Have I completely sabotaged myself?

Nanny_B said:

Can anyone advise approx how long it takes to start seeing normal blood sugar levels again?

Click to expand...

You've really been through the ringer, I feel for you.

Good news, you've done this before, you have the tools & with keto you're already on the right path.
How long were you initially in remission ?
We now know it can take 12 months post remission for your beta cells to heal.
Perhaps your reintroducing of carbs took you back over the tipping point.
How has your weight & exercise faired over this period.

My advice is to stay low carb, lose weight & up your exercise.
This process will take months to achieve your goals but is so worth it.

You could ask for a fasting insulin or GAD test to rule out a slow onset T1 but I don't believe that's likely.

Good luck, you've got this.

Thought of a fast for a couple of days to kick start your progress?

Nanny_B said:

Im not sure if a couple of days will be good...I have to drive for my job. I don't want to be passing out at the wheel! I could try a day and see if that helps to start bring them down?

Click to expand...

Any non triggering of insulin production will likely help. So yes maybe eat dinner then see how long you can go without food (I use coffee with double cream as a "fasting crutch").

Every day is a new day. It might take a few weeks to get your blood sugar levels down enough. You are doing the right thing and going in the right direction.

Well done for getting back on the wagon.

Hi @Nanny_B

From what I have seen here on the forum, and experience of my own, it seems as though the more times, and the longer we ‘fall off the wagon’, then the harder it can be to get back on. That is certainly my own experience. I think the difficulty can be as much emotional/psychological as physical, but it is one of the reasons that I really try hard not to yoyo with my carb control. Sometimes, when we get back to low carbing, we need to be stricter and more systematic to get the same benefits.

Additionally, if you are someone who gets carb cravings, then avoiding having to go through all that again is good motivation for me!

having said that, we have members here on the forum with T2 who have been on insulin for years, but still manage to improve their way of eating and lifestyle (sometimes including weight loss) to the extent of reducing or even eliminating their diabetes medication.

So it is never to late.

Ronancastled said:

You've really been through the ringer, I feel for you.

Good news, you've done this before, you have the tools & with keto you're already on the right path.
How long were you initially in remission ?
We now know it can take 12 months post remission for your beta cells to heal.
Perhaps your reintroducing of carbs took you back over the tipping point.
How has your weight & exercise faired over this period.

My advice is to stay low carb, lose weight & up your exercise.
This process will take months to achieve your goals but is so worth it.

You could ask for a fasting insulin or GAD test to rule out a slow onset T1 but I don't believe that's likely.

Good luck, you've got this.

Click to expand...

Hi @Ronancastled

I really do applaud your success in putting your T2 into ‘remission’, but you have been making some really strong statements about beta cell healing on a few threads lately.

its very important, when making claims like this, to give appropriate references, and to specify which type of diabetes is being mentioned (because not all types can even hope for ‘remission’). And it is also important to explain the conditions and expectations involved.

My understanding is that there is actually very little evidence of beta cells ‘healing’ in humans, though recent studies and investigations are ongoing. More examples can be found in young lab mice (which cannot, of course, be extrapolated across to humans). In the human examples, very specific circumstances are required, and the benefits have not yet been shown to be long term.

So could you please provide references when you make that claim, so members can examine the evidence and circumstances, and make up their own minds? I am certainly interested in seeing the basis of your statement that beta cells heal in up to 12 months.

Brunneria said:

Hi @Ronancastled

I really do applaud your success in putting your T2 into ‘remission’, but you have been making some really strong statements about beta cell healing on a few threads lately.

its very important, when making claims like this, to give appropriate references, and to specify which type of diabetes is being mentioned (because not all types can even hope for ‘remission’). And it is also important to explain the conditions and expectations involved.


So could you please provide references when you make that claim, so members can examine the evidence and circumstances, and make up their own minds? I am certainly interested in seeing the basis of your statement that beta cells heal in up to 12 months.

Click to expand...

Brunneria said:

Hi @Ronancastled

I really do applaud your success in putting your T2 into ‘remission’, but you have been making some really strong statements about beta cell healing on a few threads lately.

its very important, when making claims like this, to give appropriate references, and to specify which type of diabetes is being mentioned (because not all types can even hope for ‘remission’). And it is also important to explain the conditions and expectations involved.

My understanding is that there is actually very little evidence of beta cells ‘healing’ in humans, though recent studies and investigations are ongoing. More examples can be found in young lab mice (which cannot, of course, be extrapolated across to humans). In the human examples, very specific circumstances are required, and the benefits have not yet been shown to be long term.

So could you please provide references when you make that claim, so members can examine the evidence and circumstances, and make up their own minds? I am certainly interested in seeing the basis of your statement that beta cells heal in up to 12 months.

Click to expand...

The facts come from the Prof Roy Taylor 2 year follow up to the Direct Study for T2s with continued remission.

Covered here although I've quoted it in many other threads.
https://www.diabetes.co.uk/forum/th...two-years-full-recovery-of-beta-cells.171900/

References you require in that thread too.
Bottom line is that at 12 months post remission the 2nd phase insulin secretion rate is comparable to that of non diabetic cohort of equivalent age and weight.

I can get further into this in the thread I've copied if you prefer. Bottom line is a great beacon of hope.

Ronancastled said:

The facts come from the Prof Roy Taylor 2 year follow up to the Direct Study for T2s with continued remission.

Covered here although I've quoted it in many other threads.
https://www.diabetes.co.uk/forum/th...two-years-full-recovery-of-beta-cells.171900/

References you require in that thread too.
Bottom line is that at 12 months post remission the 2nd phase insulin secretion rate is comparable to that of non diabetic cohort of equivalent age and weight.

I can get further into this in the thread I've copied if you prefer. Bottom line is a great beacon of hope.

Click to expand...

Thank you.
That was just on type 2 diabetics, who had undergone significant weight loss, and is of unknown duration (because not enough time has passed to make long term claims). And from what I can remember of Taylor’s work, he only has a minority % who see the benefit of remission, decreasing over time.

I agree with you that this information can be considered a beacon of hope to those T2s who are in a position to (and wish to) follow the Newcastle Diet protocols, and who are able to maintain the significant weight loss over future years - which is obviously not every T2. This ‘beacon’ is most definitely not applicable to the other types of diabetes, so please bear these significant limitations in mind when you post, and provide references when you make claims like this:

Ronancastled said:

We now know it can take 12 months post remission for your beta cells to heal.

Click to expand...

Ronancastled said:

Bottom line is that at 12 months post remission the 2nd phase insulin secretion rate is comparable to that of non diabetic cohort of equivalent age and weight.

Click to expand...

This refers to diabetics who before those 12 monts had low insulin production. There is no way of knowing our insulin production without lab tests, so there is no way of knowing if this applies here. Your post is highly suggestive of diagnosing the opening poster with low insulin production, which may not be the case at all.

@Nanny_B , I wish you all the best with staying on the wagon!
Do you know what has triggered you in the past to fall off? Is there some strategy that could help you prevent this happening again? Or making it easier for you to get back on after a one-off mistake?

Nanny_B said:

I’m really scared I’ve done long lasting damage and will have to go on to insulin.

Click to expand...

Are you on any medication for your diabetes at the moment? If not, insulin won't be the next port of call by a long way. Have you had any appointments or blood tests for your diabetes lately?

@Brunneria @Antje77
I'll agree to disagree with both of you about my postings.

There are many posters on Reddit and Twitter, some of whom I correspond with, who have found significant weight loss their magic bullet. Although the paths to diabetes can be multifactorial there are a subset where it's purely down to visceral fat. All I wish to do is present my own experience as a possible pathway to remission.

There is an issue on Reddit where posters are warned off posting about reversal or remission. The long term members are all Keto advocates who have never been lucky enough to reintroduce carbs. I would implore you not to let this place become a carb hating echo chamber, there are other ways that work for some.

Having said all that I'll take a break from posting for a while. Might be in both our interests.

Nanny_B said:

The problem is my blood sugar levels are not dropping below 11 and show anything between that and 15. ( test strips in date) I’m really scared I’ve done long lasting damage and will have to go on to insulin. Can anyone advise approx how long it takes to start seeing normal blood sugar levels again?

Click to expand...

I don't think that anyone can - it all depends on when things start to sort themselves out.
When I was diagnosed I went two days eating just protein and fat - and not all that much. I had a steak one day and a pork shop the next - then on the third day a small salad with chicken, I think - no food which required insulin - but after a while I began to feel wobbly - I had burned through the stores of easily accessed glucose and now my metabolism had to face up to unloading stores from elsewhere. That did take weeks rather than days. A warm drink and three grapes sorted out the unpleasant effects, and in 80 days I was no longer in the diabetic range, and at the top end of normal at 6 months.
Over the years I was constantly pushed to abandon the low carb Atkins diet as it was next thing to Devil worship, and to embrace a high carb diet - it went on for decades, so I am not all that sure that you will have done damage to yourself, though the only thing to do is keep trying to put things right again and see what happens.
You will have considerable stores to unload, as I did - after years on a 'cholesterol lowering' diet I was almost spherical - but I now have lost 12 inches of my waistline and reached the age of 70, so there is hope for almost everyone, I think.

Ronancastled said:

@Brunneria @Antje77
I'll agree to disagree with both of you about my postings.

There are many posters on Reddit and Twitter, some of whom I correspond with, who have found significant weight loss their magic bullet. Although the paths to diabetes can be multifactorial there are a subset where it's purely down to visceral fat. All I wish to do is present my own experience as a possible pathway to remission.

There is an issue on Reddit where posters are warned off posting about reversal or remission. The long term members are all Keto advocates who have never been lucky enough to reintroduce carbs. I would implore you not to let this place become a carb hating echo chamber, there are other ways that work for some.

Having said all that I'll take a break from posting for a while. Might be in both our interests.

Click to expand...

You seem to have completely misunderstood my posts.
Both were intended to encourage you to use facts and references, rather than rhetoric, and to make you cautious about applying universal statements.

This forum has, for years, encouraged open discussion of the many different treatments available to the various different types of diabetic. We have entire sub forums that cheerfully and comprehensively discuss keto and low carb (as well as other ways of eating). We also have many threads, going back years, discussing the pros and cons of Taylor’s Newcastle Diet studies and 800 cal diets.

However, we do like any claims and categoric statements to be accompanied by reputable references, so that they can be discussed in detail by our members. And it is always good when the original poster gets responses that help with their query.

ed. For typos.

I’m T1 so a little different but I’ve fallen off the wagon more than once

I’m a comfort eater and whilst I keep nothing in the house to easily snack on.. the village shop is less than a hundred yards away

Just yesterday I has a falling out with someone and the first thing I did was goto the corner shop and buy all the munchies I could… sat in front of the TV and stuffed them all then topped it off with a hot chocolate.

So I’m not surprised people have fallen off the wagon over the last 12 months.

However I would have thought and significant long term damage would have been done in only 8 to 12 months.

So try and get back on track.. if you can’t without help go see the gp even if it means medication for a short while then so be it…. Some of the meds like bydureon also act as an appetite suppressant and bydureon the should take you off when you have a normal BMI

One thing is for certain though.. better control will reduce the risk of longer term damage .. so it’s never too late to try