• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »

Which phone? Samsung or iPhone?

Dillinger

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,209
Location
London
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Celery.
My phone contract has ended; should I move from an iPhone to a Samsung Galaxy S4 or S5?

Tedious question I know...

Best

Dillinger


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
I've been with iPhone for years but gonna try the new Samsung S5 in April. Can't beat the iPhone apps but I'm just bored with Apple now ! **** battery life too !
 
My phone contract has ended; should I move from an iPhone to a Samsung Galaxy S4 or S5?

Tedious question I know...

Best

Dillinger


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App

Personally I would stick to iPhone but plenty of others would advocate the Samsung phones and they are both awesome phones as well.

Also to mix it up a bit, if you take alot of photos the Nokia Lumina 1020 has a camera with a 41 MP resolution! It is a windows phone though so not so popular.

I've had an iPhone 4S for coming up to 2 years and its going to be the first time ever that I've not upgraded at the end of my contract as I'm that happy with the phone.

It used to be that you needed to upgrade for the latest tech but my opinion is that phones are much the same now and its only really a question of if the phone still meets your need and if the battery still has optimum performance etc.


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
Thanks, I agree about being bored with Apple, but feel some 'tech guilt' about rejecting this incredible bit of technology because I'm bored!

The other thing is that I find my iPhone is a bit flakey as a phone which is ironic. It's like saying "my car is amazing apart from the driving..."

That is amazing about the Lumia!

Best

Dillinger


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
I've had every iphone since they first came out

I've also had more than a dozen recent android phones including

Htc one x
Samsung s3 and s4
Galaxy note 1,2,3
Sony experia z

And each of the androids I've only kept for a month or so and then gone back to the iphone

Some things have never worked so well on android, push notifications being the main one

But it's one of those thing of personal preference

I even had a funny 5 minutes where I almost considered a blackberry z30


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
Hi, I have had a single Android phone through T-Mobile. What really annoyed me about Android, was that when I really wanted my phone to be upgraded with a more recent release of the Android OS, I first had to wait for the hardware vendor (HTC) to decide whether or not to port the new OS to the phone hardware despite it not being that old. Then when HTC made the OS update available for that handset, I had to wait for several months for T-Mobile to put their branding onto it and finally push it out over their network. I decided then, the best option for a smartphone would be Apple, because iOS updates are easily available for each of their models for several years. They therefore dont't become obsolete as quickly as any other phone.
 
I've had iPhones and Samsungs and the Nexus 5 blows them both out of the water. Failing that, I'd advise an LG G2.
 
Coincidentally, I've just been looking at the Samsung Galaxy SIII ... I might try it in May when my upgrade is due.
 
Hi, I have had a single Android phone through T-Mobile. What really annoyed me about Android, was that when I really wanted my phone to be upgraded with a more recent release of the Android OS, I first had to wait for the hardware vendor (HTC) to decide whether or not to port the new OS to the phone hardware despite it not being that old. Then when HTC made the OS update available for that handset, I had to wait for several months for T-Mobile to put their branding onto it and finally push it out over their network. I decided then, the best option for a smartphone would be Apple, because iOS updates are easily available for each of their models for several years. They therefore dont't become obsolete as quickly as any other phone.
Oh that sounds like a lot of bother... enough to put me off altogether...
 
Oh that sounds like a lot of bother... enough to put me off altogether...

That's one thing that always bothered me

Samsung and htc Are coming out with so many new handsets each year that updates seem to be last on the list of priorities and very short lived, not often you get an update on a handset more than a year old


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
Oh that sounds like a lot of bother... enough to put me off altogether...
This is why people who want the latest android release should buy GOOGLE phones! Since Google develops android, those of us who use their nexus phones get the updates before anyone else. Samsung, HTC, Sony, LG etc. all use their own customised version of Android that comes with a ton of unnecessary apps that they need to update before they can release a stabilised version of the new Android.
 
I've had iPhones and Samsungs and the Nexus 5 blows them both out of the water. Failing that, I'd advise an LG G2.

Hi Giverny,

What about it is better? I know people like the Samsungs because they are easier to customise than iPhones, but I'm not really that bothered about that. Is it a technical or aesthetic preference?

Thanks

Dillinger
 
I had to replace my own phone recently so I also had the same issue to decide on.

In the end I decided to stay with Apple mainly on the grounds that I have been using iPhones for years and have had no problems with them. Things just work the way I expect them to.

I also did not want to have to learn how to use a new operating system or have to replace the large number of iOS apps I already own.

So I chose the path of least resistance and went with the iPhone 5s.

I larger screen size and better battery life would not go amiss though

Pavlos


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
Hi Giverny,

What about it is better? I know people like the Samsungs because they are easier to customise than iPhones, but I'm not really that bothered about that. Is it a technical or aesthetic preference?

Thanks

Dillinger
The main reason I got my Nexus 5 is that it's affordable. I paid £300 for it, sim-free and pay £12/mo for unlimited data, texts and minutes. Compared to the £600+ you'd pay for an iPhone that has zero customisability, lower specs, and is pretty much proven not to stand the test of time (iOS updates making older devices unstable etc.) it's really a bargain.

The decision was also partly based on both the technical aspects and the aesthetics. The phone is higher spec than pretty much every phone on the market right now, and at the price you pay for it you get more than your money's worth. Aesthetically, it's great.

Here's a copy-paste of a review I wrote for the Nexus 5:

The nexus 5 is Google's new flagship Android phone. Following in the well-trodden footsteps of its predecessor, the nexus 4, it dons a pair of bigger boots that are proving incredibly difficult for other manufacturers to fill.

Initially, I was a little dubious about the transition from custom Android ROMs on my I9100 to stock Android. However, I wasn't disappointed. Android 4.4 KitKat is easily the best one yet, without a doubt. I particularly like that Google are now really pushing out the whole ‘make the experience yours’ attitude with the option to change your default launcher and SMS apps.

Google have also phased in their Google Now very well and it’s not especially intrusive. Overall, it’s been very helpful in providing traffic updates on long journeys and keeping me up to date with those all-important football scores (you can turn off live score updates for certain teams if you want). In fact, it even reminded me of an appointment I had totally forgotten about… phew! After seeing video snapshots of people playing around with the ‘OK Google’ voice prompts, I was disappointed to find that this doesn’t work if your language is set to UK English. I changed it to US English but it then had a bit of trouble understanding the British accent, as expected. Oh well, not a major deal breaker. The Google caller ID lookup is also incredibly efficient at telling me who’s calling even if their number isn’t saved in my Google account.

The 2.3GHz quad-core Snapdragon 800 processor combined with 2GB RAM and Google’s bloat-free OS ensure that you get the best experience available to any Android user right out of the box. It handles virtually anything with finesse and the whole mobile experience, for the first time in a long time, truly feels seamless. We threw a couple of games on there, expecting some framerate lag somewhere along the way but were truly amazed at the performance.
The Nexus 5 is also equipped to handle 4G straight out of the box and boy does it handle well! Even in the dreary depths of Coventry, I could load up Reddit and browse to my heart’s content.

All this speed and amazing hardware does come at a price, albeit not a monetary one. The battery life suffers slightly if you don’t remember to turn off your data and location services when you’re not using them. Personally, I use my phone excessively for around 3 hours a day during my commute between home and work. During this time, I’m listening to music through Spotify, constantly refreshing Facebook and Twitter, loading up videos on YouTube and reading the news. It does quite easily last a whole working day without any sweat and is out of juice by about 7pm.
The camera is really nothing special. It takes decent pictures but isn’t anything revolutionary like the Sony Xperia Z1 or Nokia Lumia 1020. The video capabilities were beyond expectation and the phone does a great job of negating any shakes and bumps in your footage whilst also capturing surprisingly good audio. The HDR function is disappointingly slow, but if you’ve got a few seconds to take that snap then by all means go for it! The Optical Image Stabilisation (OIS) is the only thing that’s really different between the Nexus 5 and other smartphones. It ensures you get a nice crisp image every time… if you’re willing to wait for the slow shutter.

Straight out of the box, it's obvious that for a reasonably cheap £300 smartphone, the finish exceeds all expectation. The soft plastic finish provides you with a nice sense of grip, unlike the plastic Samsung models and glass iPhones. The ceramic lock and volume buttons on the sides are subtle but work great. If you don't get on with the flatter buttons then you might want to invest in a case to help. Unfortunately, it didn't take long for the ceramic buttons to reveal their small flaw. About 3 days in to using the phone, we started to notice a rattling noise whenever there was any haptic feedback from button presses. Turned out this was coming from the power/lock button. Whilst it's not always noticeable, you can definitely hear it quite easily when you're in a quiet room. If, like me, you have ridiculously small hands then it might take you a little while to get the hang of stretching out your hand a little more than you would with other phones. The screen is a nice size for viewing though, and it's bright enough for outdoor use on a sunny day. Sadly, the speaker leaves a lot to be desired. In comparison to the HTC One’s Beats Audio experience, it’s incredibly quiet and can be hard to hear in noisy environments. On a day out in Greenwich my phone rang 3 times on full volume and I didn’t even hear it. Pair this with the fairly weak vibration motor and you’re in for a bad time if you work on a building site or anywhere else that’s noisy.

Overall, the Nexus 5 is definitely the best Android phone on the market. It’s priced to undercut the iPhone 5, HTC One and Xperia Z1 by a huge margin and outperform them at the same time, leaving them in the dust. Unless you’re after a phone with a larger screen or expandable storage, this is a very safe bet.
 
I don't know what it is, But for some reason I just like the look and feel to apple products, they look professional and smart, I'm not saying samsung etc don't but the operating systems they use put me off quite abit where as apples just looks great, I'd stick to apple :D
 
The biggest drawback to the samsung to me is its fragility as a workkday phone. i've had my iphone for 3 years now dropped it hundreds of times and no damage. 3 of my friends over the past couple of months have dropped their new samsungs and suffered shattered screens within a couple of weeks of getting them.

I also had an Android tablet for ages but got very fed up with the apps compared to those on the iphone, so dumped it for an iPad. Its just a more polished product.


Sent from the Diabetes Forum App
 
Hi Dillinger!

Well, I'm not an expert in mobile phones these days so you'll probably want to ignore this, but I decided I am actually bored with mobile phones - not bored with any particular make or model, but I just want a phone that works, with enough texts, minutes and data that I don't have to think about it - and most importantly I want it to be cheap! Gone are the days when I worried about having the latest flashy handset and contract. So, when my contract came up recently I looked around for the best deal - not just on handset but also on network. I ended up ditching my rather expensive iPhone on O2 for a much more budget-friendly MotoG on Tesco network. In so doing I have cut my monthly charge from around £40 per month to £12.99 per month - and the phone was free on a 2 year contract. It's an Android phone. It does all the things Android phones do - or at least the things i need to do with it. It probably lacks the real whizzy features, but i'd never have used them anyway. It lacks the iPhone's looks, but I can live with that. Porting my phone number was easy and went without a hitch. Tesco use O2s network so the coverage is the same. I haven't found a downside yet.

I guess in the end it depends what you do with your phone. If you use it a lot for Apps, you might find it a bit expensive to move from the iPhone and have to re-purchase the Apps you want. Also any accessories, because the Apple connections are different, so chargers, docks, etc etc might need replacing. The camera isn't as good on the MotoG as the iPhone, but hey! it's a phone - I have a camera for taking pictures! If all you do is phone, text and use the internet a bit, I'd go for a cheaper deal and save yourself some money - if you use it is a mini computer then think about the features you use the most and make sure whatever you're upgrading to has those covered.

Personally I can find far better things to spend my money on than the latest handset and overpriced contract - but it's taken me many years to believe that ;-)

Smidge
 
iphone all the way for me, I've tried others but this little bar of gold just seems so sturdy and the perfect size etc, i use it all the time and like thommo I've dropped it so many times, I've a small thin case thing around it but offers little protection but its always been fine (fingers crossed) i dropped it into a puddle the other day, it was completely submerged in the muddie curb puddle for the few seconds it took me to fish it out and its absolutely fine. plus my mate just went for the galaxy and wishes he hadn't
 
I have a Samsung Note 2 and MW has an S4. Both are better than iPhones. As a techie I don't get taken in my the Apple marketing "we're better, more reliable, easier to use" rubbish, it simply isn't true. Apple are brilliant at sales whereas most techs know their kit is no better and in many cases is worse than other manufacturers. You end up paying a premium and lock yourself into their world view for example ITunes compared to better services like Spotify etc.

I'm about to change providers and will be picking a Nexus 5 like Giverny as they look like they rock.

If you go down the Google Nexus route you should pretty much guarantee that you will get the latest OS upgrades as Android is made by Google. That's the only criticism I've had with Samsung, the time it takes them to release later versions of Android. I've only recently been upgraded to 4.2 but 4.4 is already on the Nexus.
 
Back
Top