Pre

bigladneast said:

See the diebetic nurse at ours said no don’t buy one your not dibetic and that’s way over the top

Sensible diet don’t cut any foods out

Click to expand...

I disagree with your nurse, a meter used correctly helped me prevent a type 2 diagnosis and lose weight.

Why wait to find out what foods and portions are sensible for your blood sugar control? I don't cut out any food groups and eat a wider range of natural nutrient dense food than before prediabetes.

bigladneast said:

A lot of things get said on here that differ to medical advice I have been given even to point of pre dibetic buying their own testing kit

Click to expand...

Simple answer for that is that we've been there and done it unlike most HCP's...

bigladneast said:

Remember the supersize me film where he ate McDonald’s for 60 days solid he became borderline diebetic, but once he went back to normal diet it disappeared don’t get too wrapped up in doing too much

Click to expand...

So are you still going to do the Newcastle Diet, which is quite hard core, or are you just going to cut down on the junk food?

bulkbiker said:

Simple answer for that is that we've been there and done it unlike most HCP's...

Click to expand...

The great French writer Marcel Proust, who was virtually crippled by terrible ill-health all his life, wrote that you should only trust a doctor who himself suffers from your ailment. Obviously, this is not the whole truth - a GP who has never had eg chicken pox can perfectly well treat it. And conversely, middle-aged female doctors who must have themselves experienced menopause made a complete hash of helping me with mine. However, it does confirm my enthusiasm for writers Jenny Ruhl (T2) and Dr Bernstein (T1), as well as Dr Ian Lake (T1) Adam Brown of Diatribe (T1) Christel Oerum of Diabetes Strong (T1) Dr Keith Runyan (T1) Maria Muccioli PhD (T1). Sad that there are not more T2s (outside this Forum) offering guidance.

Alexandra100 said:

The great French writer Marcel Proust, who was virtually crippled by terrible ill-health all his life, wrote that you should only trust a doctor who himself suffers from your ailment. ..Sad that there are not more T2s (outside this Forum) offering guidance.

Click to expand...

Dr Tim Noakes (as in phd doc in sports science), Dr Michael Mosley (medical doctor and journalist and writer, Dr Jay Wortman (medical doctor and doc maker) - to name just three off the top of my head, all have been diagnosed with Type 2, and have reversed it and have gone on to communicate and disseminate meaningful information in various forms .

Then there is the doco chappie - Lathe Poland in 'Carb Loaded: A culture dying to eat'. Also the Irish sportsman for 'Cereal Killers' docos Donal O Neill.

And the marvellous Ivor Cummins, and Marty Kendall, have both had metabolic dysfunction - I am not sure 'how much' (if one can say that) but they both had dysregulated blood glucose to some extent and have done all the fantastic work that they have from an engineering/science position.

Those just off the top of my head....

AloeSvea said:

Dr Tim Noakes (as in phd doc in sports science), Dr Michael Mosley (medical doctor and journalist and writer, Dr Jay Wortman (medical doctor and doc maker) - to name just three off the top of my head, all have been diagnosed with Type 2, and have reversed it and have gone on to communicate and disseminate meaningful information in various forms .

Then there is the doco chappie - Lathe Poland in 'Carb Loaded: A culture dying to eat'. Also the Irish sportsman for 'Cereal Killers' docos Donal O Neill.

And the marvellous Ivor Cummins, and Marty Kendall, have both had metabolic dysfunction - I am not sure 'how much' (if one can say that) but they both had dysregulated blood glucose to some extent and have done all the fantastic work that they have from an engineering/science position.

Those just off the top of my head....

Click to expand...

Thanks, I'll certainly have a look at those. However the claim "I reversed my diabetes" always arouses my suspicions, to put it mildly. If it means, "Due to lifestyle measures my bg numbers have been going down instead of up" that's credible, but IMO the terminology is (deliberately?) misleading and actually encourages people to entertain false hopes of a complete cure.

Alexandra100 said:

Thanks, I'll certainly have a look at those. However the claim "I reversed my diabetes" always arouses my suspicions, to put it mildly. If it means, "Due to lifestyle measures my bg numbers have been going down instead of up" that's credible, but IMO the terminology is (deliberately?) misleading and actually encourages people to entertain false hopes of a complete cure.

Click to expand...

Now that is a whole other discussion!

Hi @bigladneast

Have read this thread with interest!
But your original topic is starting to get lost in other discussions.

Am very interested to hear how it is going? Are you still sticking with the strict diet? It can be so depressing and demoralising when you get conflicting advice, especially when it is the doc and the nurse in your own health care team who are contradicting each other.

So much information available here, and elsewhere, it can start to feel like info overload.

Please give us an update?

bigladneast said:

Hi

After 3 weeks in the Newcastle diet I had lost 10lb and the diebetic nurse at the practice advise to get another HBCA1 test done as she was convinced my reading would be normal this is 2 month after my first test, my first reading was 44 the second came back 37 back in the normal range.

I have continued with the diet and going to do so until next week then just a normal healthy balance diet I.e I will be bad at times then going to get checked again in 3 month. She was convinced that skipping breakfast is what caused my high reading along with lots of sugary snacks

Click to expand...

Thanks for the update.
And well done for sticking to your chosen diet schedule.

The good thing about being prediabetic is that you can often get back to 'normal' and out of prediabetes with less extreme diet changes than if things get as far a full blown type 2. So hopefully you have nipped things in the bud.

One thing I will mention though, is that lots of us here on the forum have found that something called Intermittent Fasting is great for helping us to keep and maintain good blood glucose levels. One of the ways that we intermittently fast, is by skipping breakfast. It has certainly helped me. So I respectfully disagree with your nurse on that point.

Once again, well done!

That's a great HbA1c reduction @bigladneast. Keep your sugar and carb intakes down and you should continue to be in the non-diabetic range.

For someone who has already shown that they don't cope well with carbs, a 'balanced diet' is equivalent to being balanced on the edge of a very steep slope. Continuing to eat the normal amount of carbs after a near miss could mean that in a few years you are back in the prediabetes range or even further along the track.Your doctor and nurse have given you some rather unrealistic advice about diet - in my opinion, and also what you can expect in the future.
I have dodged the bullet and from fully diabetic got down to the top end of normal. I know that I need to stick to what many might regard to a very restricted diet - but it is that or high blood glucose. My suspicion is that - having once got to prediabetes - your own carb intake should be less than the usual amount on a daily basis or you will simply drift back into the danger area.

Alexandra100 said:

Thanks, I'll certainly have a look at those. However the claim "I reversed my diabetes" always arouses my suspicions, to put it mildly. If it means, "Due to lifestyle measures my bg numbers have been going down instead of up" that's credible, but IMO the terminology is (deliberately?) misleading and actually encourages people to entertain false hopes of a complete cure.

Click to expand...

I know it is early days but I would like to "stand up" for the "I've reversed my diabetes" and the prospect of a complete cure. After 1 month of <800 calories, real food , low carb diet (as per Dr. Moseley) my blood sugars started responding normally (i.e. fasted and 2hr after meals were within the "normal" ranges). I carried on to lose more weight.

I then experimented with re-introducing carbs as the proper Newcastle diet was never "low carb".

I have, for many months now eaten everything that I used to eat, even to the extent of bingeing and my blood sugars 2 hours after meals are invariably within the normal range (below 7.8). The highest level I have seen was after Naan bread with 12.4 which lasted less than 15 mins and the time over 7.8 was less than an hour.

Even while binge eating and drinking my bloods are normal.

I am not advocating that anyone binges! I allow binges and counter the weight gain with intermittent fasting and watching my calories.

I would expect that if I put back the 3 1/2 stone that I have lost then I would become diabetic again. It is still early days as to whether the liver and pancreatic weight loss caused by the low calorie diets reverses and T2 comes back even if I don't bloat up again so I'm not saying that "I'm cured and everything will be OK" but it does concern me that no-one suggests that it might be possible for some of us lucky ones to effectively "cure" their diabetes at least in the short term. I don't want to raise people's hopes unrealistically but my experience should give hope to newly diagnosed T2's.

If anyone has managed to read this far into this long post could I ask why many people seem to be saying that being obese doesn't cause diabetes? Where is my misunderstanding? I was obese then I got diabetes then I got more obese. Diabetes didn't cause my obesity but it did fuel it. Surely if I hadn't been obese then I wouldn't have developed diabetes? Presumably this wouldn't apply to skinny-fat types but for the fatty-fat types like me...