Low-Carb Diabetes Diet

Low carb diet
Low carb diabetes diet

Low-carbohydrate diets are one of the most controversial topics relating to diabetes diet. For one of the best resources relating to low-carb diets for people with diabetes, please visit:

Low-carbohydrate diets for people with diabetes are widely regarded as a healthy, effective way of maintaining low and stable blood glucose levels.

Carbohydrates are recognised as one of the fundamental influences on blood sugar levels, and many people with diabetes find that eating a low-carbohydrate diabetes diet helps them to control blood sugar better than other diet types, including those currently (2010) recommended by the National Health Service.

But how low is low when it comes to carbohydrates? How do carbohydrates affect the body? What is the counter-argument against low-carb diets for people with diabetes? How will low-carbing affect my weight? Find out the answers to all of the above questions by reading the following guide to low-carb diabetes diets.

What are good and bad carbohydrates, and how does this affect people with diabetes?

Every time a carbohydrate is consumed an increase in blood sugar levels occurs to a greater or lesser extent according to the carbohydrate. Amongst people without diabetes, the pancreas then releases insulin which causes blood glucose levels to fall by making cells within the body absorb the glucose, which can then be used to fuel respiration and all the metabolic activity of that cell.

Previously, carbohydrate has been classified into two groups, ‘quick sugars’ and ‘slow sugars.’ This was due to the complexity of the carbohydrate molecule and the belief that the more complex the molecule, the more time it took to digest and for the glucose to be released and affect the glyceamic levels of the blood.

More recent research has found this belief is not the case, instead that the ‘glyceamic peak’ (point of maximum absorption) of ingested carbohydrate is reached within half an hour of eating a carbohydrate and the only difference between different carbohydrates is the affect that it has on blood sugar level.

This is now known as the hypoglycaemic potential of a carbohydrate, a figure that is defined by the glyceamic index.

Therefore, the greater hyperglycaemia induced by the carbohydrate the higher its glyceamic index.

Carbohydrates and diabetes diet

Amongst people with diabetes, the body is unable to remove glucose from the blood stream as it does not produce insulin efficiently. However, by consuming less carbohydrates (or carbohydrates with a lower glyceamic index) the condition can be better controlled will a lesser requirement for medication or insulin injections.

By not eating carbohydrate, or by eating a low-carbohydrate diet, blood sugar levels do not change as significantly and less insulin is required to counteract the changes.  Advocates of a low-carb diet claim that lowering carbohydrate intake will allow lower insulin dosage and lower use of diabetes medication.

Your Comments
 
Can anyone tell me how many carbs constitute a low carb diet. I am type 1 and have always eaten pretty healthily. I know how many carbs I am eating as I count them to calculate insulin dosage, but I have no idea of what is considered normal, high or low.
Posted by maria b, Essex on Thursday, August 26, 2010
I had gestational Diabetes 3 years ago and followed the Diet guidance from NHS after giving birth to my son. But it didn't work for me. I put on weight and felt tired&hungry all the time. Then I found a book from library about Low Carb diet and Diabetes. I have been on Low Carb diet for 4 months ( plus Metformin x3 a day) and I have lost 2 kgs and I don't feel hungry all the time.
Posted by norayen, bathgate, west lothian on Friday, August 20, 2010
I am 'possibly' type 2. What I cannot get my head round is that half of medical science says High Carb and the other half says Low Carb - how do you know who to follow, and which is right?
Posted by John VIzer, W.Sussex on Tuesday, June 29, 2010
I have found the following comments very interesting. I was diagnosed with type 2 5 years ago and was put on insulin almost immediately. I always had a low carb diet before this point, my diabetes doctor and nurse insisted on a high carb diet which has nevert seemed right to me. As a result I am now approx 5 stone over weight and I am constantly having to increase my insulin dosages to match my weight increases. i feel positive about trying a low carb diet after reading other peoples comments. My only concern is knowing what amounts of carbs I should be taking?
Posted by Andy Brotherton, South Shields, Tyne and Wear on Sunday, June 06, 2010
I have Type 1 Diabetes and have 4x injections a day and was on 2x a day before that. I also have addisons disease (35, male) but have been put on a high protein low carb diet and haven't had such bad BMI in years. I'm getting really bored looking at eggs, bacon, sugar-free jelly and double cream - the type of foods that wouldnt help weight loss! How can I enjoy my grub!
Posted by GAZZA2012, Crieff Perth Scotland on Thursday, May 27, 2010
To all of you looking for a carb counter book, try one called - 'Beyond GI - Understanding Glycaemic Load' by Dr Fedon Alexander Lindberg. It lists most foods and their GI and GL and it explains how it works and why it is better for us diabetics. There are many other books, as I've found out. Dr Rob Thompson has done a lot in this area and written a few books. I was always told to eat a high carb diet by my diabetic nurse, but it just pushes the blood sugars up. Even brown bread has a high GI. My new diabetes diet regime has certainly worked for me. Good Luck!
Posted by Sue 32, North Wales on Monday, March 15, 2010
I have T2 diabetes and taking Byetta. I have changed my diet completely and now follow the GL plan. This lets me eat low carb veg and fruit but not too much starchy carbs like bread and potatoes. This change has helped me lose 2 stone since Christmas and my blood sugar readings between 4.1 and 6.1. My last HbA1c was 7.2...excellent for a diabetic I was told by my GP!!
Posted by Sue 32, North Wales on Monday, March 15, 2010
I was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes in January 2007 but none of my consultants have every said to me about going on a low carb diet to help me control my sugar levels, due to this my levels go from low to high, which I get headaches with. It's only from looking on the Internet that I have discovered this information. Up until yesterday I have always eaten lots of pasta, rice, bread and so on. Please can you advise me of some food that is low in carb or where I can get a carb counter book from?
Posted by julie, swindon on Wednesday, February 24, 2010
I have been trying this for 7 weeks, I have lost some weight, 11 pounds, but I'm really sticking! My blood sugars are still high, I have now been given metaformin on top of my insulin, to try and combat my insulin resistance. I feel tired, lethargic and totally fed up! I don't eat meat, and wondered if my body wasn't coping with no starchy carbs! I know I'm getting side effects from the metaformin, as in headache, nausia, dizziness etc. I have been on them for 2 weeks now. I'm approx 5 stones overweight. It's ok if you have the time to prepare and EAT the veg, but I can see me faultering when I'm busy! I'm self employed in my shop and sometimes struggle to get enough time to eat carrot stick & celery! Can't say I have been hungry, just weak! I clicked onto the vegetarian diet link and read this - "A well-balanced vegetarian diet, with an emphasis on low fat, high fibres, and high carbohydrates can be particularly suitable for diabetic patients." A contradiction?
Posted by heypapatooni, Durham on Monday, February 22, 2010
I am trying to control my diabetes with diet low cal, but I also have Myeloma (cancer of the blood) I was wondering if thie chemo called Valcade that I am being treated with will effect the diabetes?
Posted by jasmin, norwich on Thursday, February 18, 2010
I have just been diagnosied with type 2 diabetes and I haven't a clue what I can eat.
Posted by jenny grundy, uk on Wednesday, February 03, 2010
I can say for certain that a reduced carbohydrate diet works. I not only reduced my daily carb intake, but now also use low-GI/gl method of eating to help stabilise blood glucose. Many are put off a low-carb diet thinking that they cannot eat any carbs at all, this is not true, many of us still eat carbs as part of a well balanced diet, carbs are found in most everyday foodstuff that are both nutritious and fulfilling, it is more about balance and portion control. Reducing carbs, and following the low GI/gl approach to eating improves diabetes control overall, and is not a fad, but an eating plan for life.
Posted by noblehead, Cumbria on Sunday, January 24, 2010
I was diagonosed with type 2 before Christmas and am struggling to get my sugar levels down. I am tired all the time and have a thirst I cannot quench and each low carbs and fat all the time, I am losing weight which is good but even when I fasted my sugar levels are still very high. I started on 1 tab with breakfast and now take one with my evening meal and think I may have to take one at lunch too, if I cannot get my levels down does this mean I will have to start injecting or are there many different tabs to take before that?
Posted by Pammi2206, Manchester UK on Friday, January 22, 2010
I have also followed a low carb diet for 18 months and feel so much better with loads more energy. I am really interested when people say their BGs are in a range of 4-6 - does that mean their levels never peak at 7-8 at one hour?
Posted by mandy, cambridge on Friday, January 15, 2010
I am on a weight loss program, I just decided to be a moderate eater. I find that eating 3 moderate meals a day with fruit snacks in between results in weight loss. I eat either porridge , boiled eggs with a slice of wholemeal bread or boil in the bag kippers also with slice(medium) of wholemeal bread for breakfast salad sandwich or soup and a roll for lunch Low cal evening meal with fruit sugar free jelly and 0% greek yoghurt . As always I could do with support so would be pleased to communicate with anyone on the subject.
Posted by lordbrecon, wales UK on Thursday, January 14, 2010
Has anybody compiled a comprehensive list of low carb food items that I can use?
Posted by Habib, London on Monday, January 11, 2010
Unfortunately Reynor, this is Diabetes.co.uk which has NO connection with Diabetes UK, the charity I think you mean? We will still have to try and persuade them that there can be and there are alternative diabetes recipes that are also healthy!
Posted by cugila, Sutton Coldfield, West Midlands on Sunday, December 27, 2009
I was diagnosed with type 2 in March this year and had to go on to metformin immediately. This, and the recommended NHS diet seemed to work until August when my readings started to rise alarmingly, I am now also on Gliclazide (1/2 tablet in the morning) which doesn't seem to be having any effect. If I dont eat carbs my readings are good - but if I eat carbs they are very high and take ages to come down. I have always been slim, but have lost a stone when first diagnosed and would like to put at least 1/2 stone back on as I am now a size 6 which isn't me. I would definately like to try a diet with no carbs or very low carbs and welcome some ideas on what to eat and also put on weight.
Posted by Jan Bailey, Birmingham on Wednesday, December 16, 2009
I have had T2 for many years and for many years I have been advocating a low carb diet.I have suffered much comment from nurses, doctors and dietitians who seemed to think that this was the wrong way to control the BGs. Now I see a change and the low carb diet is gaining credence.
Posted by Keentishman, East Kent on Wednesday, December 16, 2009
Barry Groves book titled 'Trick & Treat' says it all and agrees with all the above. I control my diabetes by having only 60/80gms of carbs a day. It actually works. We all know that once you're on medication that's it. My daughter's a pharmacologist in internal medicine research and says that the reason new drugs are invented is because the masses do not take control of their own conditions and therefore drugs have to be invented to deal with their lack of discipline. Diabetes can be controlled but the patient has to help himself and the correct diet is not the one the government and the GP's tell us all to follow. Please whoever reads this get a Barry Groves Trick & Treat book and see what sense he makes! The best Christmas present you will ever have. Happy Christmas and low readings to you all. Mary Edwards
Posted by Mary Edwards, Chudleigh, Devon on Wednesday, December 16, 2009
I support all attempts to shed the light of reason onto this area. I have been low carbing for around a year and normalised my blood sugar levels with no medication. Also as a vegetarian it is quite possible to low carb without resorting to meat and fish.
Posted by Moogie1947, Surryey, UK on Tuesday, December 15, 2009
I was diagnosed this time last year with type 2 diabetes and did a lot of research. The low carb diet works for me and my diabetes. I have lost 2 stone, blood pressure has gone from high to low-ish and my blood sugar is in the 4.5 - 6.5 range and occasionaly higher. I also started aqua aerobics. Now I am fitter than I have been for years and I don't drop off to sleep all the time - no meds either!
Posted by maisiesgranny, crawley on Tuesday, December 15, 2009
I have followed a low carb diet for about 9 months now and discovered that any form of wheat makes my readings rise alarmingly. Therefore no flour, bread, pasta cakes etc. Rice also affects me. I found some rye crispbreads in LIDL which are 6 calories each and I have not noticed any reaction. I originally followed the diabetes dietician's advice and readings just kept rising so I did my own research and now I am almost always under 6-7.
Posted by Hazel Fry, Wales on Tuesday, December 15, 2009
Good to see that our charity is at last seeming to take low-carbing seriously and encouraging informed discussion. I lost all faith in NHS dietary guidance for Type 2's when I found that measuring BG before and after food strongly informed me of the bad effect on my system. I am sure that I am not the only one to feel this way.
Posted by Reynor, Cambridge on Monday, December 07, 2009
Have Your Say
Name:*
This is my Diabetes Forum username
Email:*
Location:
Your Comment* (1000 characters max)
 
Your email address will not be published. Your comments may be moderated. By submitting your comments, you agree to the Diabetes Community Rules.
Explore Low Carb Diets
Join the Diabetes Newsletter
Share Us
Follow Us