• Guest - w'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2026 Survey »

Kenny's "In Remission" thread - Six Years Keto

October's results are in and much as expected.

A1c is 39, so I'm inclining more to the theory that my "real value" on current lifestyle is somewhere about 38. The variation of my results since April 2020 then being down to variation in machines and acceptable testing inaccuracies. Weight unchanged. All bloods "normal" (undefined) and for the first time ever no statin conversation. Maybe they've just given up on that.

I did remember to fast for around 18 hours before the blood draw this time. Recommended.
 
Today marks five years since my Type 2 diagnosis on 9th December 2019.

9th December 2019 is also the day that I started low carb/keto, and I've been limiting carbs ever since. In anticipation of the diagnosis, I had already read up quite a bit on that way of eating (almost all the good stuff was found on this forum). If not for the advice and support from the people on this forum, particularly in the early days, I don't think I'd be where I am now. Still using the same GlucoRxQ meter but on my third lancet.

If anyone had said to me at Christmas 2019 that by Christmas 2024 I'd not only have normal BGs (achieved by April 2020) but be six and a half stone lighter and playing football three times a week, I wouldn't have believed it. And yet here it is.

So much for keto being only a "short term fix". Keto is sustainable (some willpower is needed in the beginning) and has worked very well for me.
 
Last edited:
March 2025 checkup/monitoring:

HbA1c 37. BP 125/80. Weight slightly up (14 stone/90kg), which I am not bothered about as I think it's football-driven muscle (re)gain - my waist is still shrinking - down to under 32 inches.

However, there's a story to this. The initial A1c test was done on the machine at the general practice and that returned a value of 53! I challenged it - it would have been my highest ever HbA1c - and the DN agreed to do a blood draw for a lab test. That resulted in the 37 (which is more like what I'd have expected).

I guess the moral of the story is that the testing machines can be really wrong sometimes. One rogue result in five years...... I don't think it's worth fretting much about a couple of points either way - a 39 as opposed to a 37, for example, there's just that built-in level of machine variation. But clearly machines can be seriously wrong sometimes.

So that's five years of normal, non-diabetic, HbA1c results. Next milestone - March 2030.
 
So here we are in April 2026. This year's HbA1c is 37, same as last year. That is five years of bang normal results with a start point in April 2020.

I think this means I get coded differently by the NHS - will need to check that.

Other points - didn't get weighed, no statin conversation, no foot check. Still have the BP and meds check though.
 
I had a look around for some figures, any figures, about long-term success in bg control. The best I could find was words to the effect that "it can happen, but it's rare". No figures, no estimates. Maybe nobody has ever bothered to look.

There will be figures - this is what NHS England instructs practices to do:
  1. Add SNOMED code 703138006 (Type 2 diabetes mellitus in remission).
  2. Retain the original Type 2 Diabetes diagnosis.
  3. Continue annual review monitoring.
So it should be fairly easy simply to count the number of people with the 8006 code....shouldn't it?

However - it's further complicated by the new (and to my mind ridiculous) definition of "remission" as requiring only a BG below 48mmol/l - in other words, an abnormally high level of blood glucose is accepted as an indicator of not having high blood glucose. It's clearly no bad thing to reduce BG, even if it can't be brought back to normal levels, but calling having elevated blood glucose "in remission" is positively misleading.

I may be old-fashioned but I think to mean anything, remission should be defined as normal blood glucose, non-medicated, for a fixed (and much longer than three months) period.

This is the only relevant research I've found so far, from 2022. It uses the sub-48 definition of remission, and indicates that, of the 2.8 million people coded with T2 diabetes in the 2018/9 NDA, 0.58% were coded as being in remission.


And it's now been over six years for me - we didn't have the five years plus conversation last year thanks to the practice's own machine returning that bizarre result, fortunately overturned by the lab test.
 
Last edited:
Here we are in November 2026 and the HbA1c is steady at 37mmol/l, which is where it was last year and earlier this. Although my weight is up a little again, my waist size stays constant and I think the increase can be put down to quite a bit of extra muscle, thanks to football and pilates, otherwise known as the Hour of Pain. I am 69 today, and physically I feel so much better than when I was 59. Or 49.

Coming up on the anniversary of both diagnosis and low carb/keto next month. It will be seven years (probably more like 20 since I actually became diabetic). There's not a lot to add to what's already posted above, but it does seem to get a lot easier as time goes on. I can be out of ketosis and back in on the same day, which certainly didn't happen a few years back - it used to take four or five days. It is possible that my first phase insulin response is working again, and the observed facts seem to fit. I have tried once or twice to push my BG up and it doesn't seem to want to go above 8.0. Things that used to elevate my BG still do, but to a much lesser extent. At the moment I am back testing blood a bit more than I have been doing, just for my own curiosity.

Of course, T2s aren't supposed to have a first phase insulin response at all, that's what makes us T2s, according to the textbook. I am not about to go down the "now I can eat everything again" road because eating as I used to eat made me diabetic, and that led to really painful symptoms. No thank you.
 
Happy birthday old friend!

Congratulations on what you did with your diabetes for so long, and by all means blame English being my second language for the ambiguity in my birthday wish! :cool:
 
1957 was a very good year! ;)

Please, in simple terms, what is " first phase insulin response?
 
1957 was a very good year! ;)

Please, in simple terms, what is " first phase insulin response?
Info and illustrative graph from Bilous and Donnelly, Handbook of Diabetes.

The body responds to carbs in two linked but separate responses. The first phase is a fast and large insulin release from cells near the surface of the pancreas, which is a way of hitting the incoming rising glucose levels very quickly. You'd almost think that glucose was a poison, the way the system responds to reduce its level as fast as possible.

The second phase is a slower insulin response (to continuing higher blood glucose levels) that comes from cells deeper in the pancreas and which takes longer and stays around longer, leading to both higher insulin levels for longer, and obviously means that the higher blood glucose levels will have persisted. I'd guess, although B&D aren't explicit, that it also makes the pancreas work harder.

Fig.5.11.jpg

The received medical wisdom is that T2s have lost the first level response for good because our blood glucose levels are always high, such that the pancreas surface cells never get a chance to refill. T2s are therefore assumed to be only dealing with glucose intake via the lower and slower second phase response, which doesn't really do it for us given insulin resistance etc.

To my mind it follows directly that if you can reduce overall levels of blood glucose, you stand at least a chance of getting that first level response working again.

That seems to make sense for me at present, but obviously this is just speculation on my part as I have no way of really knowing. However, it fits the observations - particularly that carby things that would have hit me hardest back in 2020 in terms of blood glucose rises are no longer hitting anywhere nearly as hard. So I don't see BG in double figures and it really doesn't seem to go above 8mmol/l. This is management, not a cure or anything like it - and I continue to be wary of breaking my system again exactly the same way it broke twenty years ago.

Is that clear? If not, LMK.
 
Back
Top