Sweden has not endorsed LCHF diet yet

[Oldvatr]

Contrary to what is trending on the internet at the moment, it seems that claims being made that Sweden has officially adopted new guidelines that endorse LCHF diets appear to be premature, although that position may change.

This commentary here discusses this and seems to provide a rationale that is probably true for the moment. It is not a debunking of the effects of the diet, but clarifies the official position somewhat.

https://experiencelife.com/article/debunking-news-of-swedens-low-carb-high-fat-guidelines/


Note: Sweden was in the early days the seedbed of LCHF and provided much of the early scientific progress in its transformation from Banting to LCHF, It was also the first country worldwide to condemn LCHF as being dangerous to life and to be avoided. This dichotomy still lives on.

Here is an article on the web about the supposed change alledgedly made by Sweden, so must be viewed with eyes open to what I posted above. However, I think it is a good article anyway, and has good referenced material.

https://benjamindavidsteele.wordpress.com/2019/06/02/official-guidelines-for-low-carb-diet/

 

[Listlad]

Contrary to what is trending on the internet at the moment, it seems that claims being made that Sweden has officially adopted new guidelines that endorse LCHF diets appear to be premature, although that position may change.

This commentary here discusses this and seems to provide a rationale that is probably true for the moment. It is not a debunking of the effects of the diet, but clarifies the official position somewhat.

https://experiencelife.com/article/debunking-news-of-swedens-low-carb-high-fat-guidelines/


Note: Sweden was in the early days the seedbed of LCHF and provided much of the early scientific progress in its transformation from Banting to LCHF, It was also the first country worldwide to condemn LCHF as being dangerous to life and to be avoided. This dichotomy still lives on.

Here is an article on the web about the supposed change alledgedly made by Sweden, so must be viewed with eyes open to what I posted above. However, I think it is a good article anyway, and has good referenced material.

https://benjamindavidsteele.wordpress.com/2019/06/02/official-guidelines-for-low-carb-diet/

Are you in Sweden?

 

[Rosiegough_]

Wonder why it’s dangerous

 

[Listlad]

What has the OPs location got to do with either of the articles?

Local diets vary across the globe. I spent a year in Sweden and have a degree of insight into the diet. Hence the question.

Good enough?

 

[Guzzler]

It is interesting that in the second article cholesterol values are discussed but other than that there are firm identifiers stating risk... of anything.

 

[Guzzler]

Local diets vary across the globe. I spent a year in Sweden and have a degree of insight into the diet. Hence the question.

Good enough?

Not really, a diet lower in carbs in the West is just that whether you are in Sweden or Bulgaria or the US. A carb is a carb after all.

 

[kitedoc]

Thankyou for the clarification @Oldvatr.
Methinks the saturated fat/cholesterol/ lipid hypothesis beliefs are a stalling point, but that is a guess.

 

[Oldvatr]

Are you in Sweden?

Nope, but the Internet gets there for me. Did my research when I was skeptikal over LCHF myself, and it took me a while to unlearn all I had been taught. Started with Banting and Harvey, and moved up the timeline.

 

[Mr_Pot]

Thankyou for the clarification @Oldvatr.
Methinks the saturated fat/cholesterol/ lipid hypothesis beliefs are a stalling point, but that is a guess.

I think low carb would be more acceptable everywhere without the high fat label. Of course some people actually pursue high fat but for many it is just a case of adequate fat or compensating fat. In my case I don't really eat more fat than I used to, but now I don't feel guilty about it.

 

[Brunneria]

Hi Everyone

I only just came across this thread and realised how far off topic it had drifted (into a kind of 'What I eat') with absolutely no relevance to the OP.

Those posts have now been moved into the General Chat section of the forum, here
https://www.diabetes.co.uk/forum/threads/what-i-eat.164918/
for those who want to continue that discussion, to avoid further derailment.

 

[Listlad]

........but now I don't feel guilty about it.

Me neither.

 

[JohnEGreen]

I like Norway I remember sitting in an establishment at 3 AM wondering why it was still light till I remembered where I was.I did eat a fair bit of salami, ham, smoked salmon and pickled herring. while I was there so low carb would not be a problem.

The photo is of Andenes in Andøya Where I stayed for a while.

 

[Listlad]

I like Norway I remember sitting in an establishment at 3 AM wondering why it was still light till I remembered where I was.I did eat a fair bit of salami, ham, smoked salmon and pickled herring. while I was there so low carb would not be a problem.

The photo is of Andenes in Andøya Where I stayed for a while.



View attachment 33406

Nice scenery.

So I wonder if there is such a thing as a Noggie diabetic?

 

[AloeSvea]

Hejsan! I have written about this issue rather a lot in this forum, but here I go again. I need to look up more information for this thread on a different computer, than the laptop I am currently on, and get the latest official stance on LCHF (ie in Swedish, off Swedish Governmental websites), at least to read and summarise in English to post here. So I plan to do this some time today.

What I have mentioned before is that certainly LCHF has a very high level of social acceptance in Sweden. It is known about by the general populace, and, as there has been court cases about it, vis a vis medical professionals advocating it, it is legal and accepted as an official dietary treatment, as mentioned above, for weight loss/management/obesity and for treating and managing diabetes. This is all well documented, as it centred on a legal case re professional practice- can the doc continue to practice or not? situation with the doctor known as 'Doctor Fat' (Doktor Fett) https://annikadahlqvist.com/., and the famous Diet Doctor writes and posts about it. But a statistic I rather like was mentioned on the wonderful documentary 'Statin Nation' that about 25% of Swedes actually practice some degree of LCHF/Keto way of eating. And as Stockholm had two LCHF food boutiques when I lived there, I was inclined to think that stat could be true.

It is also true though, that when I took a hospital-based diabetes education course for those with diabetes, LCHF/Keto was not promoted, in fact I was shocked to spend a whole morning on which loaves of bread were best, by the very un-carb-troubled nutritionist. This was followed by the afternoon getting to know the syringe for the insulin injection that was being treated as inevitable, because, treating diabetes with food was too hard (and insulin injections and kidney dialysis are sooo easty!) This was 5 years ago - I do not know how if that has improved if changed at all since. (Recently diagnosed in Sweden add to this thread?)

What I do like about talking about nutrition with Swedes, compared to NZers, is I don't get lead down an odd nutritional path in conversation, which inevitably ends up with folks telling me you can't defecate on Keto, and other such strange things. (Oh the wonders of propaganda!) It becomes, ah, uncomfortable when I get asked how long I have eaten the LCHF/Keto way and I say over four years. This is due to the differences in both social acceptance, and knowledge of that way of eating, as well as the range of ways of eating generally.

But I will do a bit of research on official acceptance, or not, anon, and post on it later.

 

[Brunneria]

Hi All,

Just notifying that more posts have been deleted, and thread bans have been given to some members, after continued derailing.

 

[millenium]

So which other countries endorsed LCHF?

 

[AloeSvea]

OK, I read the official document on 'what's healthy to eat and what's not' from Swedish officialdom. -

https://www.livsmedelsverket.se/glo...iska-naringsrekommendationer-2012-svenska.pdf

and guess what? The stuff @Oldvatr reported being reported is in fact - true! (I know you knew this already Oldvatr! .) That LCHF is not officially endorsed in Sweden.

Not a single solitary word about LCHF, and in fact, advocating the old margarine instead of butter line, and the very very odd line of throwing red meat in with added sugar for causing - yes - amongst other diseases - diabetes. Yeah - that ol' thing.

So, yes, back to what I was suggesting in my above post - LCHF and Keto has very high social acceptance and knowledge about in Sweden, but not official acceptance, still.

And, as the diet doctor says - the SBU info was as an expert committee, not the government department of health. And his comments are about a possible LCHF positive future, not a current LCHF positive present (governmentally speaking).

 

[JohnEGreen]

Either it's been endorsed by Sweden or it has not if not and that is a fact it leaves little else to say other than thank you for the information so @Oldvatr thank you and end of story.