I think all the previous commentators on this thread, including my self would disagree
I agree completely, but would add some nuance to the chocolate angle here. From my experience, as a chocolate addict prior to my diabetes diagnosis (now a slowly reforming one), I think the battle with chocolate cravings is more than just food substitution.
Real deal milk chocolate delivers hits for caffeine, fat and sugar, which in turn stimulate pleasure centres in the brain. The more you eat, the greater pleasure pay off - it's enough you can possibly even convince yourself to ignore the obvious and downsides (I did, anyway). Psychologically, chocolate is also "naughty", so in some people (I'm one of them), chocolate consumption triggers the "I shouldn't be eating this, but...." reward.
In my personal experience, fighting and handling chocolate cravings is about substituting the physical and/or psychological rewards of eating high carb chocolate, not necessarily trying to find something that exactly replaces milk chocolate itself from an eating experience.
For me, many of the previous suggestions achieve that in one way or another. One I'll add is melting 85%+ dark chocolate into double cream as a treat. Refrigerate it to make a ganache-like dessert, or use an electric mixer to whip it into a chocolate mousse. The overall sensation is very close to a regular chocolate dessert, plus the caffeine reward is higher in dark chocolate, the double cream emulates the fat based rewards, but it's lower sugar and lower carb as a result (but still adds some natural sugars in the cream). For me, this is as close as it gets to satisfying that milk chocolate craving and I save it for the times where, on previous higher carb and lower fat diets, I'd have broken the diet to binge on milk chocolate. So far, it's worked for me, so hoping this very long-winded post about chocolate might help others potentially.
