accurately. That part is important. How much bolus you're injecting to cover your carbs is irrelevant, unless it's compensating for a lack of basal. But, basal rate testing will help you avoid that.
 
Last edited:

Fearless36

Well-Known Member
Messages
112
Hi everyone,

This really isn't a question that anyone can answer. Whilst Dr Bernstein is a well known doctor who has done a lot of research some of his ideas I find particularly troublesome. For example I have been diabetic for over 30 years and used to be on premixed insulin (actually when I started out you had to use a syringe to mix it yourself) and according to him my control should have been really bad, but suffice to say it wasn't at all. My sugar results were always completely within the normal range. Plus I was very active and healthy and this doesn't match his experience at all.
 
D

Deleted Account

Guest
They're still taken at the same time @helensaramay, just divided into separate injections.

I never do it with mine, but some HCP's advise on dividing up larger doses into separate injections.
Thanks. Now I understand.
I wonder how many people who split their doses changes needles between each injection. It would be a real faff doing 4 injections and changing the needle each time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GrantGam

GrantGam

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,603
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Thanks. Now I understand.
I wonder how many people who split their doses changes needles between each injection. It would be a real faff doing 4 injections and changing the needle each time.
I probably made a poor job of explaining it...

Very good point about the needle change, I wouldn't bother. But I also wouldn't bother with what Bernstein has said either. Over your lifetime, it would literally be thousands of extra injections if you followed that man's advice. I'll take my chances with possible site absorption "problems", over worn out injection sites from unnecessary dose splitting any day:)
 
D

Deleted Account

Guest
I probably made a poor job of explaining it...

Very good point about the needle change, I wouldn't bother. But I also wouldn't bother with what Bernstein has said either. Over your lifetime, it would literally be thousands of extra injections if you followed that man's advice. I'll take my chances with possible site absorption "problems", over worn out injection sites from unnecessary dose splitting any day:)
I totally agree ... and that's before we start considering another load of injection sites to rotate.
 

Struma

Well-Known Member
Messages
536
Type of diabetes
LADA
Treatment type
Other
Hi everyone,

Which is best. More Basal or more Bolus?

What are your opinions on this question?

I was reading Dr. Bernstein's book Diabetes Solution - A Complete Guide to Achieving Normal Blood Sugars and in it he says that people shouldn't be taking more than 7 units of Basal insulin. Now 've been Itaking 32 units of Lantus each night and this made me think "whoa". So I've started lowering my doses (of Lantus) but I think this has had a big impact on my BS during the day. It's also meant that I've had to take bigger doses of Bolus (Humalog) to get me back to good BS levels.

I think that getting your BS stable with Basal first is most important, regardless if it seems like a huge dose. Then the Bolus becomes easier to manage.

Personally, I think 'Think Like a Pancreas' by Gary Scheiner to be a slightly better written book. It has been popular on this site.
This chap says 'It is commonly found that a 50:50 division in totals of basal and bolus proves the most effective.' This of course was written prior to the introduction of Toujoe or Tresiba. I have Lantus 56u/NovoRapid 60u. I quite like working along these lines.
 
Last edited:

EllsKBells

Well-Known Member
Messages
362
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
@mahola as often your comment has given me a chuckle - I'm 55 kilos and 5 foot ten, which puts my BMI around 19. I now take 19 tresiba a day, but when I was on levemir, I was on 47 units split a day. Weight is NOT the only factor affecting insulin sensitivity, which, from what I've heard about Bernstein, is something his work does overlook slightly.

@Struma mine also works out at about 50:50, on a decent day anyway. Before the switch to tresiba though, it was not even near that. It is really funny how different people get on with different insulins - I really struggled with levemir.

@Lord Midas I don't think your question really has an answer. I suppose lifestyle also comes into it though - if your activity levels oscillate wildly from day to day, then perhaps that might affect it? I don't know :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: mahola

Scott-C

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,474
Type of diabetes
Type 1
I've read a few online snippets of Dr Bernstein's books, but haven't read them in whole, so won't express a view till I've done so, but my general impression is that he's not the sort of guy who you'd want tagging along on Friday night out.

"Come on, Richard, up for another pint here, mate?" "No, Scott, as I've explained in my book, you should eat no more than 6g of carbs at breakfast etc. etc." Yeah, well, it's been fun, see ya.

His often quoted law of small numbers seems like utter cowardice to me. Here's what he says: http://www.diabetes-book.com/laws-small-numbers/

He approaches this as if it were entirely an engineering problem, focusing on uncertainties in measurement. That's correct, there are deep uncertainties in T1, but just bailing out and saying, "limit carbs and it will solve everything" seems to ignore that with cgm, we can make adjustments on the fly, in the moment.

All I know is that if I'd followed his advice, I would have spent my life saying, "ooh, sorry, I'm T1, I can't do that, Dr Bernstein says I can't.".

I take my T1 seriously. I'm rarely over 8 or 9. There's the occasional visit to the low or mid teens when I make a mistake. We're not lab rats, but Bernstein seems to want to make us so. I've visited about 20 countries. I think my experience of them would have been impaired if I'd followed Bernstein's dictates.

The irony here is that we all complain about non-T1s telling us, "you can't eat that", yet some seem happy enough with Bernstein saying the same thing.
 

therower

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,922
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
@Scott-C . I've not read Bernstein and after reading your post I have no intention to.
Can't think of anything worse than a perfect T1 diabetic.
Great post.
 

therower

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,922
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
@GrantGam . My most sincerest apologies.
My intention to use the word "perfect" metaphorically seems to have caused you to question our friendship. This was never my intention.
None of us are perfect....... I'm a miserable *****, 54 yr old, argumentative T1.
And as perfect as you undoubtedly are......... I have to question your dietary choices sometimes, they are often far from perfect ;);););););).

Good morning friend:) Hope all is well.
 

Kbarbaracollins_

Well-Known Member
Messages
49
Type of diabetes
Type 1
That is how I read it.
However, I do not know why there is a problem with injecting more basal.
If the basal lasts 24 hours and the requirements are stable throughout that time, I see no reason for splitting the dose.

Some basal does not last this long and some people experience higher needs at different times of the day. Hence, some people split their dose but splitting it four times seems excessive .. and if these four times are equally spaced, you could not sleep for more than 6 hours as you will need a basal dose during the night.

I was advised by Dr Bernstein to split large injections to max 7 units per injection. But this doesn't mean you need to stagger them - just use injections in different sites. Apparently it helps to make absorption more uniform.
 
D

Deleted Account

Guest
I was advised by Dr Bernstein to split large injections to max 7 units per injection. But this doesn't mean you need to stagger them - just use injections in different sites. Apparently it helps to make absorption more uniform.
Thanks for the clarification.
I never split my injections and experienced no problems
Out of interest do you change needles between each injection?
 

JamesNhlman

Newbie
Messages
2
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Yeah sounds like nonsense to be honest. I take 38 units of lantus before bed
 

TheBigNewt

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,167
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
I take 25 Lantus first thing in the morning. I never took it at night. Works for me. I take about 20U Novorapid with meals, so it's pretty close to 50/50 basal/bolus. I use the pen needles until the pen runs out of insulin. I do put a new one on a new pen lol! AQ box lasts me a couple years.