BrianTheElder
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 574
- Location
- Surrey, UK
- Type of diabetes
- Type 2
- Treatment type
- Diet only
- Dislikes
- Snide people
you absolutely can lose weight eating carbs if your calorie restriction is low enough.
you could live off 4 sugar lumps a day and lose weight.
I meant the general 'you'I could not as I would to keep to it for long........
As I understand it, T1's have to count carbs to adjust their insulin injections for meals. If they're eating a large number of carbs, and they get their calculation/dose wrong, there's a bigger margin for error than if they were eating fewer and requiring much less insulin. Even small errors can have larger consequences if carb consumption is higher, so lower carbs would mean both less insulin and safer/more accurate doses. (Richard Bernstein's "Law of small numbers":I do have to ask, what is wrong with non-type 2 diabetics eating carbs? isnt the idea of pushing low carbing to those not type 2 diabetic similar to those who are lactose intolerant expecting those who are not to stop drinking milk?
thank you. I rarely comment about type 1's as i know so little about their lives. I have a friend with type 1 and a friend with a husband and two sons with type 1, but living the life is different from looking on, isnt it. But I am awed by how careful and vigilant you have to be, and the consequences of error or even general life. I can understand how reducing the margins of error can help.As I understand it, T1's have to count carbs to adjust their insulin injections for meals. If they're eating a large number of carbs, and they get their calculation/dose wrong, there's a bigger margin for error than if they were eating fewer and requiring much less insulin. Even small errors can have larger consequences if carb consumption is higher, so lower carbs would mean both less insulin and safer/more accurate doses. (Richard Bernstein's "Law of small numbers":
https://www.diabetesselfmanagement.com/diabetes-resources/definitions/dr-bernsteins-diabetes-solution/ )
@Mel dCP
Robbity
Hi Brian, thanks for posting this article, it is definitely interesting.For those of you not able to view the whole article, my real concern is this snippet.
"The art, he stressed, was finding a diet that people felt able to follow and maintain. “To lose weight you have to have less calories one way or another,” Professor Lean said. “You can do that by putting someone in a cage or prison and giving them the right number of calories."
He is obviously of the CICO persuasion.
I think that approach has been thoroughly disproved.
Ya can go right off some people, ya knowI am a carboholic, eat around 250 - 300 grams of carbs a day. I have been 11stone since I was 21 years old (31 years now). Have never tried to loose weight. I guess I am very lucky and have a high metabolism
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?