By keeping a few fairly simple facts as the basis of our navigation.How the hell do you guys navigate through this minefield
Hi Alec, and welcome to the forums. One of the best things you can do (assuming you are diabetic) is to forget everything you think you know about "healthy eating". Since around 1970-80 we have been instructed that eggs, dairy, fat and meat are bad, carbs are good. At the same time the proportion of the population that is obese has more than doubled and T2 diabetes has become common.I had a blood test recently as part of my annual cardio check up. A couple of days later a request from the surgery to book a 30 minute appointment to discuss said results. Appointment booked for 4 weeks time. Such a long appointment time got me thinking. I am a 69 year old male, a smoker, a moderate drinker and I enjoy my food. Meat and 2 veg guy, don’t really do sweet stuff. Did a bit of Googling, and came to the conclusion that at meeting I will be advised that I am Type 2. Type 2 appears to be lifestyle choices. I would much rather change lifestyle then go on meds.
So I have decided to pre-empt meeting and sort myself out in the interim.
1, Reduce with a view to completely stopping smoking within the month.
2, Reduce with a view to completely stop drinking alcohol within the month.
3, The eat far more healthily.
Despite extensive reading of this forum and other sites the 3rd target has me totally confused. What I have gleaned from all my research is that there is ‘general’ concenus on the following:
1, Refined and naturally occurring sugar is bad
2, Take-away and processed foods are bad
3, Root veg is generally bad (potatoes etc)
4, Leaf veg (broccoli, cauliflower etc) is good
5, White meat (chicken and fish etc) is good
6, Certain nuts are good
So far so good. As an ex RAF engineer, the pilot would identify a problem, we would then identify the cause of the problem and resolve it. So I naturally assumed that a similar process would have been taken with Diabetes, but not so, despite the many years it has been known about and the extensive research that has been undertaken.
Many individuals and ‘esteemed professionals’ state a low carb. diet is the way to go, lose carbs and add proteins and fats, while others totally disagree. So I have looked at individual foods I would like to continue eating, half the internet says YES the other half say NO.
Butter = Yes and definitely not (it’s dairy)
Red meat = Yes and definitely not
Eggs = Yes and definitely not (one study stated that 1 egg max.a week was ok)
Milk (goat) Yes and definitely not
How the hell do you guys navigate through this minefield for possibly years. I naively thought, ok I will devise a weekly menu, but I gave up at the first breakfast, I planned poached egg on wholemeal bread with a tinned peeled tomato. Half the internet = great, other half = lethal. I gave up.
Not looking for sympathy, as I must be one of hundreds, if not thousands, who on diagnosis come to this forum and others, seeking answers only to find more questions than answers.
Can I wish you ALL the very best for your individual journeys.
Don't disagree with any of the other posters but think you may be rushing to conclusions. You may be told you are diabetic, prediabetic or something else altogether (vitamin deficiency, anaemia, who knows? I certainly don't.) Having said that, if you are diabetic or prediabetic, getting a meter and watching your carbs is an awesome way to attempt to treat without meds if what you have is T2 diabetes.Did a bit of Googling, and came to the conclusion that at meeting I will be advised that I am Type 2. Type 2 appears to be lifestyle choices. I would much rather change lifestyle then go on meds.
Yes to all those (not sure about goats milk I use double cream instead).Butter = Yes and definitely not (it’s dairy)
Red meat = Yes and definitely not
Eggs = Yes and definitely not (one study stated that 1 egg max.a week was ok)
Milk (goat) Yes and definitely not
Personaly I'd go for 2-3 poached eggs and drop the other stuff.. or drop breakfast altogether and extend your overnight fast a bit.I planned poached egg on wholemeal bread with a tinned peeled tomato.
Alec - this place is in no way like a football forum!Firstly can I thank everyone for their responses they are greatly appreciated. This forum is very unlike the football forums I frequent.
Rachox. Before I did my first post I had already read your valuable info on meters, and on the basis of it ordered one. Even if I am not type 2, its use will help me to avoid getting there. Many thanks. Just one query, in identifying reactions to different foods, is it best to check them individually or in combination of the whole meal.
MrsA2 As an ex-engineer my journey will be interesting. However, in engineering you deal with facts and certainties, yet with this thing one person's fact is another's fiction, hence my comment about it being a minefield.
KennyA From the very limited research I have done, to me, what you wrote was spot on. If I am type 2 I have already decided I want, initially at least, to go down the diet only, low carb route. Although I understand this may not sit well with NHS providers. Can I be a bit cheeky and ask you a couple of questions?
Firstly and closest to my heart, Have you tried Salute Lager or Marston's Resolution. If so your verdict. Just please don't tell me that they taste like American beers.
If I can, a similar diet to yours would do me fine. I only mentioned goat's milk because I read it was 'healthier' than cows, I also thought that cream was just 'thick' milk so I need to check this out. You mentioned that you only have 1 main meal and a light snack at lunch. For many years I have only had a main meal in the evening with little to no snacks in-between. My body and I are used to this, so I would like to continue if possible. However, from my research I have got the impression that eating needs to be spaced out over the day. What are your and others thoughts on this.
Right I am off now to munch some delicious raw Kale!!! Take care people.
Ah, I think you might have hit the "net carbs" thing. I usually calculate mushrooms at around 3% carbs, therefore 3g per 100g. In practice I usually treat mushrooms almost as a "free good" and use plenty.I cannot repeat it enough, but I am extremely grateful for all the kind comments and superb advice from you people. I am now settled in my plan of action until I go to the appointment. Low carb diet, no, or a lot less, for the time being, cigs, no alcohol, far more exercise. Becoming a dab hand at the metering and reading this forum (because I don't think it is JUST about Diabetes it is about and applicable to making good life style choices generally). I just have one last question before I leave you all in peace, but only for a few weeks. I am compiling a list of foods and their various values that I want to eat so I can plan menu's. Obviously these values are integral to making choices, I read packages labels, check supermarket information and general goggles. Sadly there seems to be a range of values dependent on where you look. Just an example: the carbs in a 100g of Button Mushrooms range from 0.5 to 3.6. Is there a definitive or a more generally accepted list that people refer to? Or is it another good old Diabetes DIY.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?