I can't offer any advice on the best pump as I was given no choice and the one I have (Animas Vibe) is longer available.
However, I can share my pumping experience.
After 12 years of reasonable control with MDI, I wasn't sure what the point was of having something attached to me all the time.
That was until I learnt about the way pumps control basal - they pump fast acting insulin every 5 minutes. The fantastic advantage of this is that you can alter your basal
- you can set up a daily schedule to account for your different basal needs at different times of the day (e.g. to handle dawn phenomenon)
- you can temporarily adjust your basal when you exercise to avoid hypos (this is huge for me)
- if you are feeling unwell resulting in high BG, you can increase your basal immediately and tweak it a couple of hours later if it is wrong rather than waiting for your daily basal dose, increase it a bit, increase a bit the next day, increase it the next day ... and before you have worked out the correct increase, you are feeling better.
Another advantage is the ability to administer tiny amounts of bolus. For get half a unit. What about 0.05 units? This allows great control with corrections and meals (if you can count your carbs that accurately).
Of course, there is the advantage of not realising you left your pens at home so can't eat. However, you do need to think of some sort of backup plan in case your pump fails.
And whilst we're on the negatives, all this fun doesn't come for free. You still need to carb count. In fact, you need to carb count more accurately - no rounding up to the nearest 10g carbs (although I still guestimate a lot of the time). As you no longer have "spare" basal running around your body mopping up any carbs you miscounted, you are more likely to go high.
Talking of going high, this more of a risk - if your pump fails, you have no basal in your body so you could go high quickly. Before you panic on that one - I have been pumping for two and a half years and never experience this ... I just have to be aware.
It's wonderful that you don't have to prime your pen every time you eat, but every 2 to 4 days, you have to change your pump sets which is more faffy. You get used to it but I was very nervous I would make a mistake when I first started.
All these different basal rates and bolus ratios and ... can take some time to get sorted. So just when you are not sure if you really want to be attached, you may experience more hypos are hypers as the settings are tweaked, tweaked again and tweaked again until they are right. And this is the time when you are nervous with the set changes. Don't expect the first few weeks to be run - expect a bit of a roller coaster. But it will sort itself out and you will be gliding along at the peaceful end of the log flume for a long time afterwards
As I mentioned, I had no choice which pump to get. So I have one with a tube. Most of the time this doesn't get in the way. I know some people express concerns what to do with it when they sleep (I put it in a garter belt type thing attached to my leg) or when they shower (I take it off) or when they swim (I take it off ... but remember to reattach and give myself a basal top up if I am disconnected for a while) or during ... ummm ... intimate moments (I take it off).
My biggest problem with the tubiness is that I find it difficult to hide and be easily accessible to give myself a dose without fumbling in my bra, hitching up my dress or running off to the bathroom. Many people cope well with this and find they can can put it in their trouser pocket (lucky guys with their large pockets and no hips) or clip it to their bra strap (lucky women with "enough" to hide the pump bulge). But, most of the time I clip it to my belt and be aware that others are wondering why I have a pager from the 90s.
Sorry for the essay - I hope I have not put you off. Whilst there are annoying things with a pump, given the choice I would not go back to injections.
However, one thing which made me take the plunge was, when I was told if I didn't like it I could go back to injections, I decided I had nothing to lose.
Tell us what you decide
@Louisek93