@RFSMarch I feel for you not liking salad. The only way I am clinging to LC for now is by eating fish and avo salad about 6 days a week and forgetting what I'm doing on the seventh - still vlc. Peanut or any other nut butter would be on my food hell list.
Just goes to show how we are all different and suggesting how to eat LC from your own experience is fraught with issues. Hope you find your way through this.
SO have to agree, it is a minefield isn't it.
as for LCHF...
Better then choices given at my DX, basically
"takes these, eat this.. and may i suggest making the most of the few remaining good years."
yes, yes, of course i made that up..but it probably isn't far off the truth...
I'd of chosen LCHF day one, given the choice, IF i'd seen the success so many had, but you are right we do need better guidance of just what that COULD contain AND the possible down sides.
I find it remarkable.
I have read so many posts where the 'expected' outcome is so wide of the mark when many get their HBA1c down to more normal numbers, yet NO ONE at the surgeries seems interested in HOW they did it.
Mines not.
i tried to be honest early days and explain, and got that 'withering' stare from the DN
and in with docs in 10mins i decided not to waste a moment, as the 1st 5 mins is spent discovering who i am, and what I'm here for..(group practice, the magical mystery tour of patient care

)
and it's not like they don't know.
i got some well done test when i got down to normal HBA1c of 40mmol in 8 months
Nice and all that but no "Can you come in and explain how you did it, so we can help others, "
a live example on their doorsteps, must create some curiosity ?
Because IF other at my surgery were as successful, they would have found out HOW and made that one of the choices at DX, right ?
Can only see
there MUST be other successes, so they would know and offer LCHF
OR
there are None, and they should wonder WHY one or two are an Anomaly
So that 'Honest' approach doesn't work at mine, sadly
Maybe with the Covid /Obesity/Diabetes being a marker of some sorts, that will all change once we de-cocoon from our homes
and those responsible WILL become interested in just how the hell, so many are bucking the trend...
AND on Little or NO Medication...
Perhaps it'll take one or two ministers with friends who can make money out of that
before they spend time & money thinking outside the "welcome to Insulin" box they all tick after we leave surgery.
Cynical, Moi...
100%