Fully agree there @Pipp
While I can see there are other avenues, should the advice allways default to the EATWELL plate in so many instances.
I'd of been happy to try another after my first 6 weeks of EATWELL was an abject failure
And for me, that's the crux of all this.
How can one surgery, be turning out stunning results for type 2, yet all I got offered was a proven to fall, archaic diet of EATWELL.
Praise to all who succeed in lowering, reducing, getting to remission, whatever... this insidious disease.
But should THAT really be in the hands of individuals to find for themselves ?
Thank God we don't DON'T use that method with every other disease.
My thoughts are that I’d continued to eat healthy as suggested by the nurse, cutting out sugar and cakes, but was eating a huge amount of carbs, cereal for breakfast, main meal with potatoes or pasta and rice and a couple of slices of bread, supper was a few slices of toast or bread rolls, no one told me that was bad, it is almost the commonly accepted diet.
I think I was too far gone for LCHF to work on its own, I started it for about 4 weeks, my numbers dropped from the teens & 20s to 6-7 but I was still spiking 11-12. And still required my 50+ units of insulin a day. Further research I came across the direct study, and total food replacement 800 calorie shakes, as soon as I started this I came off insulin and have been for a month. My target range is 4.5 to 7.5 on the libre and most days I’m in that 100% of the time.
This is a very difficult diet, I find myself slipping up often (though I try to keep slip ups to egg and bacon), and not sustainable long term, and when I finish my 8 weeks of shakes I will be returning to LCHF. I hope the VLCD is the kick start my body needs to start working for itself. If I’d been given the information of LCHF when I’d been diagnosed I think that would have been enough for me to achieve remission, but I’d slipped too far down the progressive condition that is diabetes.
While the VLCD does work for some, I think if my diabetic nurse had pushed for me to go on it I would have pushed back. Felt miserable and not continued with it. Nothing but shakes for 8-12 weeks is not fun, and I put myself on this diet I have a lot invested into getting better, if someone wasn’t 100% committed this diet isn’t for them.
On the other hand if the nurse handed me out something about carbs being the enemy in the beginning I might have made them adjustments from the off and never ended up on insulin, yes going very low carb is a substantial change, but cutting out the highest carb culprits more often than not, can be quite easily achieved at the start. This will reflect in the hab1c and then people can work towards lowering carbs further if needed.
But diabetes is different than most conditions, if you break a leg, or have an infection or cancer you go to the doctor they give you treatment and the condition goes away or is managed. Too many people use this mindset with diabetes, take medication and then the condition is managed. Diabetes and especially type 2 is a diagnosis that requires the patient to take action themselves, and in taking action and finding the way of life that works for them it won’t be a deteriorating life sentence.
YES!!! And I will honestly admit I’ve done the research, and put theories into practice before telling my diabetic nurse what I’ve done because I fear she would have persuaded me away from what I was thinking. Doing it my way (buying libre sensors, going LCHF, starting the VLCD, and stopping insulin) has been very hard for her to argue with me as the evidence is sitting there in front of her. (Thanks Libre) I have kept her in the loop, albeit a week or so behind.Isnt it so sad that we are having to.find our own paths like this. We haven't spent years in medical training yet are finding better solutions for our individual journeys than those who have.
YES!!! And I will honestly admit I’ve done the research, and put theories into practice before telling my diabetic nurse what I’ve done because I fear she would have persuaded me away from what I was thinking. Doing it my way (buying libre sensors, going LCHF, starting the VLCD, and stopping insulin) has been very hard for her to argue with me as the evidence is sitting there in front of her. (Thanks Libre) I have kept her in the loop, albeit a week or so behind.
I think Libre should be prescribed to everyone who is serious about reducing their hab1c. Even if only 6 sensors at first then 1 every 6 months. But as they are hit and miss prescribing metres and strips that will probably never happen.It was £48! But a great investment. I
I'm really enjoying seeing the graphs. And very surprised at how low I go during the night! Do you find the same thing?
It's such a fabulous tool. I just love it. No chance of getting funding for them as you day, cant even get bg monitors. I'm going to get another ordered tomorrow. Might give it a couple of days before activating. See if that makes a difference.I think Libre should be prescribed to everyone who is serious about reducing their hab1c. Even if only 6 sensors at first then 1 every 6 months. But as they are hit and miss prescribing metres and strips that will probably never happen.
I found that while on insulin I could drop in to the red at night, and with a fresh sensor it happened, but I didn’t feel rough upon waking so I think it could have been inaccurate sensor because of laying on the sensor. I tend to put my sensor on the arm 1-2 days before activating it and find it’s not as bad at showing lows now. But maybe I’m not going low at night anymore because of the changes I’ve made. I like seeing the last 24 hour graph, but I tend to focus on the daily patterns graph.
I think I will keep funding Libre continuously maybe until the new year, then allow myself one 3 times a year to keep check or something. I like having it all the time, but not sure it’s worth £50 it if it’s not telling me much.
I thought the This Morning programme was great. It might not have ticked all the boxes completely but it was a very good step in the right direction.
Update re my appearance on This Morning last week. Its caused quite a stir! A few ruffled feathers. So much so Zoe made a statement in her Twitter
https://twitter.com/DrZoeWilliams/status/1171388091443159043?s=19
https://twitter.com/DrZoeWilliams/status/1171394151503601665?s=19
I hope it was the wind and that she wasnt upset. I really do.
Passions are running high in the diabetic and medical community.
The interview has certainly raised awareness!
I've replied to all comments on any links to it I can find and pointed the people to this forum for help, support and info. I've PMd those who requested more info. It's had @100k hits on the this Morning Facebook page plus over 100 shares. Over 10k hits on the YouTube link. 1,300 hits on Ash trees house surgery thanks to @Listlad. Many on my own surgery fb page @Adelaide st surgery. And many views on my own fb page plus shares. Every little helps.
PR really is working.
Next goal is getting lots of us on that sofa. To show people this isnt just a one off here and there.
I don't see any success stories coming out whereby remission has been reached with low cal (anyone else?).This is what Dr Zoe kept reinforcing in my interview. She spoke of DiRECT results. When I popped on the internet to research it says remission can be achieved for over 2 years. So basically hba1c creeping back up until in diabetic range again. I would prefer my remission to be permanent and that's why I've changed my woe for life to #lchf. It might not be for everyone but it really suits me and so many more across the world.
Hoping that soon they start listening. They change the eatwell plate advice, they change the dietary guidelines for t2d. They offer us a choice which includes info on #lchf and dont immediately offer meds including statins. And they offer pre diabetic and diabetic pts blood glucose monitors and dont say you dont need to use them as they can make you obsessive! In.my opinion they are essential.
Keeping up the fight until this happens.
I thought the This Morning programme was great. It might not have ticked all the boxes completely but it was a very good step in the right direction.
( Did anyone else notice the faux pas by Phil Schofield on the high blood in the bloodstream?)
Anyhow I managed to get both of my local surgeries to enter the This Morning video clip on their respective Facebooks and also the first day’s Sun link.
This work you are doing Deb, our surgeries have one eye on you just now as a great target to aim for in our own back yard. I have another PPG meeting on Tuesday evening and the work you are doing will be in its content.
I thought it might be hard to get this material onto the surgery Facebook pages but not so. It helps that you are local but it is possible for any one of us to get stuff like that onto our respective practice’s Facebook pages.
Well I will be certainly be giving you a big mention at tomorrow’s PPG meeting.It was such a massive positive, getting lchf out onto mainstream TV, not only that but onto this morning with holly and Phil who are most peoples favourite presenters. I got over where to find more info (wasnt allowed to say DCUK or bring on my monitor) got in how it helps with BP and BS also cholesteol not an issue as holly confd its healthy fats got in that carbs turn to sugar which will be news to so many as it was to.me! And that fats help to satiate. I wish I had mentioned that it can help reduce meds, even come off including insulin. But overall it gave hope to so many. And the video is clocking up 1000s of views on YouTube . Sadly they took the video down from this morning Twitter page probably due to some negative tweets. Passions are running high. But we dont want our media coverage to end up being deleted. Every little out there helps people find a way that might suit them as it has so many of us. Its not for everyone as dr zoe said. But it is a long term option. As oppose to low cal. Or 800 cal shakes for 12 weeks. And good for slim diabetics too.
I'm delighted it's gone into surgery fb pages. I've been so busy of late but my plan is to contact local surgeries in the hope of meeting up to take the lchf message to them direct. With my box of goodies!
I have a surgery now where I hold 1) clinics for diabetic help 2) low carb for weight loss - only new but hoping they will become popular and help many.
I am giving a talk to around 100 PPG and CCG members on Wednesday. 10.minutes on the work I'm doing in the community with the ppg. It will include my journey and I will take this opportunity to offer my services.i will keep everyone posted.
We are in this together. I do think we could maybe work out a plan to get info to our own surgeries. We are spread out all over the country (the world in fact).
I do think we could maybe work out a plan to get info to our own surgeries. We are spread out all over the country (the world in fact).
Fantastic!!I am bombarding the admin staff at both surgeries with stuff when it comes up. The lady admin we both met is looking at having a diabetes page on the surgery Facebook, one that is fixed at the top and doesn’t shift down over time, specifically relating to diabetes. So in the case of your This Morning video it would remain visible at the top of the Facebook rather than disappear down the listing over time.
This seems to be something that is working.
I wanted to talk about my bg monitor and bring it on but no time. And she said they were good for focused pts but can have a negative impact for those not so. But I'm happy to have got the low carb message across and zoe did back it up so given a lot of people hope today. I'm a very happy (and tired) bunny. Couldn't sleep last night! Couldn't eat dinner or breakfast! So nervous.
I had my meter ready to go on, my meter was the tool that aided me teaching remission. I discussed with zoe beforehand asking if I could bring in but not enough time for our slot so couldn't bring in sadly. I'm tweeting on Twitter, I'm posting on Facebook and I'm sharing my story to anyone who will listen. Always confirm meter essential, food diary and mysugr app.Hi Debandez.
I have just seen the video, congratulations on handling it so well. It must have been very difficult when both limited in time and by what you could mention.
Dr Zoe made it sound like it is relatively easy for a Type 2 to lose weight - not mentioning that it is the high Insulin (either natural or external) required to reduce the high Blood Glucose that actually increases the store of body fat. So that although being fat can drive Type 2 Diabetes, that in turn tends to make the patient even fatter and around and around it goes in a horrific worsening spiral.
What a shame too that Dr Zoe was able to be unchallenged on her statement that it is all about weight and give the impression that normal weight Type 2's can't benefit from LCHF. I noticed that there was no mention at all about monitoring one's BG readings with a meter.
For me as a TOFI, these are the two glaring deficiencies in the overall message.
Well done,
Ian
Dr unwin actually said at the x-pert health conference that the HCPs wont be able to give rubbish advice much longer as the libre is hereit's just a matter of time.
I don't see any success stories coming out whereby remission has been reached with low cal (anyone else?).This is what Dr Zoe kept reinforcing in my interview. She spoke of DiRECT results. When I popped on the internet to research it says remission can be achieved for over 2 years. So basically hba1c creeping back up until in diabetic range again. I would prefer my remission to be permanent and that's why I've changed my woe for life to #lchf. It might not be for everyone but it really suits me and so many more across the world.
Well done. I like the title of this thread as it is accurate and you are a touch bearer.
Update re my appearance on This Morning last week. Its caused quite a stir! A few ruffled feathers. So much so Zoe made a statement in her Twitter
https://twitter.com/DrZoeWilliams/status/1171388091443159043?s=19
https://twitter.com/DrZoeWilliams/status/1171394151503601665?s=19
I hope it was the wind and that she wasnt upset. I really do.
Passions are running high in the diabetic and medical community.
The interview has certainly raised awareness!
I've replied to all comments on any links to it I can find and pointed the people to this forum for help, support and info. I've PMd those who requested more info. It's had @100k hits on the this Morning Facebook page plus over 100 shares. Over 10k hits on the YouTube link. 1,300 hits on Ash trees house surgery thanks to @Listlad. Many on my own surgery fb page @Adelaide st surgery. And many views on my own fb page plus shares. Every little helps.
PR really is working.
Next goal is getting lots of us on that sofa. To show people this isnt just a one off here and there.
I don't see any success stories coming out whereby remission has been reached with low cal (anyone else?).This is what Dr Zoe kept reinforcing in my interview. She spoke of DiRECT results. When I popped on the internet to research it says remission can be achieved for over 2 years. So basically hba1c creeping back up until in diabetic range again. I would prefer my remission to be permanent and that's why I've changed my woe for life to #lchf. It might not be for everyone but it really suits me and so many more across the world.
Hoping that soon they start listening. They change the eatwell plate advice, they change the dietary guidelines for t2d. They offer us a choice which includes info on #lchf and dont immediately offer meds including statins. And they offer pre diabetic and diabetic pts blood glucose monitors and dont say you dont need to use them as they can make you obsessive! In.my opinion they are essential.
Keeping up the fight until this happens.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?