• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

Cholesterol/statins And Other Bunkum

Just watched it. A very good explanation and refutation of the whole load of bunkum that our GP's are giving out on an hourly basis.
Sally
 
Don’t beat up on your doctors they have a big job to do. My experience is they will always listen and explain what they are doing with you. It a team effort.
 
Blackcountry Lad said:
Don’t beat up on your doctors they have a big job to do. My experience is they will always listen and explain what they are doing with you. It a team effort.
Click to expand...
I wish I could say the same.
My experience is that they know little if anything about various conditions but are always keen to whip out the prescription pad.
 
Blackcountry Lad said:
Don’t beat up on your doctors they have a big job to do. My experience is they will always listen and explain what they are doing with you. It a team effort.
Click to expand...

Couldn't agree more, however, it doesn't help when your GP tells you that the muscle pain in your legs is because of your age, because you exercise too much, or because you're overweight, a different excuse every time you mention the pain, and then say "you're the only patient who mentions muscle pain". By the time my GP was saying I was a rare case I was in possession of a copy of a patent application made by Merck Pharmaceutical in 1990, seven whole years before I was first prescribed Statins, to put CoQ10 in with the statin to prevent impending muscle pain.

Fortunately, he's now my ex GP, he had also told me to keep eating the carbs when I asked if I should cut back and he'd also said the side effects of Metformin were IBS, after putting me through all sorts of investigations on my insides. Out of touch would be under statement. My present GPs always listen and explain and I do consider us a team tasked with looking after my health.

So fair to say I have experienced both sorts of GP.
 
Here is a lecture (just short of a hour) that is a little more technical and presented by Ivor Cummins.

 
Blackcountry Lad said:
Don’t beat up on your doctors they have a big job to do. My experience is they will always listen and explain what they are doing with you. It a team effort.
Click to expand...


Blackcountrylad, I agree with you in that most Doctors listen to you and try to explain, I know mine does. However, all they try to explain is the generic NHS advice, eg eat lots of carbs/don't eat eggs because of cholesterol and as this post says, all the things that are in the process of being debunked. They do not (in my experience) stray very far, if at all from their text books.
 
Blackcountry Lad said:
Don’t beat up on your doctors they have a big job to do. My experience is they will always listen and explain what they are doing with you. It a team effort.
Click to expand...

Although I have been lucky enough in the past to have had a couple of excellent GPs I have to say that I have lost faith in HCPs in general. If one is 'awkward' enough to have multiple conditions or ask for full details or even to want a discussion on choice wrt treatment options then one must hunt high and low for a HCP to accommodate.
 
I am I must admit anti statins mostly, but reading on line that Akira Endo having never taken statins when learning his cholesterol levels were high, until about 5 years ago has since been taking them but only three times a week not daily. I wonder if he had any serious doubts about his own discovery would he be taking them at all.
 
Last edited:
Wot I learned:-

Don't meat and drive. I suppose eating a burger, smoking and driving at the same time would result in an adverse outcome.

More seriously, an excellent presentation. I'm also curious how 'relative risk' became a thing because as shown in this presentation, it's statistically meaningless bordering on the fraudulent. I guess people are being taught this as a neat presentation trick rather than decent statistics.

With the statins, the huge issue is glossing over the benefits vs adverse outcomes, especially given the way they're prescribed. I sense large lawsuits looming in statins future.
 
first14808 said:
I sense large lawsuits looming in statins future.
Click to expand...

Lawyers in Canada filed lawsuits in 2014 because of the increased risk of diabetes.

In the USA, more than 2,300 Lipitor lawsuits have been filed in the District of South Carolina on behalf of individuals who allegedly developed Type 2 diabetes due to their use of the statin, according to court documents.

These lawsuits started after the FDA warned of the possible connection in 2012.

As for the U.K., just google "statin lawsuits U.K." Lots of horror stories about the side effects but I couldn't find anything about lawsuits. I have seriously thought of litigation but lets be honest, unless I was incredibly rich, I would be daft to waste my money.
 
Big Pharma, in the case of litigation, tends to philibuster until claimants die. Look at British claimants wrt Thalidomide.
 
bulkbiker said:
There have been quite a few cholesterol questions recently as well as statins... I'm not sure if this has been posted before but it seemed timely to me.

Click to expand...
Thanks for introducing me to David Diamond. I have been looking for a good summary about saturated fats and statins - and here it is .
 
hooha said:
Thanks for introducing me to David Diamond. I have been looking for a good summary about saturated fats and statins - and here it is .
Click to expand...

Note. Bulkbiker has a separate thread titled 'Cholesterol and Statins', it is quite comprehensive and ranges from the very simple to the technical if you are interested in delving deeper. Highly recommended.
 
mahola said:
My GP wanted to prescribe me statins within a week of me being diagnosed. I politely told him where to put his statins...
Click to expand...

This is what I do not understand, it's almost like *they* want to treat a number rather than finding out how that number is broken down and if there is a potential problem within. Picture the scene 'Good morning Mrs. Guz, I'm sorry but you have.... number X' or worse, 'You live in which postcode! OMG, take this drug or you will expire next Tuesday week!' It makes absolutely no sense to me.
 
Back
Top