• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

Type 2 Statins - GP insisting Simvastatin 20mg

Hi @Rachox Did your discussions with the doctor cover whether your T2D (diet controlled) affects the new Q-risk score. It has always seemed odd that you have to add on big numbers even though you are not currently diabetic. I did my own numbers on the new tests and was very low risk if you can ignore the T2D.
 

Just a slight correction, I take Metformin so I’m not solely diet controlled. However he did agree with me that it wasn’t fair that all Type 2s score the same regardless of control. He did say, and quite rightly, that you’ll never know if you have suffered any damage between the start of your diabetes and diagnosis. There definitely needs to be graded scores for Diabetes, maybe score all diabetics a couple of percent as a blanket score but then add more as your HbA1c rises?
 
If you are unlucky enough to get the muscle pain it goes away when you stop the drug. Only about 1 person in maybe 5,000 gets any actual muscle "damage'' measure by CPK enzymes. That's REALLY rare. All the bad stuff's reversible.
 
If you are unlucky enough to get the muscle pain it goes away when you stop the drug. Only about 1 person in maybe 5,000 gets any actual muscle "damage'' measure by CPK enzymes. That's REALLY rare. All the bad stuff's reversible.

I’m not risking being the one of 5000 that does get the permanent damage!
 
I’m not risking being the one of 5000 that does get the permanent damage!
Actually I've never seen that happen and I've prescribed statins since they came out. Muscle pain yes, liver function test elevations (reversible) yes. I think one weird bad thing I forget. that's it. I have a feeling the providers there get some sort of Good Do Bee quality points for doing this risk assessment and getting some people to take preventive therapy like statins. I don't use 'em a lot for that.
 
Last edited:
i had the reversible pain unplesant. my liver function tests are still out of range.
 
i had the reversible pain unplesant. my liver function tests are still out of range.
There's a gazillion reasons for LFTs to be out of range. If it's statin they go back. If don't go back still blame statin.
 
I’m not risking being the one of 5000 that does get the permanent damage!

I had a drug some years ago and had a side effect quoted in the data sheet as 1 in 10,000!
 
If we listened to all the "experts" and powers that be, we would be restricted to water only ..... but hey! we can't even drink that with all the additives.
Tap water where I am will raise your blood sugar it has fluoride in it.
 
There's a gazillion reasons for LFTs to be out of range. If it's statin they go back. If don't go back still blame statin.
well it was normal before and then went mad when they put me on 80mg simbastatin sorry cant spell. think my gpwas mad to increase my dose by 8x. i refused it for a number of years then had a cardiac issue and am taking it at 10mg my bloods are off but not as bad as at 80mg. ive just had to go through a screening for liver conditions all normal apart from the alt and aft
 

Grrrrr. Glucose control is MUCH more important. Sorry just to assert, but it makes me so cross.

Evidence: suggest you read Peter Attia blog for in-depth on cholesterol, if you like science. Malcolm Kendricks is also good, if annoyingly jokey sometimes. Fact remains that lowering cholesterol for women has always increased all-cause mortality. Not one single study where it hasn’t. I would never take statins.

Read, research. Good luck!
 

Atorvastatin 4Omg a day gave my dad uncomfortable muscles pain enough to prevent him from wanting to exercise and increase his bg reading by around 10%. The side effects took about two weeks to appear and a month to go away after tapering it off.
 
Atorvastatin 4Omg a day gave my dad uncomfortable muscles pain enough to prevent him from wanting to exercise and increase his bg reading by around 10%. The side effects took about two weeks to appear and a month to go away after tapering it off.
Hi @millenium That really struck a chord. I have so often seen my Doctor and DN give me the blank look, over numbness in the feet, pins and needles, low B12, statin problems... It must be deliberate.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn More.…