May I ask why I should get protein from pulses and grains that spike me rather than from meat and poultry that doesn't? I am not afraid of sat fat or of cholesterol so that argument holds no sway with me.
We are all unique, you have seen great results with your chosen diet but telling people to eat grain based foods when many, many people can barely tolerate them is a little thoughtless imo.
The whole point was to answer and share my own experience, I wasn't telling any one to stop MEATing for that matter, I EAT everything myself in MODERATION!May I ask why I should get protein from pulses and grains that spike me rather than from meat and poultry that doesn't? I am not afraid of sat fat or of cholesterol so that argument holds no sway with me.
We are all unique, you have seen great results with your chosen diet but telling people to eat grain based foods when many, many people can barely tolerate them is a little thoughtless imo.
My type2 has made it far too expensive to have any decent life insurance coverage although I’m not on any meds and my numbers for the most part have been anywhere from the at risk level to barely into the type2 range.
They don't expect us to live as long, so are willing to pay out higher benefits.
Ok, how about this for an answer: the standard western diet is not healthy for anyone regardless of whether they're diabetic or not. So even if a person can eat the standard western diet and maintain normal blood glucose levels, they still increase their chances of getting other western diseases such as cancer, heart disease, stroke, Alzheimer, etc. So even if I could go back to SAD and maintain normal blood glucose levels, I wouldn't.Ok, thank you, it was relevant to me but never mind.
Many thanks for your reply.Ok, how about this for an answer: the standard western diet is not healthy for anyone regardless of whether they're diabetic or not. So even if a person can eat the standard western diet and maintain normal blood glucose levels, they still increase their chances of getting other western diseases such as cancer, heart disease, stroke, Alzheimer, etc. So even if I could go back to SAD and maintain normal blood glucose levels, I wouldn't.
Agreed, the diet eaten by many in the west of processed rubbish is unhealthy, though life expectancy does continue to rise so maybe not as unhealthy as we assume.Ok, how about this for an answer: the standard western diet is not healthy for anyone regardless of whether they're diabetic or not. So even if a person can eat the standard western diet and maintain normal blood glucose levels, they still increase their chances of getting other western diseases such as cancer, heart disease, stroke, Alzheimer, etc. So even if I could go back to SAD and maintain normal blood glucose levels, I wouldn't.
Well they certainly don't help... and aren't necessary for life so....why bother?but carbs are not the problem by themselves
I think you might, as diabetes can be genetic.But...if you had always naturally eaten a low carb diet and never had any issues, never been tested, could you still be diabetic and not know it?
Modern medicine is certainly helping people live longer, but that doesn't mean the standard western diet is healthy. The current standard western diet is heavy on sugar, refined carbs, industrially produced seed oils, and highly processed food. This results in a significant increase in the chances of getting one or more of the western diseases such as type 2 diabetes, NAFLD, Alzheimers, cancer, cardiovascular disease, obesity, metabolic syndrome, etc. I disagree that most people can subsist on SAD all their life and suffer no health affects from that diet. Very few people in the western world survive to old age free of any chronic diseases. Rather, most die of one of these diseases.Agreed, the diet eaten by many in the west of processed rubbish is unhealthy, though life expectancy does continue to rise so maybe not as unhealthy as we assume.
However, this does not mean that all carbs are unhealthy. Most people have no problem eating moderate amounts of carbs as part of a balanced diet and for most people will come to no harm from this at all.
A combination of too little exercise and too much processed food is the most likely cause of ill health, including metabolic syndrome leading to diabetes, heart disease, and cancer. Too many carbs plays a part in this, as does too much fat and too many calories generally, but carbs are not the problem by themselves.
Well they certainly don't help... and aren't necessary for life so....why bother?
Good wine, bacon, cheese, sex, music, fell walking, steak, friendship, brandy, lamb chops...............I could go on (and on).....
None of these are 'necessary for life' but they give pleasure to some people and without compelling evidence that they are harmful why should people give them up? There is no compelling evidence (or any significant evidence at all) that moderate intake of carbohydrates is in any way harmful to a healthy individual.
There is evidence to suggest that a high saturated fat diet increases the chances of high levels of LDL cholesterol, which in turn increases the chances of atherosclerosis and CVD. Therefore, high fat diet makes CVG, heart attack, and stroke more likely, not certain, but more likely. Recent evidence suggests that this connection is not as straightforward as was once thought, but the connection still exists.
It is probably the case that for many people who cannot process carbs due to permanent damage to the pancreas, leading to uncontrolled BG/insulin, the risks of high fat are lower than the risks of uncontrolled BG. But it is not without risk, and will never be desirable for a healthy person.
I don't drink but would agree that most of the others are essential certainly for my life...and I enjoy them all eating my way.
How many "healthy" individuals are on this site however. We are here because we have a condition and some of us can't process carbs because of it so they are surely best avoided in that case.
I see more and more evidence that sat fat is nothing to worry about and am happy to take in as much as my way of eating brings. LDL is the new "demon" but again I have yet to see any convincing evidence. As Dr Fung would say is our body so stupid to make something that we have eaten for millennia (sat fat) bad for us? In my opinion it is far more likely to be something more recently introduced into our diets that causes the problems. Excess carbs fits this description nicely..
Ok, how about this for an answer: the standard western diet is not healthy for anyone regardless of whether they're diabetic or not. So even if a person can eat the standard western diet and maintain normal blood glucose levels, they still increase their chances of getting other western diseases such as cancer, heart disease, stroke, Alzheimer, etc. So even if I could go back to SAD and maintain normal blood glucose levels, I wouldn't.
Good wine, bacon, cheese, sex, music, fell walking, steak, friendship, brandy, lamb chops...............I could go on (and on).....
None of these are 'necessary for life' but they give pleasure to some people and without compelling evidence that they are harmful why should people give them up? There is no compelling evidence (or any significant evidence at all) that moderate intake of carbohydrates is in any way harmful to a healthy individual.
There is evidence to suggest that a high saturated fat diet increases the chances of high levels of LDL cholesterol, which in turn increases the chances of atherosclerosis and CVD. Therefore, high fat diet makes CVG, heart attack, and stroke more likely, not certain, but more likely. Recent evidence suggests that this connection is not as straightforward as was once thought, but the connection still exists.
It is probably the case that for many people who cannot process carbs due to permanent damage to the pancreas, leading to uncontrolled BG/insulin, the risks of high fat are lower than the risks of uncontrolled BG. But it is not without risk, and will never be desirable for a healthy person.
In my opinion it is far more likely to be something more recently introduced into our diets that causes the problems. Excess carbs fits this description nicely..
I'd agree that it's likely to be recent changes (i.e. last few decades) to western lifestyles that explain the increasing incidences of Type 2.
Excess carbs is one candidate. As are excess calories. As is insufficient exercise.
I appear to have been born with a body that could make a decent job of running away from predators, or hunting for food. However I find myself living in strange times, where all I need to do to survive, is sit behind a desk all day to earn money, then waddle to a shop where the shelves are packed with more calories than my body knows what to do with.
It's certainly not all about balance and self control for *everyone*. Some people will never be able to get Type 2 no matter how hard they try, and some people will not be able to avoid it. I don't know where I lie on that spectrum, but there is plenty of reason to believe that, had I had more self control (or hindsight) I could have spent all my life eating all types of food in moderation and I wouldn't have Type 2.
I don't drink but would agree that most of the others are essential certainly for my life...and I enjoy them all eating my way.
How many "healthy" individuals are on this site however. We are here because we have a condition and some of us can't process carbs because of it so they are surely best avoided in that case.
I see more and more evidence that sat fat is nothing to worry about and am happy to take in as much as my way of eating brings. LDL is the new "demon" but again I have yet to see any convincing evidence. As Dr Fung would say is our body so stupid to make something that we have eaten for millennia (sat fat) bad for us? In my opinion it is far more likely to be something more recently introduced into our diets that causes the problems. Excess carbs fits this description nicely..
Eating too much of any macronutrient can cause health issues. If you consume more calories than you use, you will gain weight. Processed food, being very energy dense and easy to overconsume is part of the problem.
It isn't compulsory though, it is possible to avoid large food companies and their products. If diabetes teaches anything it is that eating more nutritious food, avoiding processed food, increases chances of a long healthy life.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?