• Guest, the forum is undergoing some upgrades and so the usual themes will be unavailable for a few days. In the meantime, you can use the forum like normal. We'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

Managing diet too strictly

RachieSparkle

RachieSparkle

Member
Hi, I wonder if anyone could help me out please?

My husband was diagnosed with T1 about 2 weeks ago. We usually eat a low GI diet with no refined sugar. Our main source of carbohydrate is sweet potato, quinoa, vegetables, some fruit etc. We also exercise regurlary.

So far - since the diagnosis - he has managed to keep his blood glucose between 5 and 8.9.

He spoke to the diabetes nurse today and she kept emphasising that he shouldn’t manage his diet ‘so strictly’ as it isn’t good in the long run. We haven’t changed our diet because of the diagnosis; we’ve eaten like this for years.

Can anyone help me out and explain why this is. I’m really confused as I genuinely didn’t know that there was a benefit to eating refined carbs / sugar.

I want to do what’s best for our family so we’re being very open minded.

Thanks in advance.
 
Hi @RachieSparkle Welcome to the forum :)

Please ignore your nurse, her advice is wrong, you haven't changed your diet so are not doing anything 'special' since diagnosis, they often give out this advice with the aim to instruct newbies to continue with 'normal' eating, she may of mis-interpreted what you said and thought you were doing this as a result of diagnosis.
 
When health professionals who are otherwise fairly sensible start talking about diet stupid things come out of their mouths.

If it's working for him, that's great.

Perhaps what she *should* have said is don't be afraid to try things. It might give you a 'bad' number afterwards, but don't stress, you know for the future.

Don't panic. Be kind to yourselves. Your husband is a very lucky man to have such wonderful support from you.
 
RachieSparkle said:
Hi, I wonder if anyone could help me out please?

My husband was diagnosed with T1 about 2 weeks ago. We usually eat a low GI diet with no refined sugar. Our main source of carbohydrate is sweet potato, quinoa, vegetables, some fruit etc. We also exercise regurlary.

So far - since the diagnosis - he has managed to keep his blood glucose between 5 and 8.9.

He spoke to the diabetes nurse today and she kept emphasising that he shouldn’t manage his diet ‘so strictly’ as it isn’t good in the long run. We haven’t changed our diet because of the diagnosis; we’ve eaten like this for years.

Can anyone help me out and explain why this is. I’m really confused as I genuinely didn’t know that there was a benefit to eating refined carbs / sugar.

I want to do what’s best for our family so we’re being very open minded.

Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
I wonder with him being diagnosed as type 1 (and presumably starting on insulin) she may have been clumsily alluding to the effect of (new) insulin on him and possibly hypo's based on his current diet etc? They always seem to start everyone off with the same carb to insulin ratio regardless of what diet they follow and then observe. Sounds like she wants your husband to up his carbs simply to suit the amount of insulin everybody else gets when first diagnosed. I had similar and 4 units was dropping me like a stone for weeks. Then they kept reducing the insulin until I was on 2 units.
 
Juicyj said:
Hi @RachieSparkle Welcome to the forum :)

Please ignore your nurse, her advice is wrong, you haven't changed your diet so are not doing anything 'special' since diagnosis, they often give out this advice with the aim to instruct newbies to continue with 'normal' eating, she may of mis-interpreted what you said and thought you were doing this as a result of diagnosis.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the reply.

Good to know that our normal way of eating shouldn’t be detrimental.
 
EllsKBells said:
When health professionals who are otherwise fairly sensible start talking about diet stupid things come out of their mouths.

If it's working for him, that's great.

Perhaps what she *should* have said is don't be afraid to try things. It might give you a 'bad' number afterwards, but don't stress, you know for the future.

Don't panic. Be kind to yourselves. Your husband is a very lucky man to have such wonderful support from you.
Click to expand...

Thanks so much. We’ve taking the diagnosis on as a family. So what he can eat, I eat too.
 
KK123 said:
I wonder with him being diagnosed as type 1 (and presumably starting on insulin) she may have been clumsily alluding to the effect of (new) insulin on him and possibly hypo's based on his current diet etc? They always seem to start everyone off with the same carb to insulin ratio regardless of what diet they follow and then observe. Sounds like she wants your husband to up his carbs simply to suit the amount of insulin everybody else gets when first diagnosed. I had similar and 4 units was dropping me like a stone for weeks. Then they kept reducing the insulin until I was on 2 units.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the reply.

I see, I didn’t realise they started people off on the same. He is taking 10 units of levemere before bed and 4 units of novorapid before breakfast and lunch, and 6 units before evening meal. When he’s felt ‘low’ he’s checked his blood glucose and if it’s in the low 5s he’ll have an apple and almond butter or mixed nuts or something like that, and that picks him up. I think maybe his body just isn’t used to being so low, as it was running on high for so long.

Hopefully, the nurse might lower his insulin soon then. He reduced it last night before evening meal as we had a smaller tea and didn’t want to go too low over the night.

Thanks, for the advice. We’re so new to all of this and really want to start off doing the best we can.
 
RachieSparkle said:
Thanks for the reply.

I see, I didn’t realise they started people off on the same. He is taking 10 units of levemere before bed and 4 units of novorapid before breakfast and lunch, and 6 units before evening meal. When he’s felt ‘low’ he’s checked his blood glucose and if it’s in the low 5s he’ll have an apple and almond butter or mixed nuts or something like that, and that picks him up. I think maybe his body just isn’t used to being so low, as it was running on high for so long.

Hopefully, the nurse might lower his insulin soon then. He reduced it last night before evening meal as we had a smaller tea and didn’t want to go too low over the night.

Thanks, for the advice. We’re so new to all of this and really want to start off doing the best we can.
Click to expand...
To be fair to them I guess they don't know how people will react to the insulin to begin with so they have to start somewhere, but I would say really keep an eye on it and don't let them convince you that he must adjust his diet to the insulin instead of the other way round. Good luck.
 
Back
Top