WWe have endless debates and arguments about what constitutes a healthy diet. It seems one man's carb is another man's poision.
One common concern, however, is that newly diagnosed visitors will get mixed messages from the conflicting opinions. I have therefore decided that it's time for a wee census. I know of many members who have gained control of their condition by adopting a low(er) carb diet, but then found no further use for the forum, taken their normal blood sugars and disappeared. I would like us to gather statements from diabetics who have found success by restricting their carbohydrate intake, by whatever amount.
So please let us know if you have succeeded in managing your diabetes by restricting your carbs.
If you can supply before and after figures for diet, blood sugar readings, HbA1c, weight, weight or lipids it will all help to build a picture of how real people are getting on.
Oh, and the arguments won't be tolerated here but can be continued elsewhere!
All the best,
fergus
My own story is too long and tedious to relate here, but I'll summarise it as well as I can. There is a version I wrote earlier in the February 2015 archive of Jason Fungs blog.We have endless debates and arguments about what constitutes a healthy diet. It seems one man's carb is another man's poision.
One common concern, however, is that newly diagnosed visitors will get mixed messages from the conflicting opinions. I have therefore decided that it's time for a wee census. I know of many members who have gained control of their condition by adopting a low(er) carb diet, but then found no further use for the forum, taken their normal blood sugars and disappeared. I would like us to gather statements from diabetics who have found success by restricting their carbohydrate intake, by whatever amount.
So please let us know if you have succeeded in managing your diabetes by restricting your carbs.
If you can supply before and after figures for diet, blood sugar readings, HbA1c, weight, weight or lipids it will all help to build a picture of how real people are getting on.
Oh, and the arguments won't be tolerated here but can be continued elsewhere!
All the best,
fergus
Well done! You may not need to try the Newcastle diet, seeing how well you have done with carbohydrate restriction. It was Roy Taylor's work at Newcastle that first alerted me to the possibility of reversing type two diabetes, but I didn't like the idea of his very low calorie diet. I am very much a real food fan so I cautiously tried low carb and intermittent fasting which worked for me. I had already got down from 140 kg to 103 kg over the years on low-fat, calorie-restriction but never kept the weight off permanently. This time I aimed for a modest reduction to 90Kg which I reached quickly and kept going to my present 70Kg. I don't panic if it goes up or down by a couple of Kg. A long holiday, with temporary carb-laden treats can add up to 10Kg but I can lose that quickly when back home.I was diagnosed with a A1C of 95.
I messed about for a couple of weeks reading things on this site then researching - I am carefully cautions.
I thought I was doing low carb, with a bit of rice and some brown pasta - then I realised that was not the case.
So I hit the LCHF diet hard about 7 weeks ago. I can be ruthless and determined and some days just about got to 10, most days less than 20 and aside from a BBQ (unintentionally) where good knows what I ate I have not gone above 35 in a day. Now if my BGs peak over 7 after a meal I have a mild panic as to why. Typically I can remain under 6.5.
Last Monday, almost 9 weeks since my diagnosis, my HBA1C was 44.
I put that down to the help of people on this site - one or two in particular who have spent time responding to my long emails. I have lost a couple of stones and started walking, using my own gym which was gathering dust.
I still intend to try the Newcastle diet at some point soon - but I think better to think it through and know the best time in your calendar to fall apart in week 3.
Thanks for all of your help to date - a long way to go.
This one is from Saturday in Manchester at the PHC Conference with my hero Dr Jason FungView attachment 23180
NC = Newcastle? or No Carb? or someting else. Plz clarify for an Old Vart.You have done really well!
I am inclined to have a go on NC diet, mainly because I think as well as the outcome, the lesson of doing it will remind me never to eat a carb too many again.
Oops?
fat and protein..Where do you get your energy from if you don't eat carbs?
Where do you get your energy from if you don't eat carbs?[/QUOTE
fat
Well to date I have lost 4stone this year. Having a rest from strict low carb and reducing insulin. Xmas is here in our house. The build up has started.I am at last losing @bulkbiker .
I feel it is completing my overall efforts, at last!
For me unless I lost weight I couldnt call my low carb efforts a success.
I've lost 2st since xmas now and still losing
Stopped statin advised by cardiologist.
Bgs are giving a hba1c as 53 again so medics are very happy, me too.
I'm looking forward to a less IR 2018
Low carb, low fat is working for me.
I have a doubt,in lchf diet we take plenty of how does it effects lipid profile.I was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes three and a half years ago, at the beginning of 2014 at the age of 59 - blood sugar 19 mmol, HbA1c 104 (should be below 50). I also discovered over the next few months that I had damage to both my feet and my eyes – it seems that I must have had diabetes for about 5 years without realising it (no obvious symptoms). My weight was about 11.5 stone (as my avatar pic) – BMI around the 25 mark, so borderline overweight. Always been well-covered, but i'm tall and big-boned – the largest dress size i ever needed was a 16. Have been vegetarian for about 35 years (plus fish the last five years) and have always eaten a good basic diet, wholegrains, fresh fruit and vegetables, etc., etc. - but a fearsome sweet tooth, so a fair amount of chocolate and biscuits as well. I don't smoke and I drink less than once a month. My job is sedentary and I've always hated doing anything like running, but I usually swim at least twice a week, about half an hour doing front crawl, and have done for years. When I was diagnosed, my GP told me that I would need to resign myself to being on medication for the rest of my life, as there was nothing I could change about my lifestyle that would make any significant difference. So I started on Metformin.
I followed the conventional dietary advice given to diabetics in the UK, and my blood sugar levels gradually reduced, until after a year I was able to stop the Metformin; but that didn't last, and in April last year I found my HbA1c was back up, in the 60s. When it went up again, I asked the diabetic nurse if there was anything I could do - she said that there was nothing she could suggest, as I was following all the current advice. So back on the Metformin again.
By great good luck, someone mentioned a nutritionist living locally who specialises in treating diabetes , so I went to see him. He told me to forget the conventional advice, and suggested I cut out dried fruit completely, limit fresh fruit to one or two pieces a day, and include protein in every meal. However, the two biggies were to cut out carbs altogether and to leave at least 5 hours between meals, with no/miminal snacking in between. His reasoning for this was that your body needs time to reset after eating; he also recommended having generous portions of food at mealtimes. He also suggested increasing my exercise, but he was quite particular about what I should do. He said that, while swimming would be good for my general fitness, it was also important to build in exercise that involved less regular movements - so he suggested running on rough ground, using a hula hoop or dancing. He also said that it was important to do at least five minutes of fairly high-energy exercise first thing in the morning, to wake my system up. I decided to dance - I had lots of fun putting together music that I liked, and made myself a playlist from which I play three songs at a time, three times a day. I always dance soon after waking, and then fit in the other two sessions when I can. That gives me about half an hour of exercise daily, and fits into my normal routine very easily - and it's fun, and seldom feels like a chore. I started this regime in April last year (2016), also taking some over-the-counter supplements that he suggested – Glucobalance, cider vinegar and bitter gourd juice. Delighted to discover that coffee can help things along, as it's bitter – I've always loathed bitter food, but I've learned to enjoy black unsweetened coffee.
I also started monitoring my sugar levels (almost daily at first), first thing in the morning, and then again either a couple of hours after a meal or at a random time during the day. My aim was to average below 6 mmol, which I managed to achieve after a couple of months and I came off Metformin again last October. I had a diabetic review in April this year and my HbA1c was 36 - so technically, I no longer have diabetes. I also found I had lost a stone over the year, despite not monitoring my fat intake at all, and regularly eating full-fat diary products, nuts and peanut butter. Cholestrol, blood pressure, kidney function, etc., were all normal.
So I continue to follow this regime, although I do allow myself a little leeway now and then, but am very careful not to overdo it. I monitor my sugar levels every 4-5 days, still aiming to keep them averaging round about 6 mmols. I have the occasional blip when they go up, but not often, and it's not dramatic when they do - the highest reading I've had was 8 mmol after I ate far too much fruit at one sitting, but my post-meal readings are generally well below 7 mmols, and my early morning reading is nearly always somewhere between 4.2 and 5.5 mmol. My eyes and feet haven't got any worse since I was diagnosed, so everything seems stable at the moment - my next review is due in September, so I'm keeping my fingers crossed.
I was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes three and a half years ago, at the beginning of 2014 at the age of 59 - blood sugar 19 mmol, HbA1c 104 (should be below 50). I also discovered over the next few months that I had damage to both my feet and my eyes – it seems that I must have had diabetes for about 5 years without realising it (no obvious symptoms). My weight was about 11.5 stone (as my avatar pic) – BMI around the 25 mark, so borderline overweight. Always been well-covered, but i'm tall and big-boned – the largest dress size i ever needed was a 16. Have been vegetarian for about 35 years (plus fish the last five years) and have always eaten a good basic diet, wholegrains, fresh fruit and vegetables, etc., etc. - but a fearsome sweet tooth, so a fair amount of chocolate and biscuits as well. I don't smoke and I drink less than once a month. My job is sedentary and I've always hated doing anything like running, but I usually swim at least twice a week, about half an hour doing front crawl, and have done for years. When I was diagnosed, my GP told me that I would need to resign myself to being on medication for the rest of my life, as there was nothing I could change about my lifestyle that would make any significant difference. So I started on Metformin.
I followed the conventional dietary advice given to diabetics in the UK, and my blood sugar levels gradually reduced, until after a year I was able to stop the Metformin; but that didn't last, and in April last year I found my HbA1c was back up, in the 60s. When it went up again, I asked the diabetic nurse if there was anything I could do - she said that there was nothing she could suggest, as I was following all the current advice. So back on the Metformin again.
By great good luck, someone mentioned a nutritionist living locally who specialises in treating diabetes , so I went to see him. He told me to forget the conventional advice, and suggested I cut out dried fruit completely, limit fresh fruit to one or two pieces a day, and include protein in every meal. However, the two biggies were to cut out carbs altogether and to leave at least 5 hours between meals, with no/miminal snacking in between. His reasoning for this was that your body needs time to reset after eating; he also recommended having generous portions of food at mealtimes. He also suggested increasing my exercise, but he was quite particular about what I should do. He said that, while swimming would be good for my general fitness, it was also important to build in exercise that involved less regular movements - so he suggested running on rough ground, using a hula hoop or dancing. He also said that it was important to do at least five minutes of fairly high-energy exercise first thing in the morning, to wake my system up. I decided to dance - I had lots of fun putting together music that I liked, and made myself a playlist from which I play three songs at a time, three times a day. I always dance soon after waking, and then fit in the other two sessions when I can. That gives me about half an hour of exercise daily, and fits into my normal routine very easily - and it's fun, and seldom feels like a chore. I started this regime in April last year (2016), also taking some over-the-counter supplements that he suggested – Glucobalance, cider vinegar and bitter gourd juice. Delighted to discover that coffee can help things along, as it's bitter – I've always loathed bitter food, but I've learned to enjoy black unsweetened coffee.
I also started monitoring my sugar levels (almost daily at first), first thing in the morning, and then again either a couple of hours after a meal or at a random time during the day. My aim was to average below 6 mmol, which I managed to achieve after a couple of months and I came off Metformin again last October. I had a diabetic review in April this year and my HbA1c was 36 - so technically, I no longer have diabetes. I also found I had lost a stone over the year, despite not monitoring my fat intake at all, and regularly eating full-fat diary products, nuts and peanut butter. Cholestrol, blood pressure, kidney function, etc., were all normal.
So I continue to follow this regime, although I do allow myself a little leeway now and then, but am very careful not to overdo it. I monitor my sugar levels every 4-5 days, still aiming to keep them averaging round about 6 mmols. I have the occasional blip when they go up, but not often, and it's not dramatic when they do - the highest reading I've had was 8 mmol after I ate far too much fruit at one sitting, but my post-meal readings are generally well below 7 mmols, and my early morning reading is nearly always somewhere between 4.2 and 5.5 mmol. My eyes and feet haven't got any worse since I was diagnosed, so everything seems stable at the moment - my next review is due in September, so I'm keeping my fingers crossed.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?