Water makes my sugar drop...

Jocenel777

Newbie
Messages
2
Type of diabetes
Reactive hypoglycemia
Treatment type
Diet only
I have reactive hypoglycemia. I've had it since I was 12 years old. Currently 39. Anyway..

I'm trying to loose 30 to 40 pounds it makes me said though because if I drink water my sugar drops quickly.

If I take small sips of soda all day. I know nor healthy. My sugar doesn't drop...soda is bad and a waste of calories but what can I do?
 

Melgar

Moderator
Staff Member
Moderator
Messages
1,556
Type of diabetes
Other
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
Hi there @Jocenel777 and welcome to the forum. I’m going to take a stab at answering your question. There could be a couple of reasons, the most obvious is hydration, if you are slightly dehydrated then drinking water would cause a drop in blood sugars. By how much I don’t know.
The other reason maybe a bit obscure, but I heard this years ago. If you drink very cold water it can slow down metabolism of food. They say if you are trying to lose weight don’t drink iced water with your food. That might be a load of nonsense but I was told that years ago. You may get more constructive and helpful replies from other members.
 

Chris24Main

Moderator
Staff Member
Moderator
Messages
1,017
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
We definitely have some RH specialists on the forum, and I'm not one of them, but as far as I understand it, the main characteristic of RH is that there is an abnormal secondary response which ends up with more insulin than was needed, which pushes the blood glucose down too far.
My thought would be then that in your case, there is something about drinking water that triggers this secondary response in your case.

Any more detail that you could offer? - what happens if you sip water at the same rate as soda? - what levels are we talking about in terms of blood glucose?
 

Lamont D

Oracle
Messages
17,750
Type of diabetes
Reactive hypoglycemia
Treatment type
I do not have diabetes
In all my years on this forum discussing RH. I have never heard of water being an issue.
This has surprised me.
And I have no idea what to advise, except.....
When going abroad drink the beer not the water!
Do not take this advice seriously.

Flouride?
 

Grant_Vicat

Moderator
Staff Member
Moderator
Messages
1,350
Type of diabetes
Don't have diabetes
Treatment type
I do not have diabetes
Dislikes
Intolerance, selfishness, rice pudding
I have reactive hypoglycemia. I've had it since I was 12 years old. Currently 39. Anyway..

I'm trying to loose 30 to 40 pounds it makes me said though because if I drink water my sugar drops quickly.

If I take small sips of soda all day. I know nor healthy. My sugar doesn't drop...soda is bad and a waste of calories but what can I do?
I have just read this link, which doesn't give me a definite answer to your question. But it does make me wonder whether adding a couple of segments of an orange, or any fruit you enjoy, might counteract the sudden drop in BG?
 

Jocenel777

Newbie
Messages
2
Type of diabetes
Reactive hypoglycemia
Treatment type
Diet only
Background-

Diagnosis-When I was in 6th grade I passed out. When the nurse took my blood sugar it was severely low. Then they took me to the hospital and did the blood sugar test before eating and after. After I came back from the meal 3 hours later my sugar was dropped. That's how I found out I have reactive hypoglycemia which my Great Aunt did, not sure if hereditary.

Currently- I figured out overtime that if I ate an atkins type diet meat and green leafy vegetables it never went down. Not hardly ever. Yeah I probably should do that or the small meals.

Eventually I just moved on and wanted to eat carbs or whatever I wanted. I had to be careful with my sugar and back up with protein.

Then I just figured out if I sip on soda all day it never completely drops- sounds crazy/not healthy but works.
I tried drinking other things but it had to be something with high sugar 46 plus mg to sip on and I was good.

If I drink a cup of water my sugar will drop in like in 2-3 hours if I do nothing.

Anyway that's me lol.

Basically if I want to diet I know I need to do small meals protein leafy greens. If I don't my unorthodox method of soda works I guess lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lamont D

Lamont D

Oracle
Messages
17,750
Type of diabetes
Reactive hypoglycemia
Treatment type
I do not have diabetes
Hi, I was diagnosed over twelve years ago.
And I never thought that soda could help with control.
What type of soda?

Ignore your BG levels for now.... What symptoms do you get through the day?
Have you had further very low episodes?
Do you feel hungry, fidgety, trembling, headaches, eyes blurring, spaced out?
Do these symptoms happen after food, soda?
What other diagnostic tests have you had?
Any other conditions?
Sorry about the questioning, but I'm trying to understand a little more.

One of the things that I am concerned with, is how much all that soda and carbs, if you are RH, is going to do to your metabolism in a few years.
Why?
Because I went there, but I was unaware of my condition at that time.
Before diagnosis, I was really ill, my weight was eighteen stone plus, very obese, my organs were in decline. And my endocrinologist told me in no uncertain manner, that I would have probably died a few years ago if I hadn't done something about it. I did.
Can you fast?
Have you fasted?
I ask this because the defining diagnostic test, which is used when the other diagnostic tests present no diagnosis. I'm talking, full blood panel, including c-peptide, GAD, a mixed meal (which I think you had) an extended oral glucose tolerance test (5 hours) scans on your organs, intolerance tests, food allergys, then finally a seventy hours fasting test.
RH is a food related condition.
Mainly carbs and sugars, and even some industrial sugars, additives, oils and such.
If you have RH.....
You react to food.
You react because you are intolerant to certain dietary factors.
I have been lactose intolerant since very young.
But I found out that I'm also intolerant to wheat, grains, carby vegetables and such. Believe it or not, with wheat, it is not gluten, but the carb count in the wheat flour itself. It is one of the reasons that wheat is in BOLD letters on every product. It is typically sold as healthy...
But for me it's definitely not.
It probably is not for you.
So I am concerned about your future health.
Because it will build to another issue going forward and many with similar metabolic conditions do increasingly become prediabetic and probably T2.
I endeavour to not go hypo, or even not not spike higher than the BG levels that trigger my reaction and subsequent hypos, by avoiding these foods and drinks that spike you and trigger the reaction, the excess insulin (called an overshoot) which produces the hypos. My trigger levels are around 7-8mmols.
Do you have a glucose monitors or CGM? To see what happens.
I tend to want to be and my body certainly does, like to be in as near normal BG levels as possible, no spikes, and if I can, I use intermittent fasting and every so often have a couple of days fasting.
I only eat for a few hours each day. I eat less because of this. And as you have hinted, you have before, good protein, good saturated fats, leafy vegetables. Which are all low carbs and are healthy for you.
Even looking at a keto diet.

BG levels are important, it shows how in control you are of the condition.
Keeping a food diary, to record your daily results, mainly before and after (2 hours). And maybe your fasting BG levels.
You naturally fast during the night, sleeping. So why not try to extend it.? See if you can fast.

Finally, I eat when I want, not because it's a labelled meal time.
My body does not like much food.
And even favourites from young have to be avoided to be as healthy as possible.
And I'm never hungry, don't hypo, and in control. No symptoms unless I am a bad lad or inadvertently have something that will spike me.

So, no carbs, no spike, no symptoms, no overshoot of insulin, no hypo.
No hypos, better future health, no symptoms. Better life.

Keep asking.
Keep learning,
Keep safe.

BTW.... I'm approaching 70, and I'm very healthy for an oldie. Clear brain, high energy, no lethargy.
It works for me.
But if you prefer soda............eek!!!!
A balanced dietary approach, tailored for you, by you, because of your BG results.
That is my recommendation.
Best wishes.