• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

No Wonder We Become Confused!

djt1st

Newbie
Messages
1
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Having recently received my new Balance magazine I note that advice and articles simply present totally confusing messages.

I like many others being a long term diabetic from a family of "diabetics" I have seen a whole range of differing advice given to us from the so called "experts"/health professionals.

Some months ago we were being encouraged to follow new diets with the advice that healthy/low fat products should be avoided at all costs and that we should concentrate on basing our diets around "natural/unprocessed" foods - echoes of the advise given to us in the 60s & 70s.

Over the same period the targets for blood glucose levels have dropped and are now being challenged again as are the interpretation of what is the impact of our condition on our ability to live a normal life.

In this months Balance - Fad or Fiction (p48/49) - the advice given relating "Butter is better" is totally at variance to that given previously by your own team.

Can you wonder why people are confused - my own experience suggests that a good many so called "healthy options" are far from it especially relating to sugar content.

How many young people are being condemned to a lifetime of taking damaging medication simply because diabetes now seems to be the route to simply making money out of our condition - from GPs benefiting by numbers identified to the vast range of meters, so called specialist foods and treatments as well as experts all making a living out of giving advice.

Too many health professionals immediately resort to prescribing medication rather than exploring alternatives as they used to. Not speculation on my part but detailed knowledge of actual cases.

Please ensure that the advice that you give is consistent if you genuinely want to help us. Of course over time advice changes and develops but not so drastically in a couple of months.
 
Are you sure you have the right organisation? It's Diabetes.org.uk who tend to give the advice you are talking about and they publish the Balance magazine, not us. We are DCUK and are simply a group of diabetics doing the best we can to help others. Most of us would advocate using natural fats like butters, or at least olive oil.

DCUK does have an official low carb program, but that advocates eating heathy fats like butter and lard.

http://www.diabetes.co.uk/lowcarb/

Welcome to the forum anyway - maybe we can help you to be a bit less confused. :)
 
hi and welcome
I think you are confusing the diabetes forum here with the .org people that @zand has pointed out.
 
Hi. Most on this forum have no problem with butter and support a lower-carb diet. Interestingly I have today cancelled my DUK membership following various Balance Mag articles over the years which I have disagreed with. My experience of providing feedback to DUK by email on diet etc is that it is a waste of time. I will just stay with this forum and I find that the other (.org.uk) site forums increasingly share similar dietary views to this site.
 
Having recently received my new Balance magazine I note that advice and articles simply present totally confusing messages.

I like many others being a long term diabetic from a family of "diabetics" I have seen a whole range of differing advice given to us from the so called "experts"/health professionals.

Some months ago we were being encouraged to follow new diets with the advice that healthy/low fat products should be avoided at all costs and that we should concentrate on basing our diets around "natural/unprocessed" foods - echoes of the advise given to us in the 60s & 70s.

Over the same period the targets for blood glucose levels have dropped and are now being challenged again as are the interpretation of what is the impact of our condition on our ability to live a normal life.

In this months Balance - Fad or Fiction (p48/49) - the advice given relating "Butter is better" is totally at variance to that given previously by your own team.

Can you wonder why people are confused - my own experience suggests that a good many so called "healthy options" are far from it especially relating to sugar content.

How many young people are being condemned to a lifetime of taking damaging medication simply because diabetes now seems to be the route to simply making money out of our condition - from GPs benefiting by numbers identified to the vast range of meters, so called specialist foods and treatments as well as experts all making a living out of giving advice.

Too many health professionals immediately resort to prescribing medication rather than exploring alternatives as they used to. Not speculation on my part but detailed knowledge of actual cases.

Please ensure that the advice that you give is consistent if you genuinely want to help us. Of course over time advice changes and develops but not so drastically in a couple of months.



Re Butter--it is better--no additives, you see, therefore it is "natural & unprocessed" !!!
 
Back
Top