SJC
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 683
- Type of diabetes
- Prediabetes
- Treatment type
- Diet only
- Dislikes
- Diets!
I am agreeing with you Kyrani.Where's the contradiction?
I was saying that ideas point to issues, those ideas may (if they are taken as true), cause the person to react and that reaction is somatic. I gave the simple case of anxiety because it is a simple example of conflicting emotions causing problems, especially for the heart. But I wanted to stress that it is not always a simple matter. Emotional reactivity is only one sort.
For example if the person perceives danger and it is not evident that the danger is external AND at the same time there are ideas of some internal problem, the person's immune system might be stimulated to react unnecessarily and do damage to cells.
In the case you bring here about the medical problem of this patient, there would have been ideas that she may have treated as treal BUT there could have been some other conflict due to her bodies reaction to a number of ideas. It is hard to say anything much if one doesn't know the person's problems.
What I was trying to do in that post was to point out that
1. I am NOT a New Ager, and
2. That I see problems with the simplistic views that New Age ideas convey.
Doctors talk about stress and stress hormones but they don't
go on and explain the reactivity in the body in any detail at all. They only talk about diet and exercise, which are important but stress IMO is even more important.
Kyrani
,
I can personally tell you that without a shadow of a doubt, it has been stress/anxiety in my past that has caused physical issues for me too. I had been through sheer hell emotionally for five years when I was diagnosed with cancer. It didn't even surprise me at the time because I knew how much out of sync I had felt for those years.
I can even draw on my present 'mystery illness' that as yet is undiagnosed. I lost my best friend of thirty years, my dad, and my beloved 11 year old dog, all in the space of a year. I was told I had a measure of depression, and then I started to feel really ill physically (still do). I don't have panic attacks, but I KNOW that anxiety and depression are closely linked. Top that up with being worried about nobody actually knowing what is wrong with me and of course I am keeping my symptoms ticking over nicely. I am aware of it and trying to address it.
I am query ME because I have had bouts like this before, but perhaps my emotions may be playing a huge part. My eyes are well open to it all. I wouldn't mind if doctors finally diagnosed me as having a stress born illness that is cyclic, because it would be an answer and I can work with that.