• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

X-pert course - I was told no need to test?

anna29 said:
I only got one full day with both beginners course and then the Xpert refresher course .
Got them both done in a full day session .
How times have changed in less than 5 years .
Click to expand...

Ten years ago, I got no course, only a short chat with practice nurse and a booklet from British Heart Foundation advising 6 - 8 portions of starchy carbs a day. I had already been following this advice for several years after gaining weight. Doh! I was a bit slow in recognising the link to more weight gain and T2 diagnosis. A prescription for Metformin and meter and strips were given. The test strips stopped 5 years ago.
 
donnellysdogs said:
It would be interesting to inform health care professionals that the top bod is now advocating low carb!!

Wonder how long it will take to pass the the line?

Wonder what qualufications the course leaders of the xpert courses have?
Click to expand...

In the meantime, it would appear that there persists on these courses the advice to eat starchy carbs at every meal, and do not bother to test BG levels.

How many course participants must there be who are condemned to a progression of complications of diabetes by slavishly following this advice?
 
I'm going to check with my GPs on Weds whether they send people on xpert courses and then update them that the designer of the course has now brought out a book "eat fat".

Not a t2 but as part of the gp patient group I can get information to the gps easier than a direct patient appointment...
 
donnellysdogs said:
It would be interesting to inform health care professionals that the top bod is now advocating low carb!!

Wonder how long it will take to pass the the line?

Wonder what qualufications the course leaders of the xpert courses have?
Click to expand...
From Xpert website : http://www.xperthealth.org.uk/

Who can become an X-PERT Educator?

Healthcare professionals, link workers and lay educators may attend training to deliver:

You may be employed by a licensed organisation or hold a freelance licence.
What competencies do I need to become an Educator?

We provide you with all the information, tools and techniques necessary. However, it will help to have the basic knowledge, skills and understanding of pre-diabetes/diabetes to deliver the relevant programme and also be familiar with adult education principles.

Recommended competencies to deliver different aspects of the programme can be found in the competency framework document

www.xperthealth.org.uk/Portals/0/Downloads/An%20Integrated%20Career%20and%20Competency%20Framework%20for%20Dietitians%20and%20Frontline%20Staff_2013_reduced%20memory.pdf
 
Brilliant, @donnellysdogs . I am glad I never did one of these courses, but can't help feeling more than a bit miffed that someone can have such influence on many peoples' health, then change have a complete about turn on the advice given. I wonder does she recognise or acknowledge that previous info could have caused many T 2s to damage their health?
 
I am in Ribble valley too I have never been offered a course but we have 1 surgery in Blackburn and 1 in Ribble Valley so maybe that is why
CAROL
 
People I know who have attended T2 X-pert courses say such things to me as ' I can eat what I always ate'. "I eat healthy carbs now, brown rice and wholewheat pasta, jacket potatoes, brown bread, bran flakes. Have to include some carbs at every meal". They think I am uneducated about T2 because I haven't been on a course, and say I am wrong to restrict the carbs in my diet, yet many of them have ever increasing BG, despite medication. Some have complications such as neuropathy and retina changes, whereas I am not on medication, and have well controlled BG.

I am getting quite annoyed!
 
carty said:
I am in Ribble valley too I have never been offered a course but we have 1 surgery in Blackburn and 1 in Ribble Valley so maybe that is why
CAROL
Click to expand...
Seems those of us not having attended a course, but getting our education from here on forum are the lucky ones.
 
Don't be annoyed -- be smug. It's much more satisfying
 
Fergus,Im also from Rossendale,but now live in Rochester Kent.
I did the X Pert course last year 6 sessions of 3 hrs,thought it was good at the time until I joined the forum,and relised it wasnt good advice at all.
 
I am getting quite annoyed![/QUOTE]

That's exactly what I was about to say.
If Trudi expert Deakin is changing her advice, she needs to change her website for a start!
 
Very interesting comments here. I'm seriously considering the benefits of this course, but will keep going if only to hear the diet advice! Ha ha...

If I hadn't been ill with a viral infection, I'd have spoken up but I was losing my voice, had swollen glands and sore throat. Speaking without having a coughing fit wasn't an option


I'm disappointed because I'd really hoped this was going to be educational but this forum is and will remain my go-to place for information
I really don't understand the contradictory advice they give and it seems I'm not the only one!
 
I finally get to go on the local course, 2 3hr classes. Will be 4 months into diabetes for me when I go on the course, boy are they in for a surprise. Hehe. They gunna wish I hadn't gone.
 
DeejayR said:
Don't be annoyed -- be smug. It's much more satisfying
Click to expand...

But I can't be smug. These are people I really care about, and they truly believe that the advice they have been given on these courses is going to help them to stay well. They believe that although they have high BG levels they would be higher still if they didn't follow the instructions given by the HCPs on these courses.

I am beyond annoyed. I am furious that somebody like Trudi Deakin can make a career, and possibly a comfortable living out of developing a system that gives info on health care for people with a chronic illness, when that info is at best of dubious benefit. Then after a while, shift emphasis to a different diet, but the old diet is still being preached to the unsuspecting, trusting individuals who are being instructed by people using the outdated information. All because Trudi Deakin has the kudos.
 
In my own experience the course was as everybody else has shown that dietary advice is criminal!

Besides my own experience the OH has had the carbs with every meal changed to low carbs now. But, she was told by the dsn to stay away from the computer as the info was completely against medical recommendations!

Whose? I asked!
 
 
My mother was T2 for a number of years and, despite eating 'healthily' ie brown bread, jacket potatoes, pasta etc, etc, never lost a lot of weight and ended up on insulin. I now know it was because she was eating what her DN had advised was a balanced diet! Luckily for me I have access to the internet etc which has allowed me to research how to control my diabetes through diet and testing.
 
The 6-week Expert Diabetic Patient course I went on in Wales may or may not be the same as X-Pert, but it is offered to everyone who is diagnosed.
The courses are led by Diabetic Nurses, follow a strict curriculum and also have a Diabetic or two on hand for personal anecdotes and advice.

All Type 1s are told to test regularly, very few Type 2s are, because, it seems it world be rather expensive whilst occasional tests at the Doctor's practice are deemed "enough". I believed this for a while and then went out and got my own tester.
 
This course is run by a nutritionist. Last week was more like weight watchers or something and the message was pretty much that we were diabetic because we were fat. The only discussion re type 1 or 2 was the causes really and that was week 1.
 
I was given a book last June The X-Pert Diabetes Programme.Virsion7
I think its very much out of date now. The nurse taught from the book.
Im going to order Trudi Deakins new one,she has changed her mind about diet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn More.…