See also http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/255712.php
BMI was devised nearly 200 years ago. Time for a change?
BMI was devised nearly 200 years ago. Time for a change?
-
Guest, the forum is undergoing some upgrades and so the usual themes will be unavailable for a few days. In the meantime, you can use the forum like normal. We'd love to know what you think about the forum! Take the 2025 Survey »
BMI chart
- Thread starter SWUSA_
- Start Date
D
Deleted member 308541
Guest
This forum has a BMI Calculator, but it is in imperial measurements and of no use to metric users. I am to lazy to do mental arithmetic conversions anymore.
It would be nice if the powers that be took this into account that not only people from the UK but the rest of the world are members of this forum.
Or build a metric / imperial BMI Calculator into the app.
http://www.diabetes.co.uk/bmi.html
It would be nice if the powers that be took this into account that not only people from the UK but the rest of the world are members of this forum.
Or build a metric / imperial BMI Calculator into the app.
http://www.diabetes.co.uk/bmi.html
Indy51
Expert
Here's one that allows you to select "standard" or metric:
http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/educational/lose_wt/BMI/bmicalc.htm
Here's one that's meant to give a better calculation?
http://www.smartbmicalculator.com/
http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/educational/lose_wt/BMI/bmicalc.htm
Here's one that's meant to give a better calculation?
http://www.smartbmicalculator.com/
D
Deleted member 308541
Guest
I got their android app from them a month or so back, it is about the same as my GP's calculations
M
mist
Guest
My BMI is 21
Prem51
Expert
The analysis of my reading said I shouldn't lose any more weight.
Last edited:
that smartbmicalculator is great!
It takes me out of the red zone, and into the orange, and explains why.
Very interesting.
This comment was also interesting:
It takes me out of the red zone, and into the orange, and explains why.
Very interesting.
This comment was also interesting:
By the way, being fat without tobacco is better than being slim due to nicotine. The best advice for smokers is to postpone the weight loss and stop smoking first.
I had heard it before, but it is nice to hear again.
M
mist
Guest
People still smoke tobacco products? When I heard the cost of a pack of smokes last week I almost fainted. No wonder they keep them locked behind a shutter these days..
qe5rt
Well-Known Member
I'm borderline obese on BMI charts. But i only have a body fat percentage of 12,5% ... so i guess it's safe to say it's muscle. As i only carry a little fat around my lower belly.
I remember back when i was in school and had to do those horrible medical checkups i was pretty muscular and ripped back then. Literally veins popping out, visible abs and side abs, striations, ... Standing there in my briefs the lady looks at the BMI chart and warns me that i'm closing in on an obese BMI and should take extra care because of my diabetes. I'm usually pretty good with witty comebacks but just couldn't reply to such stupidity.
I remember back when i was in school and had to do those horrible medical checkups i was pretty muscular and ripped back then. Literally veins popping out, visible abs and side abs, striations, ... Standing there in my briefs the lady looks at the BMI chart and warns me that i'm closing in on an obese BMI and should take extra care because of my diabetes. I'm usually pretty good with witty comebacks but just couldn't reply to such stupidity.
M
mist
Guest
I always liked the phrase "As round as a Reuben's" 
Snapsy
Well-Known Member
Hadn't heard of Smart BMI before I read the recent posts above, but I just found it and put in all the info they asked for, so as to be given the comments.
Had put that I'm low-carbing. This is what it said in that section of the comments:
Your low-carb diet
If you are currently dieting: With this diet you can achieve a fast weight loss by tricking your body. In the long run this may be unhealthy, as your body will try hard to compensate for the carbohydrate shortage by storing more fat. This will most likely result in a yo-yo effect. If you want to stop dieting, do it step by step.
I'm not low-carbing as a 'diet' in the sense that I think they mean it, although I'm wondering what they mean about the yo-yo and compensatory fat storage....
Had put that I'm low-carbing. This is what it said in that section of the comments:
Your low-carb diet
If you are currently dieting: With this diet you can achieve a fast weight loss by tricking your body. In the long run this may be unhealthy, as your body will try hard to compensate for the carbohydrate shortage by storing more fat. This will most likely result in a yo-yo effect. If you want to stop dieting, do it step by step.
I'm not low-carbing as a 'diet' in the sense that I think they mean it, although I'm wondering what they mean about the yo-yo and compensatory fat storage....
SWUSA_
Well-Known Member
@Snapsy :"Yo-yo dieting or yo-yo effect, also known as weight cycling, is a term coined by Kelly D. Brownell at Yale University, in reference to the cyclical loss and gain of weight, resembling the up-down motion of a yo-yo. ... The dieter then seeks to lose the regained weight, and the cycle begins again."
Indy51
Expert
If you've seen pictures of Dr Brownell, unfortunately it would seem he is describing himself
SWUSA_
Well-Known Member
You may have missed the heading of this thread which asked that we do not use aesthetics but rather science and/or experience to discuss this topic. Thank you for your post.If you've seen pictures of Dr Brownell, unfortunately it would seem he is describing himself
Kelly D. Brownell, PhD
Forums are free flow things. I'm afraid we don't get to dictate the content of people's responses.
This is a much more recent pic of Brownell. I wonder if he eats the way he tells us to?
(edited about 50x cos apparently, I can't type
)Attachments
Last edited:
Indy51
Expert
Thanks @Brunneria, you beat me to it. I don't recall seeing anything in the rules and regs that says people who start a thread get to 'moderate' the content. I thought that was, you know, a job for the forum moderators
Since I've already captured a far more recent picture of Dr Brownell than the one posted by the OP above, I think I'll go ahead and post it.
All the opening post in this thread, titled "BMI chart" says is that you're posting the chart. Nothing about "aesthetics".
Since I've already captured a far more recent picture of Dr Brownell than the one posted by the OP above, I think I'll go ahead and post it.
All the opening post in this thread, titled "BMI chart" says is that you're posting the chart. Nothing about "aesthetics".
I always liked the phrase "As round as a Reuben's"
Me too.
Although some of 'em look a bit scrawny, to me.
Bluetit1802
Legend
I used the Smart BMI calculator and checked the box for low carb diet.
My BMI came out at 21.6 with the following advice:
Nutrition
Think over your diet. Eat a variety of foods that you like, optimally including five servings of fruit and vegetables a day. Avoid eating too sweet, too fat and too much.
Your current low-carb diet
Your weight is below average: Do you really need this diet?
My BMI came out at 21.6 with the following advice:
Nutrition
Think over your diet. Eat a variety of foods that you like, optimally including five servings of fruit and vegetables a day. Avoid eating too sweet, too fat and too much.
Your current low-carb diet
Your weight is below average: Do you really need this diet?
Indy51
Expert
I had something similar - unfortunately you don't get to say WHY you're on the diet - they seem to assume weight loss is everybody's goal.
