Hi Sophia
she still has the same injections at meal times but perhaps a little more insulin
Err....seems to prove the point about carbs/glucose/Insulin I think ? :?
I do keep her snacks between meals to low carb (to avoid extra injections), unless she needs the energy boost for sports.
Seems, pretty sensible to me ?
Are children Aliens....? Their bodies are the same as an adults, just at differing stages of development. Human metabolism is complex and a miracle of life. Some things are pretty basic though. One is the effect of certain foods on the human body, what carbohydrates metabolise into, glucose. Now do you conciously feed your child glucose ? I wouldn't have thought so ? A non diabetic can metabolise the glucose and get back to normal pretty quickly, a diabetic can't do that and in the case of a T1 has to inject Insulin to cover it. It works, but it is surely not an ideal situation ? Break the chain somewhere and Insulin can then decrease not increase.
I'm certainly not recommending that a child go on a low carb diet ( I presume you mean Atkins ?).
If you look you will find that there are many types of so called low carb diets, what they all have in common is a reduction of carbohydrate intake. My reduced carb diet is totally different to others as I don't eat fats, for my own particular health reasons. I just picked out the best bits that work for me. I don't replace carbs with anything, I just have less.
What I am saying is that carbohydrates are toxic to a Diabetic, child or no. So, any reduction has to be a good thing ? Then you wouldn't need to add more Insulin to cover them, as quite obviously you are. More Insulin is also not a good idea either. Do you really want to fill the child with something that is instantly converted to glucose, the stuff that causes more Insulin to be required ? Why on earth would you want to do that ?
As for the fact that your care team recommend that intake of carbs that is hardly surprising is it ? They are obviously going to stick to the advice that is mandatory, not many are going to put their heads over the parapet and say that you should reduce carb intake. There are those that do and like here, are criticised for doing so. Trouble is a reduction does work....it lowers Bg levels and lowers the need for Insulin. I suppose you just have to go with what you believe. You have the choice, does the child ?
As you well know, there are very few on here who have professional qualifications in any particular subject. That has absolutely nothing to do with this discussion. Virtually everybody here gives their opinions the same as you are. You don't have to take note of them, you could just ignore them and go your own way. In the same way that I think you are wrong in believing everything that the HCP's tell you. I know it is difficult to go against the accepted thinking, but that is what brings progress ? Without people questioning things that they are told nothing would ever change.
It isn't going to stop the opinions being given. None of us need to justify ourselves to anybody. We just have different opinions to others. We question medics etc. We don't think that they are always the best judges of what is best for us. If I had listened to the HCP's I would probably be dead by now because of the flawed dietary advice - then I made my own decisions based on my own research.
So, we try to pass on the benefit of that life experience. Each is different, but we are all concerned for everybody else here, child or not. Why would anybody think we are trying to harm someone ? That seems a totally illogical response to me. :?