diagnosis of eating disorder because I'm type 1 and follow low carb diet?

Dillinger

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,207
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Dislikes
Celery.
I think you need to formally complain about this; it is absolutely disgraceful behaviour. Your treatment is at the advice of your doctors not at their insistence; they can't force you to do anything and if they think they can they need to be on the wrong end of a court order.

Please make as big a fuss as you can possibly manage; certainly a formal complaint, but also get in touch with your GP, get citizens advice help and don't let them get away with this.

This makes me furious to hear!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema and michita

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
@Dillinger

Thank you for the comment and being on my side :) This happened a year ago and I'm now at different hospital. Even if I complained I don't think I have a case. Nhs thinks low carbing is unsafe for T1D but thank you for saying it. It means a lot to me.

I can appreciate they were concerned about my health but i was diagnosed with T1D only 2 months ago trying to cope. It was a bit heartless treatment and I'm angry I guess for what they've done

If you are diagnosed with mental illness including eating disorder, you lose you right as patient to refuse a treatment and make your own decisions about yourself. according to my internet research .... I don't have a family in this county to come and help me so it was especially difficult
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema

DCUKMod

Master
Staff Member
Messages
14,298
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
@Dillinger

Thank you for the comment and being on my side :) This happened a year ago and I'm now at different hospital. Even if I complained I don't think I have a case. Nhs thinks low carbing is unsafe for T1D but thank you for saying it. It means a lot to me.

I can appreciate they were concerned about my health but i was diagnosed with T1D only 2 months ago trying to cope. It was a bit heartless treatment and I'm angry I guess for what they've done

If you are diagnosed with mental illness including eating disorder, you lose you right as patient to refuse a treatment and make your own decisions about yourself. according to my internet research .... I don't have a family in this county to come and help me so it was especially difficult

In the UK, I don't believe you lose any rights, unless you are sectioned under the Mental Health Act. Patients who are not sectioned, retain their rights to consent, or refuse treatment and so on.

Quite some years ago, I was unwell enough, as a result of an eating disorder to require hospitalisation for several weeks. I was not sectioned at any time, and my treatment planning was shared with me at all stages and I was regularly asked to confirm my consent as things changed.

Eating disorders are classified as being a mental disorder under the Mental Health Act, but diagnosis doesn't automatically signal a sectioning.

The NHS summary guide to Sectioning under the Mental Health Act is here: http://www.nhs.uk/NHSEngland/AboutN...nder _The _Mental _Health _Act _Factsheet.pdf
 

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Hi @asortafairytale

Thank u for the comments and your kind words. :)

I'm still on low carb diet because it works very well for me. I don't have craving for carbs and I have always been a large eater, I would find it more difficult to eat small portion of carbs than not eat at all.

I suffered from nasty hypos a lot pre-diagnosis (when I'm not on insulin) - maybe reactive hypoglycaemia from being on high carb diet ? Now on insulin and on Low carb diet I suffer from no hypos (maybe a few times below 4 above 3.5 a month). I just don't want to take more insulin to eat carb to worry about hypos. At moment I take 2 units of Novorapid for each meal. No carb counting, no hypo, no hyper, very easy.

This might change in the future and management becomes harder then I might reconsider my approach but for the time being its working very well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HLC2017 and Freema

DCUKMod

Master
Staff Member
Messages
14,298
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Hi @asortafairytale

Thank u for the comments and your kind words. :)

I'm still on low carb diet because it works very well for me. I don't have craving for carbs and I have always been a large eater, I would find it more difficult to eat small portion of carbs than not eat at all.

I suffered from nasty hypos a lot pre-diagnosis (when I'm not on insulin) - maybe reactive hypoglycaemia from being on high carb diet ? Now on insulin and on Low carb diet I suffer from no hypos (maybe a few times below 4 above 3.5 a month). I just don't want to take more insulin to eat carb to worry about hypos. At moment I take 2 units of Novorapid for each meal. No carb counting, no hypo, no hyper, very easy.

This might change in the future and management becomes harder then I might reconsider my approach but for the time being its working very well.

Gosh, were your hypos just before diagnosis, or months or years before?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema

hh1

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,355
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
I've been on low carb diet since my diagnosis in May last year. The diet works well for me and it is my informed choice.

My consultants and DN however were not supportive of my low carb diet. They gave me a diagnosis of suspected eating disorder and I was hospitalised for 4 days. I had to eat hospital's carb/sugar loaded food because otherwise they would not discharge me. I only found out about eating disorder diagnosis at discharge, explained in discharge letter. It was a horrible experience.

Ok, I was slightly underweight then because I lost some weight due to diabetes and I'm also naturally thin type but I didn't and don't have an eating disorder. I wouldn't be on low carb diet if I wasn't diabetic. I loved eating carbs before.

This happened in July last year. I've since changed consultant /DN.

I'm aware that NHS do not recommend low carb diet, especially for type 1s, but do you think doctors can classify T1s following low carb diet as having an eating disorder? That scares me. Or am I safe as long as I keep my weight in normal range.

Michita this is one of the most horrifying stories I've ever heard. Many years ago I had to fight to take my own insulin into hospital and inject myself as usual; I thought that was a battle, but compared with this it was a breeze. I agree with Dillinger that it would be good if you complained (even though it's a while ago) as I'm all for trying to help others avoid going through bad experiences if possible. The trouble is it takes time and energy to keep pushing against health professionals who are not prepared to consider another way of seeing or doing things - even though we can produce evidence that what we're doing is working. In the past few years I've had the best DSN ever and she's revolutionised my approach and supported me in trying different approaches; if only they were all that good. I hope you have a health team you're happy with now and who are supportive of what you decide to do. Well done for finding someone else to treat you, and for just getting through a dreadful experience.
 

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
In the UK, I don't believe you lose any rights, unless you are sectioned under the Mental Health Act. Patients who are not sectioned, retain their rights to consent, or refuse treatment and so on.

Quite some years ago, I was unwell enough, as a result of an eating disorder to require hospitalisation for several weeks. I was not sectioned at any time, and my treatment planning was shared with me at all stages and I was regularly asked to confirm my consent as things changed.

Eating disorders are classified as being a mental disorder under the Mental Health Act, but diagnosis doesn't automatically signal a sectioning.

The NHS summary guide to Sectioning under the Mental Health Act is here: http://www.nhs.uk/NHSEngland/AboutN...nder _The _Mental _Health _Act _Factsheet.pdf

Hi @DCUKMod,

Thank you for the comment and info. I'm very glad that they treated you with care and respect. They should. and all my other experience with NHS they have treated me so well too.

But for this, I was honestly worried and unsure about what they can't do and they can do to me after the discharge, so I couldn't go back to them. I was afraid and worried they could even section me if they wanted, if I insisted on low carbing and I'm little underweight and they disapprove. I didn't feel I was treated with care and respect and I think it's all down to trust issue but I really thought I might go crazy during my stay at the hospital.
 

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Gosh, were your hypos just before diagnosis, or months or years before?

Many years before diagnosis. I mentioned it to GP but they didn't take much notice and seemed to think it's quite common.... my symptoms were quite bad then. Low carbing cured it. I was on high carb diet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
@hh1

Thank u for the response. you are the 3rd person who said I should complain in this post, so yes I might consider.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema

DCUKMod

Master
Staff Member
Messages
14,298
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
Many years before diagnosis. I mentioned it to GP but they didn't take much notice and seemed to think it's quite common.... my symptoms were quite bad then. Low carbing cured it. I was on high carb diet.

Did you stop having the hypos leading up to your diagnosis?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
I think it only stopped completely after diagnosis and when I started low carb diet. Why do u ask ? To be honest, it is strange I had so long pre-diagnosis hypos and get type 1 but it's possible type 1 was very slow onset and giving me the hypos ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freema

DCUKMod

Master
Staff Member
Messages
14,298
Type of diabetes
I reversed my Type 2
Treatment type
Diet only
I think it only stopped completely after diagnosis and when I started low carb diet. Why do u ask ? To be honest, it is strange I had so long pre-diagnosis hypos and get type 1 but it's possible type 1 was very slow onset and giving me the hypos ...

Yes, as you say, hypos are unusual around the time of a T1 diabetic diagnosis, but I'm not a health care professional.
 

Odin004

Well-Known Member
Messages
165
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Hi @michita

Firstly, I agree with @Dillinger - the way you've been treated has been appalling - whether or not hospitalising you was the right thing to do, this should have been handled very differently; I also agree with all of @asortafairytale's comments.

It's a tricky situation, because it is true that there are a whole host of reasons why people may choose to avoid or limit carbohydrate; and it's probably the case that doctors see more cases ( in type 1 diabetes) in which a low carb lifestyle is the result of some underlying psychological condition, than cases in which it's just an educated and informed choice.

The additional difficulty is that, where psychological conditions are concerned, quite often the patient truly believes they're acting logically, rather than out of fear or anxiety; this means that doctors have to be careful about rooting out the truth of the matter in each case, on an individual basis; but I also suspect it means that the truth is overlooked in quite a few cases where people choose freely to be low carb (as I suppose it's safer to assume the patient has a problem).

I suffered a high degree of hypo-anxiety (which is still with me to some degree), following a bad hypo last year - I posted about it here:

https://www.diabetes.co.uk/forum/threads/new-to-this-my-first-post.121586/

I now choose a low carb diet - a low carb diet is a perfectly valid lifestyle choice, and doesn't automatically mean you have an eating disorder; and it can be an excellent way, if used properly, for an insulin dependent diabetic to manage sugar levels within a tighter range, and to limit the risk of hypos; not wanting to have a high dose of insulin in your system is also quite a valid reason to limit carb intake.

You might find these links of interest, in relation to the difference between low and high carb diets:

https://diatribe.org/low-carb-vs-high-carb-my-surprising-24-day-diabetes-diet-battle
https://diatribe.org/low-carb-vs-high-carb-ii-my-diabetes-diet-battle-continued

As @asortafairytale says, perhaps don't go too low though - I posted about my own experience of going a little too low carb here:

https://www.diabetes.co.uk/forum/threads/low-carb-but-high-sugars-advice-please.123659/

It seems to me possible that your doctors misunderstood your circumstances - it sounds like you've been treated very much as though you were someone who has stopped taking their insulin, and has lost weight as a result; which clearly doesn't apply to you. In fact, it sounds as though your reasons for choosing a low carb diet were well thought through, and based on very valid concerns. Now you're on insulin, it may be worth reflecting on why you're still low carb - this is not an easy time for you, and you're still a very new T1; so I'd encourage lots of discussion with others about it; and this forum is an ideal opportunity for that! Finally, may I wish you health and happiness in whatever you do :)
 
Last edited:

azure

Expert
Messages
9,780
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Pump
Many years before diagnosis. I mentioned it to GP but they didn't take much notice and seemed to think it's quite common.... my symptoms were quite bad then. Low carbing cured it. I was on high carb diet.

I had this prior to diagnosis. My consultant explained that it was the start of a failing pancreas and that my pancreas was producing insulin too late and then in too great a quantity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HLC2017 and michita

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
Hi @Odin004

Thank you for the response.

Your comments on psychological condition is an interesting one :)

I share your view and feel low carb diet is a perfectly sensible and logical choice for diabetics even for type 1s but I will read again what you wrote and will give my thoughts.

Reading your unexplainable hypo experience makes me scared ... I think it's logical and natural to want to reduce carbs and insulin to reduce the risk of hypo ... or is this considered possibly as a illogical irrational thinking .....

Re insulin resistance, I've read about it before and I might have it. I understand it is a physiological condition and not harmful. In my case I feel the insulin resistance is helping to even out BS level in case of small overdosing. I also don't have any delayed BS rise from protein which others mention.

I think low carb diet is working well for me maybe because I am late onset 1.5 type, and someday it might change but I hope it'll last because it is very easy to manage now

Thank you again for the very informative and encouraging comments.
 

dbr10

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,237
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
I've been on low carb diet since my diagnosis in May last year. The diet works well for me and it is my informed choice.

My consultants and DN however were not supportive of my low carb diet. They gave me a diagnosis of suspected eating disorder and I was hospitalised for 4 days. I had to eat hospital's carb/sugar loaded food because otherwise they would not discharge me. I only found out about eating disorder diagnosis at discharge, explained in discharge letter. It was a horrible experience.

Ok, I was slightly underweight then because I lost some weight due to diabetes and I'm also naturally thin type but I didn't and don't have an eating disorder. I wouldn't be on low carb diet if I wasn't diabetic. I loved eating carbs before.

This happened in July last year. I've since changed consultant /DN.

I'm aware that NHS do not recommend low carb diet, especially for type 1s, but do you think doctors can classify T1s following low carb diet as having an eating disorder? That scares me. Or am I safe as long as I keep my weight in normal range.
That is absolutely disgraceful. Up to you how you try to manage your diabetes. Inflicting this nonsense on you amounts to abuse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: michita

jacqfromdwed

DWED Support
Messages
24
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Pump
@michita also just for everyone else's reference. A diabetes specialist CAN NOT diagnose you with an clinically defined eating disorder without specialist input, they can recommend that you see a psychologist/ psychiatrist who CAN diagnose you but in the same way a clinical psyc would be completely out of their depth talking about lipid profiles or protein in the urine so goes for diabetes specialists and mental health conditions.

If you are based in the UK and would like to complain DWED can help you with that. Its a precarious situation, on the one hand we desperately want diabetes specialists to be aware of Eating Disorders we simultaneously are horrified with this sort of behaviour. Definitely we could reach out to your old unit and let them know they've been recmmended for training.

I had a much less stressful but similar situation with a D consultant not too long ago where she completely berrated me for using low carb because I had a history of EDs, I explained to her yes I did and that ed involved me binging on high carb food so who was she to tell me what was safe for my mental health. Also I heard from a friend who was at a conference recently that some of the dsn's there would report parents of CWD to social services if they utilised a Low carb approach to diabetes management.

More awareness all round I think. Sorry this happened to you it sounds horrendous
 

MikeTurin

Well-Known Member
Messages
564
Type of diabetes
Type 2
Treatment type
Tablets (oral)
I agree that this is disgraceful. What I find most appealing is that the food that is served to patients in hospitals it's not exactly haute cuisine or, in some cases, http://www.ansa.it/english/news/201...s-2_c020d383-a064-449c-9f8e-d61f24fd369a.html with te assistance of beetles.
Anyway the bread or the stickbreads and the fruit they serve are pretty awful to eat, not to mention the overcooked pasta.
If refusing to eat ****** food is equal to eating disorder I think there is some bad reasoning here.
 

michita

Well-Known Member
Messages
479
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Insulin
@jacqfromdwed

Thank you for the comment. Yes that's why reason for my hospitalisation was "suspected" eating disorder.

@asortafairytale says indicator for eating disorder is not weight but whether the person is manipulating insulin or not. Then can people who choose to be on low carb /low insulin to manage good BS level be considered as manipulating insulin level. I think yes or no... ?

In my mind I'm very sure I don't have an eating disorder. I have diabetes and I'm just trying to manage diabetes the best I can in an easiest possible way for me. I don't care much about my body image (too old...). I like eating and enjoy eating, but I eat no obvious carbs (bead pasta rice potatoes etc). I eat lots of vegetables, fish meat eggs etc. I exercise daily to keep fit. I will make sure to keep my weight within normal.

I think the underlying issue for me is NHS's view that low carb diet is unsafe to type 1s, which I don't agree. I had to agree to eat carbs to get discharged. I don't know what the psychiatrist's recommendation would have been if I had told him I would like to manage my diabetes with low carb diet. My trust was completely gone by then and I was desperate to go home.

I personally think low carb diet is just a diet and should be treated same way as vegetarian diet. A diet of personal choice based on personal view/circumstances. No one would force vegetarians to eat meat. My thinking on nutrition is that as long as we take necessary amount of calories it doesn't matter so much which energy source it comes from.

I am based in uk. I'm quite certain they followed their rules. I remember DN saying documenting our conversation and typing up. I just so wish they accept low carb as one of the ways to manage type1s.
 
Last edited:

donnellysdogs

Master
Messages
13,233
Type of diabetes
Type 1
Treatment type
Pump
Dislikes
People that can't listen to other people's opinions.
People that can't say sorry.
@jacqfromdwed

Thank you for the comment. Yes that's why reason for my hospitalisation was "suspected" eating disorder.

@asortafairytale says indicator for eating disorder is not weight but whether the person is manipulating insulin or not. Then can people who choose to be on low carb /low insulin to manage good BS level be considered as manipulating insulin level. I think yes or no... ?

In my mind I'm very sure I don't have an eating disorder. I have diabetes and I'm just trying to manage diabetes the best I can in an easiest possible way for me. I don't care much about my body image (too old...). I like eating and enjoy eating, but I eat no obvious carbs (bead pasta rice potatoes etc). I eat lots of vegetables, fish meat eggs etc. I exercise daily to keep fit. I will make sure to keep my weight within normal.

I think the underlying issue for me is NHS's view that low carb diet is unsafe to type 1s, which I don't agree. I had to agree to eat carbs to get discharged. I don't know what the psychiatrist's recommendation would have been if I had told him I would like to manage my diabetes with low carb diet. My trust was completely gone by then and I was desperate to go home.

I personally think low carb diet is just a diet and should be treated same way as vegetarian diet. No one would force vegetarians to eat meat. My thinking on nutrition is that as long as we take necessary amount of calories it doesn't matter so much which energy source it comes from.

I am based in uk. I'm quite certain they followed their rules. I remember DN saying documenting our conversation and typing up. I just so wish they accept low carb as one of the ways to manage type1s.

Some hospitals/consultants do listen and believe in lower carbs etc but shamefully less diabetic ones!! I'm froends with a great cardiologist and been to a talk recently with a profssor in Oncology and they really do believe in low carb. One cardioligist actually got his pioppi diet mentioned in parliament with 100 MPs this week so there is hope that perhaps more consultants may adjust their thinking.

I think for me,its because my consultants realise I analyse all my nutrion intake for vitamins and minerals and what food will actually go thru my body without the need for A&E!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: michita